Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford is right when he says he doesn't feel the need to make another move before Monday's NHL trade deadline. He's also right when he says his team is as good as any club in the Eastern Conference. He has done his job, wonderfully for the most part. Now, it's up to his players to play up to their ability and compete for the Stanley Cup. It's especially up to stars Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Kris Letang and Marc-Andre Fleury.
The idea the Penguins need Jaromir Jagr to win a championship is ridiculous.
For one thing, there was no way Rutherford could get Jagr from New Jersey because of the Penguins' salary-cap limitations. He was able to trade for winger Daniel Winnik Wednesday only because he convinced Toronto to pick up half of Winnik's relatively meager $1.3 million salary in exchange for an additional draft choice. Rutherford couldn't take on Jagr's $3.5 million contract even if he wanted him. Florida traded for Jagr Thursday, giving up second- and third-round draft choices. It's easy to think Jagr, at this stage of his career, at 43, isn't worth that give-back. He had gone eight consecutive games without a point going into Florida's game Saturday against Buffalo, the longest slump of his career. Maybe that's just because he lost interest playing for the lousy Devils. Maybe he'll be rejuvenated with the Panthers, who are on the fringe of playoff contention. Maybe.
Speaking of unrealistic trades, the speculation that has the Penguins interested in bringing back Jordan Staal from Carolina next season might make less sense than the Jagr talk even though Rutherford clearly likes Staal. As the Hurricanes general manager, Rutherford gave the Penguins Brandon Sutter, Brian Dumoulin and a No. 1 draft pick, which turned out to be Derrick Pouliot, after the 2012-13 season to get Staal. A wise guy would say it is the best trade Rutherford has made for the Penguins.
Staal has been hurt often with Carolina and done little when he has played. Making things worse for the Hurricanes, Rutherford gave Staal a 10-year, $60 million contract. The Penguins would be foolish to take on that financial commitment. Sutter has become the better player, anyway. He was the Penguins' second-best forward after Jussi Jokinen in the playoffs last season, which, I know, doesn't say much for Crosby and Malkin. Sutter is playing well again this season.
Although Rutherford lost the Staal-Sutter trade, he has done nice work since joining the Penguins after last season. He doesn't have to make a deal at Monday's deadline because he already has added to the club and made it a legitimate Cup contender by trading for David Perron, Maxim Lapierre and Winnik. Perron is just 26 and highly skilled. It's nice to think he'll be a top-six forward here for many years. Lapierre hasn't exactly overwhelmed anyone, but the Penguins gave up just Marcel Goc to get him. Winnik should fit in nicely on the third line and as a penalty-killer.
Read More
Go back to the offseason. All of Rutherford's moves have worked out well. Free agents Blake Comeau, Steve Downie, Christian Ehrhoff and Thomas Greiss signed salary cap-friendly deals and have stepped into important roles. Dealing James Neal to Nashville for Patric Hornqvist and Nick Spaling was a good trade for both clubs. Neal had 21 goals going into Nashville's game against Detroit Saturday; Hornqvist and Spaling have combined for 28. Hornqvist is the Penguins' hottest player with four goals in the past three games.
Maybe the best move Rutherford has made was giving Marc-Andre Fleury a four-year, $23 million contract extension in November. Fleury has never looked so relaxed and is playing his best hockey. Many still are concerned that he'll wilt in the playoffs again, but I'm not in that group. Fleury played well enough to get the Penguins to the Eastern Conference final last season. Malkin, Letang and especially Crosby were more responsible for the seven-game loss to the New York Rangers in the second round.
Rutherford is convinced the Penguins have enough forward depth to win a skill game or a physical game. He also believes the team will get postseason production from its third and fourth lines. Losing Olli Maatta early in the season still concerns him, but he says the defensemen on the trade market are no better than the ones he has and aren't worth what he would have to give up to get one even if he could maneuver a way to get that player under the salary cap.
"I think we have as much chance as anyone of coming out of the East," Rutherford said.
The man gets no argument here.
The Penguins don't need Jagr to compete for the Cup. They don't need anyone else. They just need Crosby, Malkin, Letang and Fleury to play like stars. The supporting cast is plenty good enough.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the "Cook and Poni" show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.