Pitt wrapped up the regular season at 8-4, a year marked by steady progress and a few late-season stumbles. With the postseason still ahead, it’s time to take stock of how each unit performed.
This first installment of our report card focuses solely on the offense and how its position groups stacked up over the course of the fall.
Quarterbacks
The quarterback room for Pitt in 2025 was a study in contrasts, split between returning starter Eli Holstein and freshman Mason Heintschel. Holstein opened the season 2-2 but struggled to keep the offense afloat, finishing his time with 77 completions on 125 attempts, six interceptions, 12 touchdowns, and multiple turnovers in key losses to Louisville and West Virginia. While talented, Holstein’s inconsistencies and struggles under pressure ultimately forced a change.
Enter Mason Heintschel, a freshman who took over the starting role and led Pitt to a 5-0 run. Heintschel’s confidence and poise immediately transformed the offense, allowing the Panthers to operate at a high level and take what defenses gave them. His 176 completions on 276 attempts for 15 touchdowns and seven interceptions, combined with 233 passing yards per game, show a rookie with serious upside.
He made clutch plays, including a touchdown to Desmond Reid at Florida State, though he also displayed some typical freshman growing pains — several red zone interceptions, a few fumbles and avoidable sacks. The rough patches came mostly against top-tier defenses like Notre Dame and Miami.
As a group, the quarterbacks started slow but grew into a more dynamic and confident unit once Heintschel took the reins.
Read More
First four games (Holstein era): C-
Final eight games (Heintschel era): B+
Running backs
Pitt’s backfield spent the season adjusting on the fly as injuries reshaped the depth chart week to week. Returning All-American Desmond Reid was never fully healthy, missing five games outright and playing limited snaps in several others. His absence loomed largest against teams like West Virginia, Louisville and Miami, where Pitt clearly missed his explosiveness and experience. In the seven games he did play, Reid totaled 296 yards and two touchdowns while averaging 4.6 yards per carry.
With Reid sidelined, freshman Ja’Kyrian Turner was thrust into the lead role and delivered one of the bright surprises of the offense. Turner ran for 672 yards and seven touchdowns, showing excellent vision and burst. His breakout performances against Stanford and Georgia Tech — including a 201-yard effort — hinted at star potential. Like many freshmen, though, he hit a wall against elite fronts. Notre Dame and Miami kept him largely in check and exposed the line’s struggles to create consistent push.
Juelz Goff entered the year positioned as the primary No. 2 behind Reid, but ultimately became Turner’s relief option. Though his workload fluctuated, Goff carved out a useful role as Pitt’s short-yardage runner, finishing with 275 yards, five touchdowns and 3.9 yards per carry. His downhill style gave Pitt a change-of-pace presence when the offense needed tough yards.
The biggest storyline for the group, aside from health, was ball security: Pitt’s running backs did not fumble once during the regular season — a remarkable feat given the rotation and the amount of pressure placed on the rushing attack when the passing game stalled. When the offensive line created space, this group produced. When the trenches collapsed, the backs had little room to operate.
Grade: B -
Wide receivers
Pitt’s receiving corps emerged as one of the steadier elements of the offense, especially once Mason Heintschel settled in as the starter. Sophomore Kenny Johnson grew into the offense’s primary target, showcasing dependable hands and strong run-after-catch ability. His 48 receptions for 695 yards and five scores reflected both volume and efficiency, and he consistently provided Heintschel with a trustworthy outlet in key moments.
Raphael “Poppi” Williams brought a different dynamic to the group: separation and scoring. His knack for slipping past defenders was evident all season, finishing with 46 catches for 644 yards and a team-best six touchdowns — a number that also placed him near the top of the ACC leaderboard. When Pitt needed a big play on the perimeter, Williams often delivered it.
Cataurus “Blue” Hicks brought the vertical element. Though his usage fluctuated game to game, he maximized his opportunities, piling up 422 yards on just 24 receptions. His 84-yard sprint to the end zone against NC State was one of the signature explosive plays of the year.
Depth pieces such as Deuce Spann, Bryce Yates, and at times Censere Lee provided complementary snaps and helped keep the rotation fresh.
As a whole, this unit made noticeable strides in generating yards after the catch and creating chunk plays. However, the group wasn’t immune to struggles. Against elite defenses like Notre Dame and Miami, separation became harder to come by and a few costly drops resurfaced — issues that prevented the receivers from earning top marks.
Grade: B+
Tight ends
Pitt cycled through multiple contributors at tight end this year, leaning on a mix of experience and developing talent to get through the schedule. Between Jake Overman, Justin Holmes, Malachi Thomas, and occasional snaps from Josh Altsman, the position ended up playing a larger role in the offense than many expected. The group collectively posted 48 receptions for 479 yards and eight touchdowns and became a frequent target inside the 20-yard line.
The biggest revelation came from Justin Holmes. Brought in largely for his blocking background, he showed he could be far more than a complementary piece. His 22 catches and four touchdown grabs gave Pitt a dependable middle-of-the-field option and helped stabilize the passing game when receivers were taken away.
Overman’s season never quite found its rhythm due to injury, limiting him to nine catches and a more rotational role than he’s used to. Thomas contributed some much-needed athleticism to the group, and while his 156 receiving yards highlighted his potential, he still had moments that suggested he’s very much in the development phase.
As blockers, the tight ends had a mixed résumé. There were stretches where they created strong edges and supported the run game well, but there were also series where their technique or timing slipped, disrupting the structure of plays.
Grade: B
Offensive line
Pitt’s offensive line was a constant storyline this season, and not always for positive reasons. Injuries on the left side forced the Panthers into a patchwork setup all year. Michigan transfer Jeff Persi missed significant time with a knee issue, while left guard Keith Gouveia was lost for the season after the Louisville game. Rotating between Persi and Kendall Stanley brought inconsistency and frequent penalties, preventing the group from establishing a rhythm.
The right side, anchored by center Lyndon Cooper, right guard BJ Williams, and right tackle Ryan Baer, offered more stability, but even their steady play couldn’t mask the struggles elsewhere. The run game had flashes of success — Florida State and Georgia Tech were standout performances — but against physical, well-coached fronts like Notre Dame and Miami, the line failed to open lanes consistently.
Pass protection was a bigger concern. Pitt gave up more than three sacks per game and allowed one of the highest pressure rates among Power Four programs, forcing Heintschel and Holstein to operate under constant duress. The inconsistent line play limited the offense’s ability to sustain drives and put additional pressure on skill-position players.
Grade: D






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.