Can we agree the system is pretty good for the ballplayers? Major league clubs have complete say over their players’ salaries for just three seasons. After that, the players can go to binding salary arbitration where they win or win bigger. After six seasons, they can become free agents and hit the lottery. The average salary in baseball this season will be $4.25 million. More than half the players will make at least $1 million. Minimum wage is $500,000. There’s even a daily meal allowance of $100.50. Not $100. $100.50.
But all this isn’t good enough for the players. I know it’s America and everyone is entitled to make as much as they can, but the players are ridiculous. It turns out they also want control over the teams’ rosters. It was one thing for super agent Scott Boras to criticize the Chicago Cubs’ decision to send his client — phenom Kris Bryant — to the minor leagues this week, although Boras came off as a crybaby who, for once, didn’t get his way. It was something much more despicable for the players association to jump into the Bryant case and threaten to sue to change the Basic Agreement they negotiated with the owners.
“Today is a bad day for baseball,” the MLBPA said Monday in a statement. “I think we all know that even if Kris Bryant were a combination of the greatest players to play our game, and perhaps he will be before it’s all said and done, the Cubs still would have made the decision they made. This decision, and other similar decisions made by clubs, will be addressed in litigation, bargaining or both.”
Please.
Spare me the heartache.
Bryant, 23, a third baseman, is considered a can’t-miss prospect. He batted .425 this spring with nine home runs and 15 RBIs in 40 at-bats. The Cubs called his demotion a baseball decision, not a business decision. That’s nonsense. It’s hard to believe the team doesn’t think he’s ready for the major leagues even though he has played just 70 games on the Class AAA level. But so what? The Cubs can call it what they like, but they made a smart business decision. If Bryant spends 12 or more days in the minors, the club will delay him from becoming eligible for free agency by one year — until after the 2021 season.
This was an easy call for the Cubs.
“Ersatz Baseball,” Boras called it in a text message to the Associated Press a few days before Bryant was sent down.
“MLB is not the MLB without the best players.”
Again, spare me the angst.
Pirates president Frank Coonelly didn’t return a message to talk about the Bryant case, but he and his management team must be getting a kick out of the fallout. They have been widely and unfairly criticized for the way they have handled their top young players, most recently Gregory Polanco last season. Despite tearing it up at Class AAA Indianapolis, Polanco didn’t make his MLB debut until June 10. As it turned out, that probably was too soon. Polanco flourished initially, then struggled, earning a brief trip back to the minors.
Andrew McCutchen, Pedro Alvarez and Gerrit Cole also weren’t called up to the major leagues until June. Pirates general manager Neal Huntington will tell you the extra time in the minors benefitted the players. But that doesn’t matter. Remember, we’re talking good business decisions. The Pirates were able to sign McCutchen to a long-term contract and hope to do one with Polanco. But Alvarez and Cole are Boras clients and almost certainly will put in their time until they become free agents and can sell themselves to the highest bidder. There is nothing wrong with that, but it doesn’t change the bottom line: Be glad Alvarez can’t leave until after the 2016 season and Cole after the 2019 season instead of, in each case, a year earlier.
Cubs fans should be happy for the same reason. Many are screaming they want to see Bryant now, but they are missing the big picture. As one clear thinker in Chicago put it, the fans are trading a couple of weeks of Bryant as a 23-year-old unproven player for, potentially, a full season of Bryant as a 29-year-old power hitter in his prime in 2021.
Major League Baseball’s stance is it doesn’t want to hear the MLBPA’s moaning. “A club has an unfettered right to determine which players are part of its opening-day roster,” it said in a statement. “This issue was discussed extensively in bargaining in 2011 and the principle was not changed.”
Baseball certainly doesn’t want to hear Boras’ opinion on the matter. The way he has manipulated the system has helped to drive player salaries to the point that all clubs — not just the poor small-market Pirates — have to make business decisions as much as baseball decisions.
“Look, I don’t think the Cubs’ decision on what’s going to happen to Kris Bryant is really any of Mr. Boras’ business,” new commissioner Rob Manfred said a few days before Bryant was demoted.
Manfred scored a few points with me with that comment. I just hope he enjoyed saying it as much the club owners enjoyed reading it.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.