Another day without a retirement announcement from Troy Polamalu. Another day of awkwardness at Steelers headquarters.
It’s never easy for a team to tell a player he no longer is wanted. The Steelers know that all too well. It was pure agony for them to have to release Hines Ward, James Farrior and Aaron Smith after the 2011 season. Each player was great here for a long time. Each helped the franchise win two Super Bowls and make it to a third. Ward could end up in the Hall of Fame.
As difficult as those cuts were, the Steelers are facing a much tougher one with Polamalu, a future Hall of Famer and one of the more popular players in Pittsburgh sports history. All indications are they don’t want him back next season because they no longer believe he can play. Their assessment is correct; Polamalu, who turns 34 next month and is signed for $6 million next season, appears finished after 12 years in the NFL. It is believed management has expressed to Polamalu exactly how it feels. It’s not personal. It’s just business. Time eventually runs out on even the greatest of players.
So what happens now?
Polamalu could make it easy on the Steelers by retiring. They appear to be waiting and hoping for that announcement. The problem for the team is it might not come. Ike Taylor, another longtime Steelers defensive back who almost certainly won’t be back next season, told 93.7 The Fan that Polamalu told him he is working out diligently and wants to play in 2015 even if it means joining another team. The potential for an ugly split is significant. If the Steelers cut Polamalu, it likely will happen before Tuesday when NFL free agency begins. In fairness to him, the team will want to give him his best chance to sign with another team.
Such a breakup with Polamalu would be just as jarring as the Steelers’ breakup with Franco Harris during training camp in 1984. A four-time Super Bowl champion who was under contract, Harris held out for a better deal. The Rooneys refused to give in and released him. It was one of the worst days in franchise history. Harris signed with the Seattle Seahawks and played in just eight games, rushing for 170 yards.
Read More
It was awful seeing Harris in that Seattle uniform during that 1984 season. It will be just as awful seeing Polamalu in another team’s uniform.
There’s a chance, of course, that no other team will sign Polamalu. That’s what happened with Ward, Farrior and Smith, who had a serious neck injury at the end of his career. Each slipped quietly into life after football. It’s what happened with four-time Super Bowl champion L.C. Greenwood, who was released by the Steelers after the 1981 season.
But the belief here is Polamalu will play in 2015, if, indeed, that’s what he wants to do. It takes only one interested team to make it happen. The Seahawks took a chance on Harris because he had been such a big winner and a Hall of Fame running back with the Steelers. The Kansas City Chiefs signed future Hall of Fame center Mike Webster in 1989 after the Steelers didn’t offer him a new contract.
As hard as it will be for us to watch, it’s OK if Polamalu wants to keep playing and ends up with another team. It will not damage his Steelers legacy. No one remembers that Harris finished with the Seahawks. At least, no one holds it against him. He still lives here and is regarded as a Pittsburgh treasure. He always will be remembered as a Steelers legend.
So it will be with Polamalu.
If Polamalu still believes he can play and still wants to play, he owes it to himself to do it even if it makes the Steelers uncomfortable. Maybe the assessment that he can’t play anymore is wrong. Maybe he’ll go somewhere and be great again. And if not? If he fails? He wouldn’t be the first player to stay on too long. Not everyone gets to go out on top the way Jerome Bettis did, leading the Steelers to a win in Super Bowl XL, then announcing his retirement on the field as the confetti fell on him.
It’s easy to think players know when it’s time to retire, but many don’t. Farrior and Smith used to talk about that. “I won’t know it’s time. They’re going to have to tell me it’s time and then they’re going to have to drag me out of here kicking and screaming,” Farrior said.
That day came for Farrior.
It looks as if it is coming soon for Polamalu.
This much we know for certain:
It will be a horrible day at Steelers headquarters.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.