CINCINNATI -- The best outfield in Pirates history was Willie Stargell in left, Bill Virdon in center and Roberto Clemente in right. Stargell and Clemente are Hall of Famers. Virdon was a Gold Glove winner with speed.

The Pirates’ second-best outfield had Barry Bonds in left and Andy Van Slyke in center. Bonds was the franchise’s best player since Honus Wagner. Yes, better than Stargell and Clemente. Van Slyke could run down balls as well as anyone. At least that was the word from former Post-Gazette Hall of Fame baseball writer Charley Feeney, who also covered the great Willie Mays in New York in the 1950s. It didn’t matter who played in right field because Bonds and Van Slyke covered so much ground.

The Pirates’ current outfield of Starling Marte in left, Andrew McCutchen in center and Gregory Polanco in right is quickly taking a prominent spot in franchise history. It already is the best outfield in baseball, although that’s hardly a unanimous opinion. Some prefer the Miami outfield of Christian Yelich, Marcel Ozuna and Giancarlo Stanton. Others like the San Diego outfield of Justin Upton, Wil Myers and Matt Kemp or the Los Angeles Angels outfield of Josh Hamilton when he’s drug-free, Mike Trout and Kole Calhoun.

Give me Marte, McCutchen and Polanco.

Advertise with us

Each made a play or got a hit Monday in the 5-2 opening-game loss to the Cincinnati Reds. In McCutchen’s case, it was a big hit, a two-run home run in the eighth inning off Kevin Gregg that tied the score, 2-2. McCutchen also had a single off Reds starter Johnny Cueto and would have had an RBI-double off him if not for a fabulous, diving, back-handed play by third baseman Todd Frazier.

McCutchen is a star. If he’s not the best player in baseball — many will tell you it’s Trout — he’s in the conversation having finished third, first and third in voting for the past three National League MVP awards. The only surprise about his day Monday is that he’s not normally a fast starter. March/April has been his worst month of the season with a .272 batting average, 16 home runs and 58 RBIs in 123 games. But those numbers were trumped by the ferocity in which he hits Reds pitching at Great American Ball Park. He has hit in 11 consecutive games here with a .409 average, 5 doubles, 1 triple, 5 home runs, 9 RBIs and 11 runs scored. The only bad thing that’s happened to McCutchen in Cincinnati was getting hit high in the back of the shoulder in 2012 by a 100 mph fastball from closer Aroldis Chapman.

“He has a comfort zone here to hit homers late, to hit big homers late,” Pirates manager Clint Hurdle said Monday after the game.

Hurdle was referring to a game last July at Great American Ballpark when McCutchen tied the score with a ninth-inning home run and won it with another home run in the 11th.

“He’s just a really good player,” Hurdle said.

Advertise with us

So is Marte, who appears ready to become the Pirates’ second outfield star. He was their best hitter down the stretch last season, batting .354 with 13 doubles, 1 triple, 8 home runs and 22 RBIs in 49 games after Aug. 4. He struck out three times Monday but hit a line drive to center field off Cueto that would have gone for an inside-the-park home run if not for Billy Hamilton, who made a superb diving catch to his right of a ball that was slicing from him. I would have bet just about anything that Marte would get a hit instead of striking out in the eighth inning with a runner on first, two outs and the score tied, 2-2. He’s going to get a hit in that situation many times this season.

Marte also made an outstanding play, running a long way into shallow left-center field to take a bloop single from Brandon Phillips. I never imagined I would write this next sentence: Marte and McCutchen chase down balls as well as Bonds and Van Slyke, who routinely turned would-be gap doubles into singles and would-be bloop singles into outs. Marte also has an arm much more like Clemente’s than Bonds’. So does Polanco, for that matter.

Polanco’s day Monday might have been the most encouraging part of the loss. He’s still a baby, still learning how to hit on the big-league level. It was nice to see him stay back on a pitch from Cueto and line it into center field for a single. It was even better to see him go the other way with a pitch from Gregg that would have been an RBI-double if not for a fine leaping catch by left fielder Marlon Byrd.

The Pirates have reached the point where there are no moral victories. The loss Monday hurt. But that doesn’t mean the play of their outfielders shouldn’t be recognized. It was a preview of bigger, better things to come.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.