Forget the final results, that the Pirates lost two of their three binding-salary arbitration cases with their players, the latest loss Thursday to Pedro Alvarez. The team’s strategy was dubious from the start. There really is no need for contract negotiations to get to the arbitration stage. That’s why there are so few cases each year.
The Pirates reached agreement with nine of their 12 arbitration-eligible players but couldn’t do deals with Alvarez, Neil Walker and Vance Worley. The team made what it called its best offer to the players at the filing deadline, then elected not to negotiate further. That was a mistake. It should have continued negotiating up until the arbitration case date. Walker lost after his hearing. Worley and Alvarez won after theirs. The Pirates ended up saving $50,000, but might have lost much more.
The arbitration process is flawed. The player submits one figure for his salary, the team another. A panel of three arbitrators listens to presentations from each side and picks one of the two numbers. That is the player’s salary for the season.
It’s hard to say the players are losers, no matter the outcome. Players almost always win or win bigger. In Walker’s case, he must play for $8 million this season – a raise from his $5.75 million salary in 2014 – instead of the $9 million he requested. We all should be such losers.
Alvarez gets a $1.5 million raise – from $4.25 million last season to $5.75 million – despite having a lousy season in 2014. The Pirates’ number was $5.25 million. Worley gets $2.45 million instead of the club’s offer of $2 million. He made $527,500 last season.
Only in baseball.
Read More
Can we agree there’s absolutely no reason to feel sorry for the players?
But that doesn’t mean the arbitration process is easy for them. It is not. It is a negative, destructive process. No one likes to be criticized by his employer. No one likes to be told he isn’t as good at his job as he thinks he is. It doesn’t matter if you make $40,000 a year or $10 million a year.
“Our goal in hearing is not to tear down the player, but to simply explain why the club’s submitted salary is a more accurate salary for the player based on other comparable past and current players than the player’s submitted salary,” general manager Neal Huntington wrote via email Thursday.
It’s just business, right? Of course, it’s just business. That’s until you are the one being criticized. Then it’s personal.
Alvarez sat in on his hearing Wednesday. Walker and Worley also sat in on theirs. It’s hard to believe the players thought it was just business. It wasn’t a good sign that Alvarez, who, after the starting pitchers, figures to be the biggest key to the season as he adjusts to first base and tries to find the beautiful, prodigious swing that produced 36 home runs and 100 RBIs in 2013, declined to discuss the process Thursday after reporting early to spring training.
“While we do recognize the chance for lingering hard feelings, we hope the significant raise received by each player – even in an arbitration loss – the environment we work to create for our players in general and the culture in our clubhouse will partially or wholly offset the challenge of a hearing,” Huntington wrote.
Huntington probably is right. Alvarez, Walker and Worley are professionals. All three know they will play this season for their next contract. Alvarez and Walker are at the point in their career where they are playing for huge dollars. Each is eligible for arbitration again next February before becoming a free agent after the 2016 season. It will be a surprise if the Pirates sign either to a long-term contract extension.
But it seems as if the Pirates would have been smart to try harder to negotiate a settlement with Alvarez, Walker and Worley. If they had split the difference between the arbitration numbers with each player, they would be paying out a total of $16.25 million to the three. As it is, they will pay them $16.2 million.
An extra $50,000 would have been well worth it to avoid the ugly arbitration process.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.