The Post-Gazette graded Mason Heintschel and the rest of Pitt’s offensive players last week. Today, it’s time to shift focus to the other side of the ball.

This second and final installment of our report card breaks down the Panthers’ defensive units, highlighting the playmakers, the trouble spots and the key moments that shaped the season.

Defensive line

Pitt’s defensive front was the backbone of the entire team, powering one of the top run defenses in the country.

The Panthers surrendered just 97 rushing yards per game and routinely put opponents behind schedule, forcing them away from their preferred scripts. Outside of tough outings against Notre Dame and Miami — two of the best rushing units they faced — this group consistently won the line of scrimmage. Even Georgia Tech’s Haynes King, who carved up most of the ACC, found little room to work.

Advertise with us

That production becomes even more impressive considering how many moving parts the unit dealt with. Injuries at defensive end were a season-long hurdle, with Blaine Spires and Jaeden Moore missing significant time. The domino effect pushed Isaiah Neal out to end, and when Sean FitzSimmons went down inside, the rotation tightened even further.

Still, the core five of Neal, FitzSimmons, Nick James, Francis Brewu and Jimmy Scott kept the standard high.

Individually, there was no shortage of standout play. Jimmy Scott emerged as the group’s most disruptive force, finishing with eight tackles for loss and a team-best 4.5 sacks. Despite changing positions midseason, Neal posted six tackles for loss and 3.5 sacks, proving how valuable his versatility became. Brewu played with steady physicality, contributing 35 tackles and forcing a fumble. James added another six tackles for a loss and two sacks, while FitzSimmons gave the room reliable depth when healthy.

Even with all the shifting bodies, the defensive line remained one of Pitt’s most reliable units from September through November — and arguably the biggest reason the defense held up week after week.

Grade: A-

Advertise with us

Linebackers

Few position groups on Pitt’s roster were as influential — or as consistently impressive — as the linebackers.

Rasheem Biles, Kyle Louis and Braylan Lovelace formed the defense’s heartbeat by blending speed, range and physicality in a way few ACC teams could match. Biles and Louis drew most of the national attention, and rightfully so — they were among the most disruptive duos in the country, equally comfortable squeezing gaps in the run game or dropping into coverage and making plays on the ball.

Lovelace, however, was the glue. The only starting linebacker to play in every game, he provided stability when Biles and Louis were sidelined, compiling 76 tackles and two interceptions. His signature moment came against Georgia Tech, when his 100-yard pick-six stopped a Yellow Jackets rally and shifted momentum back to Pitt.

The unit was supposed to be deeper, but preseason injuries to Jeremiah Marcelin and Jayden Bonsu wiped out their seasons. While their absence wasn’t immediately felt, it mattered when Biles and Louis missed time. Even so, backups Cameron Lindsey and Nick Lapi rose to the occasion, particularly against Syracuse, combining for 13 tackles and multiple impact plays that kept the defense steady.

Individually, the production was remarkable. Biles led the team with 85 tackles, 12 tackles for loss, 2.5 sacks, two interceptions and two touchdowns. Louis matched that versatility with 81 tackles, 8.5 tackles for loss, three sacks, two interceptions and two fumble recoveries.

Advertise with us

Anchored by a strong defensive line and supported by a secondary that fluctuated, this linebacker corps consistently made game-changing plays and proved to be instinctive, aggressive and reliable throughout the season.

Grade: A-

Safeties

The safety corps quietly improved and emerged as an impactful unit by the end of the season.

After a rocky start, Pitt’s deep defenders became more confident, physical and opportunistic. Kavir Bains‑Marquez shined late, flashing ball-hawk instincts and adding a scoring play to his stat line. He recorded three interceptions, returning one for a touchdown, and finished with 54 tackles and multiple pass breakups, proving he could create plays rather than just react to them.

Cruce Brookins put together one of the most consistent campaigns in the secondary. With 44 tackles, two interceptions and two pass breakups, he showcased excellent instincts in zone coverage and discipline against the run. While other players grabbed headlines, Brookins provided a foundation of reliability that helped stabilize the back end.

Advertise with us

Javon McIntyre had a slower start but ended the season on an upward trajectory. He totaled 46 tackles, an interception and a pass breakup. Plus, his late-season performances — particularly against Georgia Tech and Miami — demonstrated improved reads, solid tackling and composure under pressure, complementing the aggressiveness of Bains‑Marquez and Brookins.

Combined, this trio helped elevate a secondary that struggled early in the year. Their mix of takeaways, strong tackling and improved coverage discipline made them one of the steadier and more impactful groups on the roster, providing a reason for optimism heading into next season.

Grade: B

Cornerbacks

The cornerback room was the most inconsistent unit on Pitt’s defense. Despite solid coaching and support from the front seven, opposing receivers often found space, leading to critical big plays. Missed assignments, coverage lapses and occasional over-commitments undermined the efforts of the defensive line and linebackers, making this group a clear area for improvement.

Shawn Lee Jr. was arguably the team’s top corner, flashing playmaking ability throughout the year — yet he was underutilized toward the end of the season. His highlight came with a pick-six against Stanford, showcasing his instincts and ball skills. Lee finished with 29 tackles, 3.5 tackles for loss, an interception and four pass breakups, proving he could make an impact against both the run and the pass.

Advertise with us

Seniors Tamon Lynum and Rashad Battle struggled with consistency. Battle compiled 40 tackles, 1.5 tackles for loss, a sack and five pass breakups, but repeated mental errors limited his effectiveness. Lynum finished with 20 tackles, an interception and a pass breakup, yet often failed to lock down his assignments, giving opponents exploitable opportunities.

Shadarian Harrison was the steadiest presence in the room, totaling 29 tackles, an interception, three pass breakups and a forced fumble. He provided reliability when the front seven created pressure, helping the secondary capitalize on opportunities.

Overall, the cornerbacks were a unit of extremes: flashes of talent overshadowed by inconsistency. When the defensive front and linebackers performed, the corners held their own. When mistakes crept in, big plays followed.

Grade: C-