James_Taiwan: Do you see the Pirates non-tendering Pedro Alvarez today? And if Pedro is not the Pirates Opening Day first baseman, what do you see the Pirates doing with the position?

Jerry Micco: I think they will give him a tender. I know that goes against everything we're hearing, but I don't see how they can't pay him the $8 mil. Morse isn't the answer full time, and Josh Bell is nowhere near ready for the big leagues. Goebbert is a project and at best would be pinch-hitter type.

Sports Joey: I read that nobody is going to give up a haul for guys with one year left - Walker, Alvarez, Melancon. Makes sense to me, so not getting my hopes up for a snazzy trade. You?

Jerry Micco: No snazzy trade but no doubt, they are trying to deal any one of these three. Melancon may bring the most in a trade. But it likely will be prospects or bench guys who can help out or maybe compete to start. The Pirates need to restock some in the minors, so they would take decent prospects, especially pitching, if they can get it.

Advertise with us

James_Taiwan: Do the Pirates really enter the 2015 with a starting rotation of Cole, Lirrano, Justin Masterson (or other reclamation project), Charlie Morton, and Jeff Locke?

Jerry Micco: Looks like they will. But they would need to tender Jeff Locke first. The top of the rotation is fine. And people expressed the same concerns when Burnett was re-acquired last season, but that worked out OK. I think the key is if a Masterson type of pitcher is indeed signed or if Charlie Morton ever puts together a season with, say, 12 wins. Jeff Locke is a No. 5 at best.

Zack B: Assuming we non-tender Pedro, can we really go into the season with that guy at 1st base we got from Seattle? He is making way too much $$ and frankly, isn't that goOd.

Jerry Micco: Are you talking about Morse? Got him from Miami, actually. See my earlier answer. I'd bite the bullet and pay Pedro the money for next season. Maybe you get nothing for him when he goes free agent, but that's the risk you take. The Pirates window won't be open forever. Next year may be the last one where they will compete for the division title. You can still build through the draft.

Sports Joey: I was hoping that the Pirates could take a flier on Tim Lincecum. I read he's having a showcase in January when he's more healthy. Could you see that happening?

Advertise with us

Jerry Micco: I think a lot of teams will look at Lincecum, but from what I have seen the past couple of years, he's nearly finished. But if any team can take a guy and work with him, it's the Pirates. My guess is they'll kick the tires on him, but I think they would rather take a look at Masterson first.

James_Taiwan: Due to Neal Huntington's reluctance to part with assets, do you see Jeff Locke possibility opening up the season in the bullpen? I see the Pirates keeping Jeff Locke as an insurance policy. He is out of options, so they cannot send him to Indy.

Jerry Micco: Unless the Pirates think there are a couple of starters out there they can put into the rotation, Locke will be the No. 5 starter. Now, if they do that, he may keep Locke in the pen. I don't think that's where he'd do the most good, though. He's not a power guy and would only be used in blowouts.

WAR On The Rock: Any chance Coach 'duzzi is camping out in South Fayette with a tape recorder trying to get Drew Saxton's verbal?

Jerry Micco: Saxton's only a sophomore, but I'm sure Pitt and many other schools are looking at him. He's a very good QB.

Advertise with us

James_West Mifflin: Cueto turns down 20 million a year. David Price gets 31 million a year. Zack Grienke must be worth what, 35 million? How can the Pirates contend with that? Goodbye Gerrit Cole

Jerry Micco: They can't contend with that. Which is why you work with guys as much as you can to see if you can get them to bite a bit early and guarantee them early money, but maybe not as much. For instance, should they offer Cole 6 years at $130 million? It's below his market value, but it would guarantee him early high paydays. There will come a time when the Pirates simply will have to pay someone big, big money to keep them. And to me, pitching is the one thing every club has to have. Unless you are excellent at developing it in the minors and you can let guys like Cole walk after 2019.

James_Taiwan: If the Pirates trade Neil Walker or Mark Malancon, do you see them getting any Major League ready talent in return?

Jerry Micco: Maybe bench or borderline types. I think they'd get more for Melancon. My guess is they'd get decent to good prospects, but not top prospects. Unless, again, Melancon was the one traded. I think teams would like Walker, but he's still somewhat limited defensively and he's 30 with a balky back. Makes him less desirable than a true closer like Melancon.

James_Taiwan: What do you see the Pirates doing for rotational depth? Assuming the Pirates start the season with Cole, Liriano, Justin Masterson (other reclamation project), Morton, and Locke, who is the guy the Pirates turn to if there is an injury before Nick Kingham's Super 2 status date has passed?

Advertise with us

Jerry Micco: I really can't pluck any names out of the air, but there are always Vance Worley types available. And they'll get that guy for long relief in the bullpen. Guys like Radhames Liz come to mind.

LA Matt: Other than Price, baseball free agency seems to be non-existent this year. Are owners and GM's asleep?

Jerry Micco: Well, after tonight there might be more action. More guys would come on the market as free agents. And you also need to see where the big signings are and how much they get paid. Didn't the Tigers just sign Zimmerman from the Nationals for something in the range of $118 million the other day?

Sports Joey: Evgeni Malkin is really heating up, but Sid Crosby? Not so much. It is entirely possible that his best days are behind him -- he's not THAT young, was never a physical specimen, and he's been through so many injuries. Thoughts?

Jerry Micco: Crosby is having a tough season, no doubt. I don't think he's "done," however. He keeps getting different line mates and they are doing what they can to get him going, but it has been difficult. He's not a big guy, true, but very strong and has always been great keeping guys off the puck. That may be the one thing I've noticed this season that he's not as good at that as he has been. He's approaching 30, but I think he's got many more years left. At what level of play remains to be seen.

Advertise with us

James_Taiwan: Do you see Neil Walker in a Pirates uniform to open up the 2015 season?

Jerry Micco: If Jung Ho Kang is ready to play on April 3, then I do not. If he can't play until late May or early June, then I think they need to keep Walker. But I think they'll try to deal him and see if they can get something for him.

James_Taiwan: Do you see Rutherford blowing up the Penguins? How will the Penguins ever turn the corner?

Jerry Micco: I don't think he'll blow the team up, but I think he likes to deal so he'll keep his eyes open for the right trade. I think they need to get much more physical on the blue line, so you might see a deal for a more physical defenseman. And at 30 points, the Pens are right in the middle of the pack in the conference. And just 6 points behind the division-leading Rangers.

LA Matt: Tough game for Pitt last night. Their comeback fell short, especially when they could not hit any big shots down the stretch. A sign of things to come?

Advertise with us

Jerry Micco: Pitt has a nice trio in Young, Artis and Robinson. I like Jeter and Luther off the bench. Much more athletic team than last year and a team that can score more. Problem is, they are still not a big team and they are not as good defenders. I think they are going to be OK in the ACC this year, but probably not a top 5 team. Still, no ACC team will be able to come to The Pete and have their way with Pitt. Again, more athletic and offensively more potent.

LA Matt: Surprised that the Cardinals went after David Price hard? It tells me that, once again, they will be big players and will not rest on their laurels. So, the window for the Pirates maybe closer to closed than we think?

Jerry Micco: The Cardinals need pitching, shoot, everyone needs pitching. And they'll spend more than the Pirates. But the Cardinals will still find ways to develop guys and find the right kinds of free agents to be very good again. I don't know if they are going to be 100 wins good again, but they'll contend. And yes, I think the window is closing some now for the Pirates. They need to restock the minors over the next couple of years.

James_Taiwan: I don't see the Pirates finding a better solution than Pedro Alvarez for $8.1 million. I see the Pirates trading Malancon and keep Pedro. Your thoughts?

Jerry Micco: I've alluded to that earlier, yes, I think they tender Pedro even though that's not the common thought. I just don't see how they can't. And if you are going to trade a guy, it has to be Melancon. He has the most value. And you have Tony Watson to close in the bullpen.

Advertise with us

Ralph The Plumber: Jerry I got UNC pulling the upset Saturday V Clemson, any chance they crack the top 4 with the win?

Jerry Micco: North Carolina is a pretty good team. And will give Clemson a game. But they won't win. And if they do? Depends on if Michigan State beats Iowa. If so, Michigan State is in and maybe Iowa, too. Or, could Stanford sneak into the final four if they win the Pac-12, which is the toughest top-to-bottom conference in the nation in my opinion. I don't think even with the win Carolina is a final four team. But a real nice New Year's six team.

WAR On The Rock: Latest on Dr. Ben versus Dr. Mike?

Jerry Micco: Dr. Ben is practicing and Dr. Mike is looking on. I think keeping Ben in concussion protocol is the prudent thing to do. I can remember a couple years back before the Ravens when Ben said he was fine all week and then before the Sunday night game (eerily similar to this week) he said he couldn't play because of concussion symptoms. Can happen at any point.

James_Taiwan: I would love to see Jamie Dixon recruit a 7 footer. Pitt needs more height.

Advertise with us

Jerry Micco: He's trying, but those guys are hard to get and you are competing with the elite for them. Purdue has, I think, 3 guys at 7 feet or above.

LA Matt: WOW, a sports chat in December and not one Steeler comment or question! Are we witnessing the end of the world or just the realization that we can cancel the Super Bowl parade this year?

Jerry Micco: I, too, was stunned that it took 30 minutes to see a Steelers question. But baseball and college football are all topics worth discussing. Hockey, too. Anything, really.

James_Taiwan: Who do you see taking over as the set-up man if Tony Watson becomes the closer? I like Allen Webster, if the Pirates can straighten him out. However, he might not get a late inning role until 2017 if he works out.

Jerry Micco: If Webster gets back to his form a of a couple of seasons ago, then yes, a set-up role would fit him. But you are right, it may take a year. I guess they'll look at Hughes, Caminero or go out and get a bullpen guy. They are easy enough to find, and Huntington has proven very good at putting together bullpens.

Advertise with us

Zack B: If UNC or Floida wins OSU should get int he playoffs. They have by far, the best one loss. They lost to MSU, in bad weather by 3 measly points. If Iowa lose by 6 or more OS should get the #4 nod, assuming there is an upset to Alabama or Clemson

Jerry Micco: Ohio State will make it's case if Michigan State wins and either Clemson or Alabama lose. Certainly having the defending champions back in the final four adds some spice. I would still argue Stanford is very deserving.

Ralph The Plumber: Ok here's a Steeler question everyone loves, if the Steelers miss the playoffs is the heat under MT at least getting a little warm?

Jerry Micco: That would be three of the last four years, so yes, there will be some heat. But looking at the schedule preseason, I didn't think they could be better than 9-7. And they could still land there. The goal is win Super Bowls, but if every team has that goal, 31 fail every year. I think the Rooneys are committed to Tomlin, but they do expect to be playing playoff ball in January.

DNY: Why on earth would Ben be "frustrated" with the Steelers on the reporting of his concussion. He went on the radio and scooped the story himself, except he was dead wrong.

Advertise with us

Jerry Micco: Hence, the frustration. My guess is somewhere in between lies the truth. He may have heard what he wanted and the Steelers would absolutely prefer that Ben keep a lid on his injuries. We'll see how this one goes, but it wouldn't be the first time Ben and the team differed or miscommunicated on injuries.

LA Matt: Having been spoiled by numerous championship(Six Super Bowls, three World Series, three cups and even a Pitt national championship) by Pittsburgh teams over my lifetime, I have to ask who has the best chance to bring me another (and soon): the Pirates, Steelers, Pitt or Pens?

Jerry Micco: Probably the Steelers as long as Ben is healthy.

James_Dormont: It seems at times Ben looks like he'd rather be playing somewhere else. Too much pressure to win in Pgh? Say we trade him to Buffalo for 2 number one picks? Thoughts?

Jerry Micco: He's one of the best 3 QBs in the NFL. You ride him as long as you can. He's perfectly happy here. Has his whole family around him and his wife's from the area. No, he's not going anywhere, at least not now.

Advertise with us

LA Matt: With all of the Steeler experts roaming the streets of Pittsburgh, you would think that Tomlin would have lots of replacements for the incompetent people on his current staff. IT seems like none of them know who to play and that they spend too much time watching practices and game film rather than just watching the game on television?

Jerry Micco: No one coaches better than a Pittsburgh Steelers fan. No one. But that's why you have to love them. Passion, even if it's borderline insanity, means they care and they are engaged. My gameday chats, and I've been doing them for something like eight years or so now, are highlight reels for this. I enjoy them and the people who participate. We argue, we complain, we go back and forth. But you'd rather have a fan base like that than what you get in say, Miami. Or many other NFL towns.

James_Franklin: If you had your druthers would you fire James Franklin and hire Mark Richt?

Jerry Micco: Richt didn't get it done with much better players and no sanctions, at Georgia. Franklin needs 4 or 5 years at Penn State to see if he can lift that program up. It needs some work and it will take time.

James_Taiwan: Bill Cowher survived back to back losing seasons, so I doubt there will be a lot of heat on Mike Tomlin ths offseason. And don't forget he has taken the Steelers to two Super Bowls. Only a few active NFL coaches have taken teams to multiple Super Bowls.

Advertise with us

Jerry Micco: I agree with you. But patience is thinner today than say 15 years ago. Teams want, and need, those playoff games especially the ones at home. I don't think Tomlin's in any trouble if they miss this season, but the expectations are still very high.

Guest: Jerry PGH sports Mt Rushmore, Lemieux/Bradshaw/Clemente and who?

Jerry Micco: If you pick that group, I'd trade Joe Greene for Bradshaw. Maybe Tony Dorsett for his Heisman. Maybe Honus Wagner, the greatest Pirates player. No disrespect to Clemente, who is an all-timer and deserves his place there.

James_Taiwan: I know that drafting is not easy. The one thing that the Steelers front office needs to look at this season is better evaluating college linebackers. They have wasted a lot of picks on so-so linebackers.

Jerry Micco: Yes and no. Timmons, overall, has been a good LB. Jones is a work in progress, and Dupree is already showing that he could be very good. I mean, they did take LaMarr Woodley, too, and he was a very good player. For a few seasons anyway. I think they probably need more work on scouting CBs and safeties.

Advertise with us

LA Matt: Great chat as always! Thanks for taking up an hour of my work day!

Jerry Micco: Hey, thanks for taking the time. And I won't tell your boss.

Zack B: In ot firing Tomlin, maybe fire all the secondary coaches and secondary scouts? The secondary has been awful for a few years, and the FO and coaches cant seem to draft well for it, or seem to keep putting low quality caliber players out there, like Blake. Blake would not start for any NFL team.

Jerry Micco: The nosedive that Cortez Allen took the last two seasons is being felt now. Guys like Blake and Cockrell are nickle and dime players at best. They need one very good CB. I don't know if Golson, the 2015 pick from Ole Miss who missed this year with a shoulder, is any good. But he'll get a long look next season.

Jerry Micco: OK folks, time to get to some other stuff. Thanks so much for spending the time with me today. I appreciate all the good questions. I'll see you at noon next Wednesday and we'll do this all over again. Until then, have a great week everybody! Follow me on Twitter: @PG_JerryMicco