The NCAA’s “transfer portal” sounds like something out of NBC’s “The Good Place.”
The characters in that NBC comedy often find themselves traveling between all sorts of fantasy-like dimensions of the afterlife. One of them is the “void,” the home of humanoid assistant Janet, who helps the protagonists’ souls escape the demons who want to torture them. It seems very much like the type of place that you’d expect a portal to lead to. Here are five hours of what it’s like.
The drumbeat of tweets in recent weeks announcing college football players’ entrance into something as mysteriously named as a transfer portal causes the mind to wonder what is waiting for them on the other side of it. Are the Jacksonville Jaguars good in that plane of existence? Do the government workers inside it get paid? Does anyone there understand the point of “The Masked Singer”?
Sadly, like most things involving the NCAA, it’s about as dull as Janet’s void. It’s not even a physical place at all. It’s just an online database implemented for the first time in this academic year as a first step in players’ bids to move between schools. For once, though, it’s a tweak to the transfer system that may actually be a net positive for their well-being.
Here’s your primer on what this step that’s exploded onto the scene is and isn’t, and what it might mean for the future:
What it is
Read More
A list of names that functions like a football purgatory. Players whose names appear on it after they declare an intent to transfer can remain enrolled at their current school but be allowed communicate with coaches at possible destinations should they choose to follow through on a move. Previously, athletes needed to seek permission to talk to other programs, so this frees them to interact more freely and avoid terminating their relationship with their current school before gaining an understanding of their options elsewhere.
It also affords schools the right to terminate the scholarships of players in the portal if they want to give them to incoming freshmen or transfers.
Basically, it gives both parties more options to explore what life could be like without each other.
What it is not
The absolute end of the line for a player and his current program, as players can remove their names from the portal and stay put (if their scholarships aren’t terminated, of course). Think of it like changing your Facebook relationship status to “it’s complicated.” It’s never a great sign for a relationship — possibly a signal that it’s coming to an end — but there’s still room for both parties to reconcile after they’ve spent a few days on dating websites and gotten freaked out.
What it means
We don’t for sure yet, but we have some hints. For example, you may have noticed by keeping an eye on the Post-Gazette’s Penn State coverage lately that a lot of Nittany Lions have taken the leap into the portal since their season ended with a thud of a loss against Kentucky in the Citrus Bowl.
Defensive end Shaka Toney is not among them, but if his Twitter feed is any indication, the new step is popular around the locker room.
The portal was one of the best things to happen to college athletes.
— 👳🏾 (@SackA_Toney) January 16, 2019
The reason why is obvious. Rivals recruiting expert Mike Farrell put it well, also on Twitter.
The transfer portal is the new recruiting https://t.co/PIhXSyKVua
— Mike Farrell (@rivalsmike) January 17, 2019
The portal gives players the leverage to more thoroughly explore their options.
If they don’t like their playing time, they can openly talk to programs that might be interested in giving them more while retaining the ability to stay put if they don’t like what they hear. If the coaches who recruited them get fired or leave for another school, they can research contingency plans while waiting to see how the replacement process shakes out. And if they merely want to test their value to a program, they can enter the portal and see how hard coaches pitch them to stay put.
For programs, there’s more uncertainty in the short term, obviously. No coach wants to have to re-recruit his own players, but the flip side could be a positive. Coaches always love to have more players to recruit. Perhaps they can sway a guy who’s just dipping his toes in the transfer pool and is inclined to stay put. Perhaps they can get a second chance to land a player whom they really liked and got to know during high school recruiting.
Add it all up and you have the potential for a more transactional college football world. The sport’s more stuffy fans might find such a landscape less wholesome than they prefer, but players are always going to seek the best situations for themselves regardless. Under the portal system, they have more freedom to do so transparently and confidently. No wonder it’s so popular.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.