Tommy Stevens’ name has been entered into the NCAA’s transfer portal, and multiple sources reported Thursday that the veteran quarterback will not return to Penn State next season.
If that move becomes official, it will have a profound effect on the Nittany Lions’ plans for 2019. Stevens was their most experienced quarterback and the favorite to win the open competition to start against redshirt sophomore Sean Clifford.
Here are the facts as we know them right now:
1. He’s not completely gone yet.
If you’re just familiarizing yourself with the transfer portal, implemented by the NCAA for this academic year, you’re in luck. Here’s a full guide on what it is and is not.
In summary, it’s just a database of players who are considering transfers. Those who enter their names can talk to other programs about the opportunities they can offer. If they don’t like what they hear, they can withdraw and stay with the current programs. Conversely, programs can revoke the scholarships of players who enter their names.
Read More
It’s the college football version of taking space from a relationship, and reconciliations are possible. In fact, earlier this offseason, former Clairton star and Nittany Lions safety Lamont Wade entered his named in the portal before withdrawing it to stay in Happy Valley.
So Stevens could still walk this decision back if he wants to and, theoretically, line up as Penn State’s starting quarterback for the season opener Aug. 31 against Idaho. That said ...
2. He seems pretty uncertain about his standing at Penn State.
“Tommy has so much invested in this year, and we know that this is his last shot. If he’s not Penn State’s quarterback, he’s going to be somebody’s quarterback,” Stevens’ father, Tom, told the Centre Daily Times earlier this spring. “Everyone already knows, if he’s not playing at Penn State this year, he’s probably going to leave. I don’t think that’s much news to anybody. He wants to be a starter.”
Straight to the point. Stevens has waited patiently behind Trace McSorley for three years. He’s been flexible, allowing coaches to play him at other positions while he waited his turn. He even battled through an injury riddled 2018 to get to this point. (In fact, those injuries limited his ability to compete this spring.)
That’s quite a demonstration of loyalty to a program, so it’s impossible to believe he’d take exploration of a transfer lightly.
Rather, this choice is an indication that the QB competition with redshirt sophomore Sean Clifford really was as open as coach James Franklin has insisted it was in the spring, and that’s not good enough for Stevens. At least not until he’s heard what other programs have to offer.
He’s a fifth-year senior with his degree in hand. He can play anywhere as a graduate transfer. Why should he stay at Penn State if his job could potentially be holding a clip board for a guy three years his junior?
If he has any intention of playing football after 2019, he’d be a fool not to seek more certainty than Penn State has apparently provided. It’s the only way this move makes sense.
3. Penn State is in a bind here.
If Franklin truly isn’t sold on Stevens over Clifford because of injury, performance or some other reason, then he has no good options. Either he commits harder to a guy he’s uncertain about to keep him in the stable, or he picks the younger guy at the expense of losing a veteran safety net for him.
Clifford may well be ready to start. He made the absolute most of his seven pass attempts in relief of McSorley last year, racking up 195 yards and two touchdowns on just five completions. He looked decent in the spring game, and he’s at the same stage of his career McSorley was when he took Penn State to a Big Ten title and the Rose Bowl in 2016.
None of that changes the fact that the Lions would be better off with both guys than just one of them. It will be a hit to their 2019 chances if they can’t find a way to maintain the status quo.
4. The situation probably isn’t anyone’s fault.
Sometimes the interests of players and their teams simply diverge. Stevens wants to play. Penn State wants to put the best candidate behind center and has recruited well enough to have multiple options.
If those two goals aren’t compatible, then the fit isn’t right for either party anymore. Period.
Sure, it would be an unfortunate ending to what once seemed like a promising Penn State career. Some fans have even preferred Stevens to McSorley these last few years, so it would be weird not to see him finally get his shot.
It’s just difficult to find fault with either side’s apparent position now, regardless of the events that preceded this moment.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.