The James Franklin era at Penn State came crashing down in a span of just over two weeks. Jay Paterno would know better than most what that feels like.
His father, Joe Paterno — the winningest coach in FBS college football history who died in 2012 — was fired in the middle of the 2011 season, just four days after his former assistant coach, Jerry Sandusky, was arrested on charges of sexually abusing boys for many years.
“The hardest part is that it happened so quickly,” Paterno told the Post-Gazette on Monday, a day after Franklin was let go. “Certainly, what happened back in November of 2011 happened really quickly.
“It happened so fast you can't even get your bearings underneath you. All of a sudden, you go from, ‘I’m the head coach at Penn State’ to tomorrow morning, when I wake up, ‘I have nowhere to go.’ ”
Paterno, now a Penn State trustee, would not comment on whether he agreed with the decision to fire Franklin and said the board had no role in the choice. But he questioned the timing, as Penn State plays at Iowa on Saturday and will have a bye the following week.
“Certainly, next Sunday would have been a little bit more advantageous in that we have an off week,” said the former player and assistant coach at Penn State. “And it could have allowed for a couple of days to kind of let this thing settle in before game week.
Read More
“But right now, you've got [interim coach Terry Smith] trying to get his feet up underneath him, the team trying to rally around Terry and everything, but dealing with some change before they head out to Iowa, which is not an easy place to play.”
Penn State will pay Franklin a nearly $50 million buyout thanks to the 10-year extension he was given in 2021, which Paterno said he had concerns with at the time.
“It had nothing to do with who the coach was,” he said. “It was a reflection of where the marketplace is, where schools are guaranteeing every dollar on a contract at the same time coaches’ buyouts to leave are a fraction of that, so there's a power imbalance that exists that gives coaches a lot of leverage.”
For Paterno, the decision to fire Franklin after a 3-3 start to the season, following three seasons with 34 combined wins, showcases the “modern reality of the marketplace.”
“The money has gotten so big, the players are making so much money — we've really professionalized this sport to an extent,” Paterno said. “And the offseason expectations got to the point where they were so high that I think it became almost unrealistic to make everybody happy.”
Paterno said he completely understands criticism of the university’s decision to fire Franklin and pay his buyout — the second-largest in college football history — in light of the news from earlier this year that the university will close seven commonwealth campuses.
“That's one of the reasons why, when you talk about 10-year contracts and guaranteeing every dollar on the contract, it's a power imbalance,” Paterno said. “But it also ... puts you at risk for having to pay these things out.”
He noted, as did athletic director Pat Kraft, that the money for Franklin’s buyout will come out of the athletics budget and not a budget that “would have been available to keep commonwealth campuses open.”
“I know that’s small consolation to people that are in the communities where the campuses were closed, but that's kind of just the way the accounting works in these situations,” Paterno said.
Paterno’s understanding was the buyout would be paid out over the length of Franklin’s contract, which extends until 2031.
According to the USA Today coaching salary database, more than 30 college coaches have buyouts greater than $20 million — and that doesn’t include coaches whose buyouts aren’t publicly available.
“I think it's absolutely crazy that we're guaranteeing that kind of money on these contracts,” Paterno said. “I think there was a real lack of leadership from a generation of ADs and administrators and presidents and chancellors — and it’s still going on — that refused to say, ‘Look, we're not going to guarantee you that kind of money.’ ”
Penn State now faces what Paterno called “the hardest part of their schedule,” six consecutive Big Ten games to close the season. They’ll need to win three of them to reach bowl eligibility.
He played with Smith, the interim coach, at Penn State and spoke highly of the Gateway High School graduate and former WPIAL coach.
“I know that he's well respected by the kids in the locker room,” Paterno said, “so I would anticipate there's going to be some energy and excitement toward playing for him.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.