Former Steelers defensive coordinator Dick LeBeau is a very wise man in ways that go beyond football. That’s why it wasn’t surprising when he described the team’s 24-20 win in 2004 at Dallas as a “Pyrrhic victory.” It lost nose tackle Casey Hampton and cornerback Chad Scott to serious right knee injuries in the game.
I thought about LeBeau Saturday. The Penguins’ 3-2 win against the Arizona Coyotes felt very much like a Pyrrhic victory. They lost defenseman Kris Letang to another concussion, perhaps, maybe even likely, for a significant period of time.
The Penguins can’t compete for the Stanley Cup without Letang, one of the world’s best hockey players.
That doesn’t mean the team won’t try, of course. It was able to come back to beat Arizona after Letang fell awkwardly and hit his head against the boards in the second period after a clean bump from the Coyotes’ Shane Doan. Then, playing with five defensemen because of Letang’s absence and salary-cap issues, it put out great effort to beat the San Jose Sharks, 3-2, in a shootout Sunday night, killing off a holding penalty to Nick Spaling late in regulation and a four-minute high-sticking penalty to Patric Hornqvist in overtime.
“It’s certainly amazing to see the character that the guys showed,” said winger David Perron, who showed plenty by climbing out of his sick bed to score a shootout goal.
The Penguins weren’t just without Letang. They played without Christian Ehrhoff, who missed his third consecutive game with what’s believed to be his second concussion of the season. They also were without Olli Maatta, who was shut down for the season in December with a shoulder injury. That’s three of their top four defensemen. The one still standing is Paul Martin, who, like Letang, is a terrific player. He, Ben Lovejoy, Rob Scuderi and Ian Cole all played more than 25 minutes against the Sharks.
Read More
“The whole team rallied in front of five defensemen,” Lovejoy said. “They knew we were going to be tired. They knew we were going to be playing a lot of minutes. I think our forwards did a great job of coming back and not turning pucks over.”
It really was impressive. But it also was just one game against a team that isn’t in playoff contention. Letang plays in every important situation and averages a team-high 25:29 minutes of ice time. He will be impossible to replace, should it come to that. He’s just like Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Marc-Andre Fleury that way.
Think about it.
Do you really believe a defensive group of Martin, Scuderi, Lovejoy, Cole, Derrick Pouliot and Scott Harrington is good enough to win the Cup?
You might guess how Martin answered that question late Sunday night.
“We’ll be able to find ways. We just need everyone to elevate their game.”
Martin talked about the injuries, sickness and adversity the Penguins have faced this season.
“Hopefully, that made us stronger. I think the guys we have in here are definitely capable of making a long run. I like our chances.”
Martin talked about taking on added responsibility — not to mention extra minutes — after playing 27:25 against the Sharks. He said it’s up to him and Scuderi, another veteran who has his name twice on the Cup, to lead the way.
“I think we’re ready for it. I like that kind of stuff. The pressure and that. The coach gets you out there and knows you’re going to do the job. I like that.”
Maybe Letang will be back, sooner rather than later. But the Penguins won’t take chances with his long-term health if there is any risk at all. It’s believed this was at least his third concussion. He also had a stroke last season.
Maybe Ehrhoff will be back. He was the Penguins’ most significant free-agent signing in the offseason but has been a disappointment, mostly because of his injuries. It’s hard to imagine him rushing back from a second concussion.
Or maybe I will be wrong about this Pyrrhic victory business the way LeBeau was wrong back in 2004. After losing Hampton and Scott in Game 6, the Steelers won their next 10 games to go into the playoffs with a 15-1 record. They beat the New York Jets in the divisional round before losing to the New England Patriots in the AFC championship.
The Penguins should be so lucky if they have to play without Letang.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.