The popular complaint about coordinator Joe Moorhead’s generally explosive Penn State offense is that its lack of under-center looks causes struggles to convert in third-and-short situations. The Nittany Lions would be better off, the theory goes, if they abandoned their option reads out of the shotgun in favor of more traditional schemes, including those that deploy a fullback.

Those murmurs have only grown louder in the wake of the loss Saturday at Ohio State, in which Penn State failed in a couple of crucial third-and-short situations in the second half, losing yardage both times.

Advanced statistics, however, tell a very different story about what’s causing the Nittany Lions’ 40 percent third down conversion rate, which ranks a mediocre No. 62 nationally. They point instead to too many third-and-long situations.

Penn State ranks No. 73 nationally with an average third down distance of 7.12 yards through eight games, according to College Football Analytics. It is, by far, their worst ranking in a relevant offensive statistical category — most of their key indicators place them at least in the top 30, and some in the top 10.

Advertise with us

And it leads to an obvious problem: The further an offense is from the lead stick, the tougher it becomes to move it.

That’s borne out not only in Penn State’s third down numbers this year, but those it posted last year, too, when the team’s 95th-ranked third-down distance of 7.42 yards was shadowed by a 118th-ranked third-down conversion percentage of 32.7.

More narrowly, long third downs were easily the biggest problem late in the loss against the Buckeyes, too. Yes, Penn State failed to convert on a third-and-2 from its own 29-yard line late in the third quarter, then a third-and-goal at the Ohio State 3-yard line late in the fourth. Those plays have understandably gotten a lot of scrutiny. The offense, however, also faced third downs of 11, 17, 19 and 15 yards in the second half.

No unit — not even one with Penn State’s many playmakers — is going to consistently convert in those situations.

The key for Penn State moving forward, then, is to cut out as many early down dead plays — those that go for losses or minimal gains — as possible.

Advertise with us

To their credit, the numbers above reflect growth in this area, year over year. An average third down of 7.12 yards is better than one of 7.42. But the Nittany Lions can be better.

The easiest way would be to reduce the number of sacks on quarterback Trace McSorley. Penn State ranks No. 92 nationally in sacks allowed per game at 2.50 and No. 91 in pass attempts per sack at 14.45.

Penn State could also stand to even out its first down performance. The Nittany Lions rank No. 19 in percentage of first downs with at least four yards gained at 53.4 percent. But they’re 40th in average yards gained on first down at 6.36. This dissonance suggests that too many dead plays happen on the remaining 46.6 percent of first downs.

Of course, zone read runs like those Penn State fancies will always lead to a baseline number of dead plays. When your offense is predicated on reading a defender and making split-section decisions depending upon what he does, sometimes you’re going to read wrong and lose yardage on ugly plays.

Oklahoma, however, runs an offense that is similar to Penn State’s in a lot of ways, and the Sooners’ average third down distance is 6.52 yards. Unsurprisingly they convert third downs at a 46.5 percent clip, which ranks No. 18 nationally. So while the style of offense has a certain number of dead plays baked in, the style alone doesn’t account for the volume from which Penn State is suffering.

Advertise with us

That leads us to the team’s offensive line, which is not the sturdiest. Coach James Franklin has been pointing this out all season, and most of the dead plays in the Ohio State game were a direct result of the Nittany Lions’ front getting mauled by the Buckeyes’ defensive line. McSorley was often getting hit, or at least under pressure, while little running room developed for Heisman Trophy frontrunner Saquon Barkley.

In what was a one-point game, though, the line didn’t have to get a surge on every play to win. It only needed to turn a couple of those third-and-15s into third-and-7s to give explosive players like McSorley and Barkley reasonable time to make Moorhead’s proven playcalls work.

Penn State is capable of making that kind of incremental growth between now and the postseason. And if the Nittany Lions are fortunate enough to spend it in the College Football Playoff, it could be the difference between a first-round flameout and a national championship.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.