So you were offended by Gerrit Cole’s boorish behavior Wednesday night at the Penguins-Washington Capitals game? Get over it. No, it wasn’t a good look for Cole, beer in hand, apparently heckling the Capitals and pounding on the glass before a Consol Energy Center usher had to tell him to settle down. It wasn’t a good look when New York Jets center Nick Mangold did the same thing last month at Madison Square Garden during the Penguins-Rangers playoff series. Remember how a lot of us called Mangold a jerk? But, as Sidney Crosby noted during that series: “If he comes to the game and he wants to do that, he’s got his ticket and he can do what he wants. It’s not typically what you see, but, at the same time, I don’t have a problem with it.”
So you were disappointed that Andrew McCutchen had a peevish moment Wednesday after the Pirates lost to the Chicago Cubs, questioning a call by the game’s official scorer and calling for him to be fired? Get over that, too. Yes, McCutchen’s petty reaction was over the top, mostly because the scorer made the correct call, charging him with an error when he dropped a line drive leading to three unearned runs. But McCutchen apologized Thursday to scorer Tony Krizmanich. Everybody moves on.
You want a legitimate reason to be mad at Cole and McCutchen?
Their start to the season has been lousy.
They are disappointments 1 and 1A for the Pirates.
The team is fortunate to have a winning record (15-13) with a rotation that has been underwhelming, at best. Its starters are averaging just 5.4 innings per start, which ranks ninth in the National League. Of their 28 starts, only three — one each by Jon Niese, Juan Nicasio and Jeff Locke — were seven innings. Half were fewer than six innings. Just 13 were quality starts.
Read More
The starters were the big reason the Pirates were embarrassed by the Cubs this week in a three-game sweep at PNC Park. Cole, Niese and Nicasio combined to pitch 14 innings and allowed 16 runs, 23 hits and 12 walks. Cole’s poor start Monday night set the tone. He gave up six runs and six hits in 4⅔ innings with four walks. He needed a staggering 105 pitches to do it.
Where was Locke when the Pirates needed him?
You read that right.
Locke, who is scheduled to pitch Saturday afternoon against the St. Louis Cardinals, is coming off two strong starts and has been good in three of his five starts this season. He might just be the Pirates’ best starter at the moment.
Think about that.
Frightening, right?
Opponents are hitting .270 against Pirates starters, who have walked a league-high 73 batters. That is a lot of baserunners. Francisco Liriano will try to do better and stop the hemorrhaging tonight in St. Louis. Like Cole, he mostly struggled the first month. Like Cole, he is capable of so much more.
The good news for the Pirates is their offense has been better than expected. They have scored 138 runs, tied for fourth most in the league going into Thursday. That’s a surprising number considering how little McCutchen has contributed. His batting line of .229/.339/.450 is, to pick a word he used last season, mediocre.
Making McCutchen’s start worse is that his defense has been subpar, at least by his high standards. It’s not just the line drive that he dropped Wednesday. He allowed a ball to be hit over his head after a bad jump later in that game. He also failed to make a catch after a long run Tuesday night. Those plays are usually outs.
It’s fair to expect better from McCutchen.
It was exactly one year ago that McCutchen stood up after a loss to the Cincinnati Reds and took responsibility for his poor start to the season.
“I’m sick and tired of going 0 for 4. This isn’t acceptable,” McCutchen said, hitting .185 at the time. “It ain’t fun making right turns, especially when you’re used to making left ones. Right now, I’m not doing what I should be doing for the money I’m making. Right now, it’s under mediocre. It’s bad. But once it gets going, it ain’t gonna stop.”
McCutchen was right. He got going and he didn’t stop. His final batting line of .292/.401/.488 was a big reason the Pirates won 98 games and made the playoffs for a third consecutive season. He was fifth in the National League MVP voting.
I’m thinking better days are coming.
For McCutchen and for Cole.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.