Today’s roster deadline, before which the Pirates must retain or jettison arbitration-eligible players, will bring the situation regarding the team’s future with Pedro Alvarez to a head.
By 11:59 p.m. tonight, the Pirates must offer a contract to all of the unsigned players on their 40-man roster. Seven Pirates are under contract for next season, meaning the Pirates have decisions to make on 33 players. Nine of them are eligible for arbitration, and three — Alvarez, Neil Walker and Mark Melancon — raise the biggest questions.
The Pirates have about $49 million committed to their 2016 payroll. The arbitration salaries could add as much as $45 million, if the Pirates tender all nine players, meaning the payroll could reach $98 million with the rest of their 40-man roster before they sign or trade for a single player. The Pirates opened 2015 at $88,278,500, according to The Associated Press; the end-of-season numbers come out later this month.
“We have the ability to bring all of those guys back if we decide that for 2016 and beyond that that’s our best club,” general manager Neal Huntington said on KDKA-FM 93.7 the Fan recently. “The challenge becomes, how do we build around those guys and how do we supplement the rest of the club as we look to move forward.”
If the Pirates don’t tender a player a contract, that player becomes a free agent, able to sign with any team — thus, the day has assumed the moniker “non-tender deadline.”
Arbitration-eligible players, those with at least three years of major league service time, have the biggest effect on the team’s deadline decisions. In arbitration, salaries are determined by comparing a player to other players at a similar position, with similar service time and similar performance.
Read More
Teams and agents negotiate on this basis, but if they can’t reach an agreement, they exchange desired contract figures on Jan. 15. A panel of arbitrators hears arguments from both sides in February and assigns the player a one-year contract at one salary or the other.
Because arbitration salaries are based on player comparisons, teams and agents can project them fairly easily. That also means they increase as the player accumulates more service time, regardless of their performance. Players projected to earn more than their performance dictates are sometimes non-tendered.
Which brings us to Alvarez, a difficult call. Alvarez, the second overall pick in the 2008 draft, twice hit 30 home runs, in 2012-13, and he hit 27 last season. But his inability to make accurate throws at third base forced him across the diamond, where he was, by most measures, the worst everyday defensive first baseman in baseball. MLB Trade Rumors, a baseball news aggregator with an arbitration salary forecasting system, projects Alvarez, who made $5.75 million in 2015, to make around $8 million in his final year of arbitration.
The Pirates have Michael Morse under contract for 2016 and recently signed first baseman Jake Goebbert to a major league contract. “We see him as a guy that will come in and compete to make our club,” Huntington told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette last week.
MLB Trade Rumors projects salaries of around $10 million for Melancon and Walker, who like Alvarez are in their final season of club control. Melancon had an exceptional season, and the Pirates could choose to capitalize on it by trading him and thus avoid paying 10 percent of their payroll to a pitcher who throws 70 innings in a season. The club and Walker have not come to terms on a long-term contract, and rival executives have said the Pirates are trying to trade their 30-year-old second baseman.
They also might non-tender left-hander Jeff Locke, who reached his first season of arbitration eligibility this year, but the lack of good options behind him means they will probably retain him. Tony Watson, Francisco Cervelli, Jared Hughes, Jordy Mercer and Chris Stewart are also eligible for arbitration and locks to stay with the organization.
Teams can non-tender players who aren’t eligible for arbitration as well, as the Pirates did with Chaz Roe last year. Catcher Tony Sanchez, the fourth overall pick in 2009, shortstop Pedro Florimon and outfielder Jaff Decker are out of minor league options and could be non-tendered.
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.