Trading Mark Melancon is one thing. It makes perfect sense even if it weakens the current Pirates. So what, right? I can’t believe the club is going anywhere after that gutless surrender over the weekend in Milwaukee. Melancon will be a free agent at the end of the season. There’s no way the Pirates were going to keep him. They received two young, hard-throwing left-handed pitchers in return and will have contractual control over each for years. Neal Huntington and his staff believe Felipe Rivero and Taylor Hearn have a chance to be really good, maybe even in Rivero’s case, great.

It is the trade or trades the Pirates could make today before the 4 p.m. deadline that have me nervous. If they move one of their ineffective left-handed starters — Jeff Locke or Jon Niese — they will get no complaints here, although what would they get for either? If they trade David Freese, Matt Joyce and/or Sean Rodriguez, fine, although it’s hard to think they would get much return on bench players, good as they are. Like Melancon, the three will be free agents at the end of the season. But under no circumstances should Huntington move one of his top prospects for a marginal starting pitcher in this decidedly sellers’ market. There’s no way I’m trading Harold Ramirez, Kevin Newman, Reese McGuire, Ke’Bryan Hayes or Mitch Keller let alone Austin Meadows or Josh Bell.

Huntington insisted the Pirates weren’t giving up on the season when they traded Melancon. Then again, what was he supposed to say? It’s his players who appeared to be giving up in the weekend sweep by a bad Milwaukee team that didn’t have Ryan Braun and, for the most part, Jonathan Lucroy. But there is some truth to Huntington’s contention that Tony Watson and perhaps Neftali Feliz are good candidates to close. The standings also say the Pirates remain in the playoff race despite their lost weekend. They are four games out of the second wild card, although they have to climb over three teams to get it.

But does anyone really like the Pirates’ chances? After watching their starting pitchers all season, especially Francisco Liriano, who was unimpressive again Sunday in a 4-2 loss to the Brewers and is 6-11 with a 5.46 earned run average? It’s so bad that Clint Hurdle is starting Locke Wednesday night against Atlanta and Ryan Vogelsong Thursday night.

Advertise with us

Does anyone really believe in this team after watching Andrew McCutchen and Jung Ho Kang struggle? The Pirates scored just six runs in the three games in Milwaukee against mediocre pitching and trailed after every inning.

Really, does anyone think the addition of one starting pitcher — short of Sandy Koufax — would make a difference?

The cost would be too high even if the Pirates could find another J.A. Happ at the deadline. The market for starting pitchers is absurd. The Miami Marlins traded the No. 2-ranked prospect in their system — first baseman Josh Naylor — to the San Diego Padres for pitcher Andrew Cashner. Sorry, if I can’t get too excited about Cashner. That kind of trade seldom seems to work. I think back to Oakland trading for Chicago Cubs pitcher Jeff Samardzija in July 2014, giving up prospects, including highly regarded infielder Addison Russell. The Athletics decided to go all in but barely made the playoffs as a wild card and were beaten by Kansas City in the wild-card game. Russell has become a top player for the Cubs, now the best team in the National League.

Huntington gets it. That’s why he hates giving away prospects.

“We’re paid to help the 2016 team win, but we’re also paid to make sure the 2017, 2018 and 2019 teams are in position to win,” Huntington said Sunday on his 93.7 The Fan radio show. He went on to say if he gave in to what other clubs are asking in return, “we would be deemed insane by just everybody except those that are the most diehard that you’ve got to give up everything tomorrow to win today.”

Advertise with us

Huntington cited Gerrit Cole, Starling Marte and Gregory Polanco as players he easily could have traded at past deadlines. He’s glad he didn’t. It will be shocking if he moves Meadows, Bell or any of his other highly regarded prospects.

“We shouldn’t do something insane for the detriment of this organization [just] to lunge to the finish,” Huntington said.

Maybe the Pirates will surprise by fighting back in the final 59 games and making the playoffs for the fourth consecutive season. But even if they don’t, they should start next season as one of the teams to beat in the National League. A fresh start should help Liriano, McCutchen and Kang, if he’s still on the team. The young pitchers Huntington likes so much — Jameson Taillon, Tyler Glasnow, Chad Kuhl and Steven Brault — will be a year better. Bell could take over at first base next season, if not before. Meadows should replace McCutchen in center field, perhaps as early as next season.

The Pirates clubhouse might not have liked trading off Melancon and might not like the team not making a deal to strengthen the rotation. But so what? They should look in the mirror. If those players had played better, the team wouldn’t — to quote Huntington — “be on the outside looking in” at the playoffs. Maybe Huntington wouldn’t have traded Melancon if the club was in better shape in the standings. Maybe he would be more aggressive going after a starting pitcher. Maybe.

“Our challenge is we want to be good for many years. The only way to do that is to have a lot of good young players in the system.”

Advertise with us

Makes perfect sense to me.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.