One month after the 2025 season ended, Pitt volleyball finds itself in a familiar but delicate position. The Panthers again are built to contend for a national championship, armed with elite experience, high-end returning production and one of the most impactful transfers in Division I.
At the same time, the roster is thinner in key areas than it has been in recent seasons, leaving little margin for error as Pitt chases a sixth consecutive Final Four appearance and its elusive first national title.
The foundation of Pitt’s roster remains as strong as any in the country, starting with senior right side Olivia Babcock. The back-to-back AVCA National Player of the Year is the centerpiece of Dan Fisher’s program. She returns after averaging 5.97 points per set and 5.17 kills per set on a .334 hitting percentage in 2025, while also contributing defensively with 2.09 digs and 1.01 blocks per set.
With Babcock entering her final collegiate season, Pitt once again has the luxury of building around the most dominant scorer in the sport.
Jessica Smallwood, a freshman at the same position, also enters at an important moment for the program. A three-time all-state selection and the top-ranked player in Kentucky, Smallwood gives Pitt a developmental option behind Babcock in her final collegiate season.
While there is positional flexibility — Smallwood could slide into the middle if needed — the expectation is that she will be groomed at right side, allowing Pitt to begin planning for life after Babcock without forcing immediate responsibility.
Read More
On the left pin, Pitt brings back continuity, if not overwhelming star power. Senior outside hitter Blaire Bayless (2.65 kills per set, .296 hitting) and sophomore Marina Pezelj (1.60 kills per set, .234 hitting) each are expected to return as starters. Pezelj, in particular, feels poised for a leap after she gained valuable experience as a freshman and heads into her first full offseason in the program.
Still, the arrival of one of the nation’s top recruits quickly might shift the pecking order.
Freshman outside hitter Ayanna Watson arrives as the No. 2 overall recruit in the class and could make an immediate impact. A 2026 Under Armour Next MVP, two-time Nevada Gatorade Player of the Year and a finalist for AVCA High School Player of the Year, Watson brings the kind of physicality and terminal offense that could push her into the lineup sooner rather than later. Whether that comes at the expense of Bayless or Pezelj remains one of the most intriguing offseason storylines.
Watson is not the only freshman pin entering the mix. Outside hitter Lola Sageer has an accomplished high school resume of her own after being named the 2024-25 Large School AAA New York State Section III Player of the Year and Central New York Player of the Year. While cracking Pitt’s veteran rotation immediately will be difficult, Sageer provides another capable option on the left side and reinforces Pitt’s long-term depth at outside hitter.
In the middle, sophomore Abbey Emch emerged late in the season and now looks like a fixture. Emch earned the starting role down the stretch and finished with 1.01 blocks per set, 0.99 kills per set and a team-best .488 hitting percentage. Her development is critical given the heavy losses at the position — most notably the graduation of Bre Kelley, a two-time All-American and ACC Defensive Player of the Year.
To stabilize the middle, Pitt added Kentucky transfer Jordyn Dailey, a redshirt junior who provides much-needed experience. Dailey appeared in 29 matches and 95 sets as a redshirt freshman for the Wildcats, recording 142 kills on a .314 hitting percentage and 82 blocks. She was replaced in the lineup as a redshirt sophomore but still had 46 kills, 34 blocks and 19 digs across 56 sets.
Her versatility — including extensive work on the slide attack from her time playing right side — should pair well with Emch. Still, Pitt currently has only two true middle blockers on the roster, an unusually thin configuration for a program with national title aspirations.
Setter is the most high-profile position change. Pitt landed former Penn State setter Izzy Starck, the 2024 AVCA National Freshman of the Year. She totaled 1,483 assists while starting all 37 matches for the Nittany Lions in their national championship run. Starck’s midseason departure from Penn State in 2025 to focus on her mental health raised questions externally, but there is little doubt about her on-court ability.
She is expected to start, with redshirt junior Haiti Tautua’a — a reliable serving specialist with 18 aces over 34 matches — serving as the primary backup.
The backcourt is where the most scrutiny remains. Junior Mallorie Meyer returns after splitting libero duties with Emery Dupes, who graduated. Meyer averaged 1.27 digs per set but struggled with consistency at times, including during Pitt’s Final Four run.
Izzy Masten, who averaged 1.09 digs per set as a serving and defensive specialist, flashed significant upside and could challenge for the starting libero role after a full offseason in the system. Freshman Trinity Thompson, recruited primarily as a setter but praised by Fisher for her defensive upside, adds another intriguing piece to the group.
Off the bench, outside hitter Sophia Gregoire remains a high-upside option after her breakout performance Nov. 16 against California, when she posted 20 kills and 23 points. With Pitt’s depth on the pins, Gregoire again might be used situationally, but her ceiling is undeniable.
Still, for all the talent and experience — nearly every non-freshman on the roster has played in a Final Four — Pitt’s needs are clear. The Panthers almost certainly need to add another middle blocker to avoid being one injury away from a crisis, a scenario they have faced in the past. And while the staff appears confident in internal growth at libero, the backcourt remains the biggest question after a shaky postseason showing.
Pitt is talented enough to contend again. Whether it can finally break through and win a national championship might depend less on its stars and more on how thin positions hold up once the season begins.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.