What a month it has been for coaches. Bill Belichick won his fourth Super Bowl. Geno Auriemma won his 900th game. Gregg Popovich won his 1,000th game. Go back to January. Mike Krzyzewski won his 1,000th game. Urban Meyer won his third national championship. What a fabulous start to the sports year it has been.
So who is the best coach out there? Not ever. That’s John Wooden. Right now. Who’s the best coach in sports this very minute?
Throw out Auriemma even though he’s the most dominant coach, by far. He has won nine national titles as the women’s basketball coach at Connecticut and, with his team the clear No. 1-ranked team again, almost certainly will win his 10th this season. The problem is women’s basketball, though much improved, still isn’t competitive enough for him to be picked as best coach. Twenty-three of Connecticut’s 26 wins this season going into its game Monday night at Tulane were by at least 30 points. Auriemma’s 900th win came against Cincinnati, 96-36. Two weeks ago, then-No. 2 Connecticut beat No. 1 South Carolina, 87-62. There is such a thing as too much dominance, you know? It makes the competition seem so lacking.
Throw out Meyer. The national title he won at Ohio State in January with his third-string quarterback was truly impressive and goes nicely with the two championships he won at Florida. But Meyer isn’t even the best coach in college football. That’s Alabama’s Nick Saban. I know, Meyer beat Saban head-to-head this past season when Ohio State beat Alabama in the national semifinals. I’m still taking Saban. He has won four national championships, including one at LSU. No program wins as consistently as the Alabama program.
Throw out Belichick. So what if he has coached in a record six Super Bowls with the New England Patriots and won four, matching the late, great Chuck Noll for most in NFL history? So what if his 22 postseason wins are a record and his 211 regular-season wins rank fifth on the NFL’s all-time list? Spygate and Deflategate trump all of it. What did the all-time winningest coach, Don Shula, call Belichick? That’s right, “Beli-cheat.” Belichick will never be regarded as the top coach even if he wins four more Super Bowls.
Throw out Krzyzewski … reluctantly. How do you a toss a legend who has won four national championships and been to 11 Final Fours at Duke and won two Olympic gold medals for the United States? The only knock against Coach K is Duke was knocked out of the NCAA tournament in the Round of 64 in two of the past three seasons. His most recent title came in the 2009-10 season. In this fierce competition, that is enough reason to bump him aside.
Throw out Popovich … very reluctantly. I can’t use the hasn’t-won-recently argument against him. His San Antonio Spurs gave him his fifth NBA championship a year ago. He took over the Spurs in 1996, which makes him the longest-tenured coach in American major professional sports. This season will be his NBA-record 18th consecutive winning season. It’s hard to pick against him, but I’m going to do it, anyway. I must be crazy. I’m sure you will agree.
So who does that leave?
Bruce Bochy.
His San Francisco Giants won the World Series in the fall, their third title in five years. That is nothing short of a dynasty in today’s era of parity. In the past 50 years, only the New York Yankees, who won four championships from 1996-2000 and went to the World Series in 2001, and the Oakland Athletics, who won three in a row from 1972-74, have done it better in baseball. Feel free to give most of the credit to Giants stars Madison Bumgarner, Pablo Sandoval, Hunter Pence and Buster Posey. Just make sure you save a little love for the manager. Bochy isn’t just the best in the baseball business. He stands above all of the other iconic coaches.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m.-2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.