Today could be the end of one of the most significant eras in Pirates history.
The Pedro Alvarez era.
Don’t hurt yourself celebrating.
Alvarez is this town’s most maligned athlete since Kordell Stewart. Some of the venom is justified. Alvarez never lived up to the potential that went with being the No. 2 overall selection in the 2008 amateur draft. He got off to a poor start that summer with the Pirates and their fans when his agent, Scott Boras, went to the final minute before the deadline before agreeing to a contract. Alvarez never looked quite right. He wore his hat down over his ears. He often looked overweight. He acted as if he didn’t care about his play. He showed no emotion when he struck out or made an error. Heaven knows, he did both many times.
But I’m thinking you’re going to miss Alvarez when he’s gone.
Today is when the Pirates have to decide if they are going to keep Alvarez on their roster and take him to binding salary arbitration for one more season before he can become a free agent, or non-tender him and allow him to become a free agent immediately. Each choice comes with a risk. If the Pirates tender Alvarez, they could get stuck with the $8 million-plus contract for next season that he almost certainly will get in arbitration. That’s a big number for a franchise that is tight with its money. We’re not talking about the Boston Red Sox here. It’s especially tough to accept with a player who has no position, at least none he can play capably. But if the Pirates let Alvarez go, they will lose his monstrous power, which produced 27 home runs last season and a National League-leading 36 in 2013. He can change a game with one swing of his bat. Good luck replacing that.
Read More
I wouldn’t want to be Neal Huntington and have to make that call.
But if I were, I wouldn’t tender Alvarez.
The Pirates are ready to move on from Alvarez. It has nothing to do with his work ethic. The other players praise him for being a good teammate. It also isn’t that Alvarez doesn’t care. You don’t have to throw a glove or break a bat in half to show that you are passionate about your job.
But the Pirates are tired of Alvarez’s errors on routine plays. He made them at third base in 2014 and at first base last season. He was so bad that Clint Hurdle regularly replaced him in the sixth or seventh inning for defensive purposes. It is tough to manage that way. Hurdle left no doubt how he felt about Alvarez by benching him for Sean Rodriguez in the wild-card playoff game in October against the Chicago Cubs and right-handed pitcher Jake Arrieta. It likely was Alvarez’s final game in a Pirates uniform. CBS Sports reported last week that he is open to a trade and thinks this is the right time.
The Pirates certainly want to move Alvarez. They have been trying to trade him for more than a year. Even if Huntington tenders him today, it seems unlikely Alvarez will be back next season. The team will continue to try to trade him. The problem is other clubs don’t want to give up something of value in a deal and also be stuck with that $8 million contract. An interested team could sign Alvarez at its price — not the arbitration figure — if he becomes a free agent. You have to believe a lot of American League teams would love to have him for $4 million or so.
Alvarez’s power is intoxicating.
Hurdle has said many times that Alvarez hits the ball like very few players. It looks different off the bat. It sounds different. It travels a greater distance.
So how do the Pirates replace that?
Highly touted prospect Josh Bell won’t be ready at the start of next season and might never become the home-run hitter that Alvarez is. Huntington probably will have to make a trade, if not for a full-time first baseman, at least for a platoon man to play with Michael Morse, who is due to make $5 million from the Pirates next season. He might have to give up Neil Walker or Mark Melancon in a deal. Those players, like Alvarez, have one year of arbitration left before free agency.
The pressure is on Huntington. If he doesn’t find the right replacement, he, too, will really miss Alvarez when he’s gone.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.