For someone whose coaching career has been defined by a series of smoke and mirrors — beating the bad teams, hardly ever beating the good ones — James Franklin’s exit left little doubt.

It was time.

Penn State, with football goals a mile wide and unprecedented resources allocated toward this season, had no choice.

On Sunday, a day after Franklin’s team delivered another dose of ignominious history by suffering a 22-21 loss to Northwestern at Beaver Stadium, the university announced associate head coach Terry Smith would serve as interim head coach for the remainder of the season.

Advertise with us

The price tag of Franklin’s buyout is believed to be around $50 million, which can’t possibly sit well with Penn State leaders.

At the same time, it’s their fault for believing Franklin was anything more than this: a terrific recruiter but a coach whose in-game struggles left much to be desired, therefore leaving Penn State on the cusp of its over-arching goal of greatness.

College football has undergone massive changes, and it looked like Penn State was actually positioned to leverage them, landing a trio of talented wide receivers and an athletic linebacker in the transfer portal. Meanwhile, the Nittany Lions did well to retain plenty of talented players, the group believing it could do something special this season.

Franklin couldn’t put it all together.

Worse, the cycle continued, a somewhat acceptable loss to Oregon snowballing into maybe the ugliest loss in program history, despite Franklin saying it could not, should not and would not happen.

Advertise with us

Penn State became the first top-10 team to lose to an 0-4 squad in 40 years, then this week became the first team three decades to drop back-to-back games as a favorite of at least 20 points.

Not exactly the history Penn State was envisioning when it made Jim Knowles the highest-paid defensive coordinator in college football, or when it ponied up the funds to obtain Trebor Pena, Devonte Ross, Kyron Hudson and Amare Campbell.

Franklin lost his team and ultimately his job, departing with a boatload of wins against mediocre teams and a wretched history of performance against the good ones.

It should teach Penn State a lesson, honestly.

Maybe a few of them.

Advertise with us

In this era of college sports — which the university is still trying to navigate effectively — it’s no longer about obtaining the most high school talent.

It’s adding college players, but it’s also about execution on Saturdays, an area in which Franklin consistently struggled, despite Penn State seemingly thinking he’d find a stash of magic beans and improve.

Yeah, no.

Those flaws were magnified during the colossal toe-stubbing at UCLA, with Franklin’s team clearly unprepared for an onside kick, a punt that drained valuable seconds off the clock and so much more.

Think through more of Franklin’s tenure, and it’s not hard to find similar stuff in games the Nittany Lions really needed to win.

Advertise with us

Costly or silly penalties. Frustrating schematics, much like the end-around that was called by offensive coordinator Andy Kotelnicki on the final play of the loss to UCLA. Butchering timeouts and late-in-half strategy. Failures to find key stops.

Over the past handful of years, Franklin allowed Penn State to become Charlie Brown in the oft-cited Peanuts cartoon, guiding the Nittany Lions to enough success to put the football on the ground, only to have top-10 teams snatch it away.

Franklin went 4-21 against them those during his tenure, which is so ugly that it almost feels fake.

It’s not.

Franklin spent 11-plus seasons at Penn State and posted a 104-45 record, winning a Big Ten championship, going to seven New Year’s Six bowl games and an appearance last year in the College Football Playoff.

Advertise with us

Franklin coached 18 All-Americans and 59 NFL draft picks, but he also presided over the consistent stench of underachievement, how the Nittany Lions would tease but never found a way to deliver in the most crucial moments.

That’s on the coach.

As much as Penn State’s goofy usage of Kaytron Allen (until Saturday), the egregious lack of receiving talent last year or Drew Allar lacking big-game success have defined the Nittany Lions of late, it all funnels to the top.

Franklin was paid a lot of money to put it all together. He did not.

And now Penn State has egg on its face.

Advertise with us

It should be a lesson about the massive, 10-year, $85 million extension Franklin got in 2021. Silly then. Ridiculous now. Think those types of talks will be different with the next coach? You’d hope so.

It should also be a lesson to other college programs thinking about extending coaches without reasonable exit strategies, protecting themselves against this sort of thing by any means possible.

For while Penn State was left with no choice but to fire Franklin, a Pirates source confirmed that money doesn’t grow on trees.

The whole thing is a gigantic black eye for Penn State after a period of relative stability, Franklin steering the university out of the Bill O’Brien mess and seemingly toward better things, instead topping out with a conference title and Rose Bowl appearance in 2016.

If there’s any redeeming value here — OK, there’s no value in paying $50 million to show you care about the football program — it’s that Penn State now has the opportunity to do something different, to pursue and hire a coach who can handle big games, who can do more than recruit and who can navigate the ever-changing era of college football in ways Franklin could not.

It’s wild to acknowledge considering the price tag, but it was absolutely time.