The Penguins’ trade for Patric Hornqvist was a good one. Can we agree on that even though the Nashville Predators are happy with James Neal? Hornqvist has done what general manager Jim Rutherford promised as a physical, net-front presence.

The Maxim Lapierre-for-Marcel Goc trade also looks better and better for Rutherford and the Penguins. Lapierre’s game is built for the postseason. He has excelled in the first two games against the New York Rangers as an agitator and penalty-killer. Other than goaltender Marc-Andre Fleury, he’s doing his job better than anyone on the team.

But the best trade Rutherford made for the Penguins, by far, involved Brandon Sutter. As Carolina Hurricanes general manager in July 2012, he sent Sutter, defenseman Brian Dumoulin and the No. 8 pick in the 2012 draft to the Penguins for Jordan Staal. It has turned out to be a steal for the Penguins.

I’m not sure, but I think that might be damning Rutherford with praise.

Advertise with us

Dumoulin, just up from the minors, held his own in the two games against the Rangers. The Penguins used that No. 8 pick to select defenseman Derrick Pouliot, who is considered a can’t-miss prospect and, though injured, should rejoin the lineup soon after playing 34 games as a rookie in the regular season. But Sutter, at least for now, is the key addition. He has become a terrific two-way center, one of the Penguins’ best big-game performers.

Sutter’s defense always has been strong. He’s the son of a former NHL coach — Brent Sutter — and a member of one of hockey’s more legendary families. He knows the game. He understands positioning and stick work. That’s why, as one of the Penguins’ top penalty-killing forwards, he was able to help neutralize 10 of the Rangers’ 12 power plays in the first two games. He always is a threat to score short-handed; he had four of the Penguins’ six short-handed goals in the regular season.

But Sutter has become an offensive force five-on-five and on the power play on a Penguins team that really needs his help. He scored 21 goals in the regular season, no two more significant than his two in the final game at Buffalo, a 2-0 win that clinched a playoff spot. He scored the Penguins’ first goal on the power play in the 4-3 win Saturday night against the Rangers and set up their fourth goal by Chris Kunitz on the power play with an aggressive move to the net. In 15 postseason games dating to last year, he has six goals and three assists.

“He does it all,” an appreciative Kunitz said of Sutter.

Penguins coach Mike Johnston praised Sutter’s work on Kunitz’s goal, just his third in 35 games. Sutter took the puck behind the Rangers net and tried to beat goaltender Henrik Lundqvist with a wrap-around shot. Lundqvist made the save, but Kunitz was there to knock in the rebound.

Advertise with us

“He walked with authority to the net and took it to the crease,” Johnston said of Sutter. “It was a hard play …

“We expect a lot out of him. We expect that type of game. His compete level was really high. When he gets his compete level up, that’s when he’s at his best because he’s good defensively, but he’s harder on loose pucks in the offensive zone and he’s creating chances.”

Kunitz and Johnston mentioned how tough it can be as the third center behind Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin. Defense is required more than offense. Staal was fine in that role for a time, but outgrew it. Sutter “thrives in it,” Kunitz said.

“If you get a goal, that’s great,” Sutter said. “It’s nice to contribute. You want to score goals. Everyone likes to score goals. But by no means do you measure your game on goals and assists. If you’re playing well and doing things right, hopefully you get rewarded.”

That’s happening more frequently with Sutter, who has made a lot of hockey fans here forget Staal.

Advertise with us

Staal always will have a prominent spot in Penguins lore. He scored two of their more important goals against the Detroit Red Wings in the 2009 Stanley Cup final — a short-handed goal in Game 4 and the first goal in a 2-1 win in Game 6.

But Sutter has outplayed Staal and been more durable since the trade. He had 45 goals and 78 points in 209 regular-season games. Staal had 31 goals and 95 points in 176 games. Sutter’s game is even more appealing because he makes a fraction of Staal’s salary. Staal is two years into a 10-year, $60 million contract extension that was given to him by Rutherford. Sutter has a year to go on the two-year, $6.6 million deal he signed with Rutherford and the Penguins.

There was speculation this winter that the Penguins wanted to bring back Staal. Rutherford didn’t exactly discourage it by saying the team has missed Staal since he left. But a Staal return makes no sense because of his contract and how well Sutter has played.

Sutter admitted it is a “weird coincidence” that Rutherford followed him to Pittsburgh after trading him from Carolina. But he quickly said he isn’t worried about next season or beyond. He said he’s thinking only of Game 3 tonight against the Rangers.

“Through two games, we have to be pretty happy with how we played,” Sutter said. “We got the split we wanted. We all know we’re a good team. There’s been a lot of negativity surrounding our team from the outside, but we know what we’re capable of. We’re just going to go play.”

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.