The last question had been asked, and James Franklin was about to leave his news conference on Tuesday.

But once he had given his final answer, he had one more point to make.

After No. 9 Penn State (8-1 overall, 5-1 Big Ten) lost to No. 7 Minnesota on Saturday, Franklin was asked a series of questions about some of the coaching decisions he made in the game.

Specifically, he was asked about going for a two-point conversion while trailing, 24-19, which was a decision that ultimately failed. A quick Twitter search yields even more questioning of Franklin, from play-calling to time management.

Advertise with us

But Franklin took issue with that particular line of questioning.

“At the end of the day, here is the thing I struggle with,” Franklin said Tuesday. “A lot of these decisions are not clear-cut. There's some that are. But there's a lot that are not clear-cut. It's a gut feel. And what I struggle with is when those decisions — and again, I already told you the two-point chart said go for it and the analytics stuff said go for it.

“But then opinions are stated as facts. And I struggle with that. I struggle with things that go on when it comes to discipline and people know very little of the story but have really strong opinions on how things are supposed to play out.”

In reality, the two-point conversion probably should have worked.

The Nittany Lions had three players on two out to the left. Quarterback Sean Clifford snapped it quickly and got it out to running back Ricky Slade, who quickly cuts to the outside and comes up short. If he cuts to the inside, maybe he gets in. Or maybe he doesn’t.

Advertise with us

Franklin’s point is that, from his perspective, these things aren’t cut and dry. His numbers told him to go for two there, and he did. If Slade gets in, nobody bats an eye. Since he didn’t, Franklin gets grilled for it.

He pointed to a kicking decision late in the game as another example.

Penn State scored to make it 31-26 with just under four minutes left to play. Franklin was deciding whether to employ an onside kick, use a squib kick or send it deep. He opted to squib kick, and the Nittany Lions pinned the Golden Gophers’ return man at the 21-yard line.

“With one guy deep having to cover the whole field, you kick it at an angle, you may go down and recover it and he may bobble it, which he did bobble it. We stopped them, went three-and-out, and I burned the time outs,” Franklin said. “That was the right decision. Why? Why was that the right decision? Because it worked. Because we stopped them. They went three-and-out, and I burned the time outs. If they would have picked up two first downs and ended the game, I would have been getting my butt ripped in the press conference for, ‘Why didn't you go on-sides kick?’”

Part of this frustration is likely because Penn State lost, but it’s also fair to say that the only reason Franklin is receiving these questions is because his team lost.

Advertise with us

It’s a delicate balance for Franklin, because he is trying to get the Nittany Lions to move on from Minnesota and focus all their efforts on Indiana, who they will play this upcoming Saturday.

And yet, after a season-altering loss last Saturday, that is where most of the questions lie, and rightfully so. Everyone wants to know if Penn State can fix the problems that emerged last week and right the ship moving forward.

Franklin himself had one last grievance to air in defense of his program and himself. Once he did, he finished up with a message likely equivalent to the one he’s trying to instill in his team this week.

“I'll be the first one to admit, I'm ultimately responsible for making sure that we execute the decision. So I don't want you to misinterpret what I'm saying. I'm still responsible for all of it, and I'll take it,” Franklin said. “But I will tell you that's where some of my frustration comes from sometimes. And doing this for 24 years, that's the hard part. You can disagree with me. You're more than welcome to. I'm stating my opinion on how I see it.

“I appreciate you guys listening to me and letting me vent for a few minutes, and it is on to Indiana and I'll look forward to not answering any more questions about last week and Minnesota.”

Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak