After Saturday’s 31-26 loss to Minnesota, James Franklin was asked about Penn State’s inability to mount a consistent pass rush.
The Nittany Lions finished the game with just one sack, while Golden Gophers quarterback Tanner Morgan picked the defense apart, completing 18 of his 22 passes for 339 yards and three touchdowns.
Franklin, though, defended his defensive line, chalking up the low sack number to Minnesota’s offensive scheme more than anything.
“Again guys, they very rarely threw the ball in a traditional throwing game,” Franklin said. “They weren’t dropping back and throwing the ball. I’d have to go back and look at the tape, but I bet out of the throws that he threw, 75% of them were RPOs, one-man read coming out. You don’t get sacks on them.”
Upon review, it is true that the Golden Gophers’ scheme was vital in slowing down Penn State’s pass rushers. Take, for instance, Minnesota’s first pass of the game:
The read on most run-pass options is the linebackers. On this particular run fake, all three move forward, vacating the middle of the field and allowing an open area for Morgan to complete to wide receiver Rashod Bateman.
Read More
But, in reality, the linebackers weren’t going to be the ones to cause consistent pressure on Morgan anyways.
Watch defensive end Shaka Toney on the near side of the formation. On the run fake, he has to stay even with the line of scrimmage in case of a run. If he gets upfield too far and Morgan decides to hand it off, the offensive lineman can just run Toney upfield, and he’s already out of the play.
So, Toney sticks inside to protect against the run, and by the time Morgan pulls it, Bateman’s already open, the throw comes out quickly and the Nittany Lions never really stand a chance of getting to the quarterback.
Here’s another good look at it:
Again, Toney has to respect the run. Safety Jonathan Sutherland moves down into the box for some extra run support, and on the fake, he steps up. If he stays home at the snap, he’s directly in Morgan’s throwing lane, but it just isn’t that simple.
All of this works because the Golden Gophers were a run-first team in all of their other games this season. Yes, Morgan and his trio of receivers have performed well, but in the previous three games, Minnesota’s three running backs ran for over 900 yards combined.
So that was Penn State’s primary concern coming into Saturday, and the Golden Gophers used it to their advantage.
And when Minnesota wasn’t running an RPO, they were running one or two-man routes with maximum pass protection to give Morgan as much time as possible.
This isn’t an RPO, but the run fake makes Toney pause on the far side of the formation. Linebacker Micah Parsons runs laterally before getting into the pass rush. By the time the Nittany Lions do realize it’s a pass, they still have to maneuver around seven Minnesota pass blockers. All of it adds up to just enough time for Morgan to find Bateman over the middle for a huge play.
And look at how close Toney ends up to making the sack. If he doesn’t have to pause to respect the run, he might get there.
Basically, it seems like this was somewhat of a perfect game plan to protect against what has been a very good Penn State pass rush.
Look what happened late in the game when there wasn’t a run fake and the Nittany Lions could pin their ears back.
It’s a matter of Penn State recognizing the plays as they happen. The Nittany Lions do have to stay home for those run fakes, but it’s on the unit as a whole to disrupt the pass attempts, force incompletions and get the opponent in third-and-longs, when passes are more predictable and the pass rush can get a better, more confident jump on things.
Coverage concerns
Now, the other contributing factor to Morgan’s stat line was that his receivers were running open down the field all game.
That really started on the first touchdown.
The Golden Gophers line up, check with the sideline and opt for this two-man route. Even if safety Lamont Wade doesn’t blitz from the edge, they’re going to run this play, and they’re probably going to throw it deep to Bateman anyways.
But now, Wade blitzes, cornerback John Reid bumps inside to cover the slot receiver and safety Garrett Taylor is left to try to sprint over to Bateman and cover the go route.
It’s a tough ask for Taylor. He doesn’t get there in time to knock the ball away, and his angle is just a little too aggressive to make the tackle.
That’s one you can mostly chalk up to Minnesota having a great play call for the defense the Nittany Lions ran.
Here, the play action buys Morgan some extra time, but again it’s just a two-man route. Bateman has been running slants and in-routes all game long, but this time he just breaks it off to the outside. Castro-Fields is completely fooled, Sutherland doesn’t get all the way over, and again it’s a big gain.
That one could be forgiven too, though. Castro-Fields got set up all game. You would like for the secondary to be able to recognize the route, but it’s a tough cover on a very good receiver.
There were ones that weren’t so forgivable.
This was on the Golden Gophers’ final touchdown drive. It’s a rare time when they ran a four-man route and opted for less protection.
On replay, Morgan looked off the safeties, staring to the left after the snap before going to the right and finding Bateman over the top.
The problem with that is that Sutherland, the safety, doesn’t have any other routes on his side of the field. It’s just Bateman.
With how Castro-Fields stays in a backpedal after Bateman gets beyond him, it seems like Castro-Fields expected Sutherland to be there. This was a huge third-down conversion to set up a score.
Franklin talks all the time about playing well on first and second down to set up tough third downs for opponents. Penn State did that on this set of downs, but it couldn’t get off the field.
When you look at the game as a whole and how it played out, the Nittany Lions’ secondary just could not stop Minnesota’s receivers. They got beat in man. They got beat in zone. Sometimes they had pretty good coverage and the receiver just made a good play. Sometimes they missed assignments and left guys open. Altogether, though, Penn State’s secondary can’t be happy with the 339 yards and three touchdowns they gave up to Morgan.
Red zone woes
Franklin lamented his team’s execution in the red zone after Saturday’s loss. The week prior, the Nittany Lions’ success in the red zone was a major pride point for them.
Before Saturday, Penn State had failed to score in the red zone just twice, and one of those was because it knelt the ball to kill the clock.
Against the Golden Gophers, the Nittany Lions were 4-for-6, which doesn’t sound awful, but considering the final score, it’s less than ideal.
The first, and possibly most memorable, empty trip inside the 20, came early in the fourth quarter. Minnesota had just scored to go up 31-19, and Penn State promptly drove all the way down the field, getting big, chunk plays on both the ground and through the air.
And then:
It’s easy to criticize play calling when the plays aren’t successful. If any of these four plays score, then nobody bats an eye, but they don’t score.
Tight end Pat Freiermuth, who was dynamite all game, didn’t get a look. The final play was left up to a 50-50 ball to Hamler, who, for all his strengths, is still a 5-foot-9 mostly-slot receiver.
However, the Nittany Lions almost certainly felt they’d be able to punch it in on the ground, especially since they had run it successfully already that drive. But things tighten up in the red zone. The blocks weren’t there, the holes didn’t open up, and Penn State came away without points.
The second failed red zone trip was the last drive of the game:
This was the second down play. Running back Journey Brown runs an angle route from the backfield. Wide receiver Daniel George’s job is simply to get in the way of the secondary players on that side of the field, but he does so a little too aggressively.
15-yard penalty, and two plays later…
There’s plenty of talk about penalties for these two plays. Some felt George didn’t interfere. Some felt wide receiver Jahan Dotson or Freiermuth were interfered with on the interception.
But the point is that George doesn’t have to straight up block his man. He just has to run in front of him, really, to give Brown the necessary space to make a play.
Even earlier in the game, Penn State squandered another chance in the red zone and had to settle for a field goal.
This play came after an unforced penalty, as the Nittany Lions were hit with a delay of game on 3rd-and-3. Then, Sean Clifford short-hops a throw in to Freiermuth, who likely would have had the first down, and suddenly a promising drive ends in three points instead of seven.
If any of these three chances in the red zone go a different way, then the entire game is different.
The margin for error in that part of the field is so small. Penn State didn’t execute like it normally does, and that’s why Franklin pointed to it as a big factor in the Nittany Lions’ loss.
Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.