Maybe it really is true, that a team can’t win a division title in April and May, but it can lose one. The struggling Pirates just might be proof.

The team is a mediocre 18-20 after beating the Chicago Cubs, 3-0, Sunday to end a four-game losing streak, their third significant losing streak of the season. They are closer in the National League Central Division standings to the last-place Milwaukee Brewers (13-25), who have been so bad that they fired manager Ron Roenicke, than they are to the first-place St. Louis Cardinals (24-12 going into Sunday night). They aren’t going to concede the division championship to the Cardinals – it’s much too early for that – but, in reality, they might be playing for a wild card.

What’s troubling is the Pirates have been bad against division opponents, going 12-16. They are 5-1 against the Brewers but just 7-15 against the Cardinals, Cubs and Cincinnati Reds. It’s like we are re-living the Penguins season.

An optimist will point to last season and tell you the Pirates have plenty of time to become a winning team. They were 16-22 after 38 games in 2014 and went on to win a wild card for the second consecutive year. It is possible to overcome a bad first six weeks. The season isn’t quite to the quarter-pole.

Advertise with us

There are reasons to think the Pirates will turn it on, at least offensively. Their lineup can’t continue to be as bad as it’s been, ranking in the bottom-third of the National League in batting average, OPS, strikeouts and walks. Starling Marte has become a star, but the rest of the lineup has been hit-or-miss, mostly miss.

Too many runners are being left on base; that’s why it was encouraging Sunday to see Neil Walker and Marte get big two-out, run-scoring hits. Andrew McCutchen and Josh Harrison — 1 and 1A as team MVPs last season — are starting to hit. It’s nice to think Jordy Mercer will find his way, sooner rather than later. He was hitting .199 with a .508 OPS through May last season before becoming one of the best offensive shortstops in the league.

But the Pirates need so much more from Walker and Pedro Alvarez. Perhaps not coincidentally, the two have been mentioned in trade speculation because they are not expected to sign a long-term deal here and will be eligible for free agency after the 2016 season. No matter the reason, Walker’s power numbers are down – two home runs and 13 RBIs. He is on pace for nine home runs and 55 RBIs after getting 23 and 76 last season. Alvarez has been even more of a disappointment. It’s not just that he’s batting .219. He has only two multi-RBI games. The Pirates won’t be able to catch the Cubs, let alone the Cardinals, if Walker and Alvarez don’t start producing.

It’s also fair to think the defense and bench will be better. Walker, Mercer, Harrison and Jung Ho Kang took turns making errors on this past trip to Philadelphia and Chicago. Harrison has seven errors at third base after having a total of six last season at his variety of positions. He is too good of a defensive player to be having such problems. Alvarez continues to scuffle learning first base. He will improve, right?

The bench isn’t as good as last season. Sean Rodriguez has been a nice free-agent signing, a player who can hit and play multiple positions. But Pirates pinch-hitters are the worst in the National League with a .103 average. Corey Hart is 6 for 14, the others 0 for 44. It still makes no sense that the organization traded Travis Snider to Baltimore for a minor league pitcher and kept Andrew Lambo as a left-handed hitter. Lambo was 1 for 25 before going on the disabled list.

Advertise with us

The hitting and defense have wasted a strong start by the pitching staff, which has the third-best ERA (3.16) in the National League. Gerrit Cole, Francisco Liriano and A.J. Burnett have been exceptional, Burnett the biggest surprise of the season with a 1.38 ERA after seven three-hit, scoreless innings Sunday. But the Pirates are just 10-13 in games started by their Big Three. It’s a crying shame they have won only one of Liriano’s seven starts despite his 2.96 ERA and 1.01 WHIP, the best among the starters. Charlie Morton’s return to the rotation, expected next week, will come at a good time because Jeff Locke and Vance Worley have slipped.

The middle relief has been disappointing, but the back end of the bullpen is just fine. People love to complain about Mark Melancon, but all he does is get saves, nine in 10 chances after his latest save Sunday. Jared Hughes and Tony Watson are quality set-up men, although Hughes had a rough outing Friday against the Cubs.

Will the Pirates hitting and defense improve? Absolutely.

Will the pitching continue to be as strong? That is doubtful.

Will the team rally to win the division? At this point, the answer has to be no.

Advertise with us

How about a return to the playoffs? I’m still thinking yes, but I’m wavering badly.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.