It would be easy to write a disparaging column about the Pitt football program. The Panthers played two home football games against challenging opponents this year. They were blown out in both, the most recent being a 38-7 beatdown last weekend against No. 12 Miami.
Pitt had a chance to take a step forward against the Hurricanes. A win would’ve secured a 9-3 showing in the regular season and, thanks to a late-night upset by Cal, a spot in the ACC title game.
But instead, the Panthers squandered their opportunity.
“Nothing good happened in that game,” coach Pat Narduzzi said following Saturday’s loss. “They’ve got a good football team, as well, and they outplayed us today. They outcoached us today, and it falls on my shoulders.”
Narduzzi was right — his team wasn’t ready. Pitt’s losses against Notre Dame and Miami displayed the sizable gap that exists between true contenders and where its program currently stands. This year’s Panthers didn’t deserve to call themselves champions, nor did they deserve the opportunity to compete in the playoff.
That being said, I don’t think they’re far away.
Read More
Even after Saturday’s debacle, I’m cautiously optimistic about Pitt football heading into 2026. The Panthers have the bones of a solid squad — minus an offensive line.
Freshman phenom Mason Heintschel is a true building block, a quarterback nearly every team in the country would love to have. It’s hard to imagine him regressing next fall, especially with the bulk of his skill players also set to return.
“I think the biggest thing for me is just trying to process and understand what defenses are thrown at us,” Heintschel said when asked what he can learn from the two games Pitt lost with him under center. “Know where my answers are and be quick getting rid of the football.”
Heintschel continued on, saying there were times he tried to do “too much,” which resulted in mistakes. I have no doubt he will learn and improve.
The same can be said for the defense, which only had four starters walk on senior day. All-American Kyle Louis might be NFL-bound and perhaps Rasheem Biles, as well, but that linebacker room has a handful of other future standouts. The secondary and defensive line will likely be better after this year of development, too.
Pitt should have the talent to contend for a conference championship, especially in a league like the ACC. Talent, however, won’t be my main concern. There are bigger issues to address, and the Panthers know it.
“I think we have the opportunity, the chance to be a really talented football team, a really great football team,” Heintschel said. “I think we are that when we don’t make those little mistakes, when we do clean up those little things. That’s just something that we gotta work on, that we gotta fix. Those little mistakes and mental problems can’t happen.”
Well, at least some within the program know it.
As far as this writer is concerned, Pitt’s biggest current program flaw has less to do with scheme and personnel and more to do with discipline. Too many times throughout the years, the Panthers have played themselves out of opportunities to win meaningful football games.
Look no further than the penalty numbers. Pitt entered Saturday’s game averaging 68 penalty yards per game. That number went up to 69.7 following the Miami loss, when the Panthers were penalized nine times for 88 yards.
Mistakes are going to happen, especially in college football. But most of the penalties Pitt committed Saturday were largely preventable.
Two that especially stand out came in the third quarter, when the Panthers secondary committed a pair of unsportsmanlike conduct fouls. The Hurricanes took full advantage of those mistakes, finishing the drive with a touchdown to make the score 24-7, ultimately ending the game.
“They probably got more unsportsmanlike conducts in the country than they got called against us today,” Narduzzi said. “I don't know how that happens. There's a lot going on both ways, and the flags just got thrown against us today.
“We talked about composure and we're going to play Pitt football. We didn't want to play their game. So that was the message is to not get baited into it, and we got baited into it.”
What Narduzzi fails to understand, however, is getting baited into such mistakes is a part of Pitt football. Just look at the numbers. For the eighth straight season, the Panthers are set to finish in the top five of the ACC in penalty yards per game. They’ve averaged north of 60 penalty yards per game in each year since 2017.
When an opposing team plays Pitt, it can count on at least six free first downs. That’s not a winning recipe, no matter how much talent is on one’s roster.
This trend falls on the coach. Part of me understands why he seems to have some leniency on this front. Pitt has long been known to recruit players with a chip on their shoulder, and Narduzzi is right to allow his team to play with an edge.
But the Panthers have to know where the line is and far too often, they don’t.
Personal fouls aren’t the only preventable mistakes Pitt routinely makes, either. There are also too many pre-snap fouls. If your team can’t properly line up or master the snap count in the final week of November, especially when playing at home, it’s a problem — one that has been a consistent theme no matter who the offensive coordinator is.
All this being said, I still think Narduzzi deserves some praise for this season.
He made a gutsy call to switch quarterbacks after the Louisville loss, one that potentially changed the trajectory of his program.
He routinely puts his foot in his mouth, but his team seemingly always has his back. Such loyalty is a rarity in today’s era of college football.
While others have put a higher dependence on the transfer portal, Narduzzi continues to prioritize high school recruiting and development. That strategy has helped produce some of his current team’s most promising talents.
There are some areas where Pitt will always be outmatched. They won’t ever have the financial resources of regular playoff contenders. But the program has shown an ability to overcome this disadvantage.
For all of its flaws, Pitt football does most of the hard things right. It’s, as the freshman quarterback noted, “those little mistakes” that have consistently prevented the program from taking a step forward.
The good news is those little mistakes can be fixed. Narduzzi has led the Panthers to an ACC championship before and he can easily do so again. It’s gone on for far too long, but a new line must be drawn. No more dumb penalties, no more being disorganized, no more overlooking lesser opponents and no more silly quotes.
If Pitt can truly learn from the mistakes it made in 2025, only then will it have a shot to achieve its highest goals next year. It’s time to buckle down and grow up.
Three thoughts
1. On a brighter note for Pitt athletics, the basketball program delivered a thrilling win Friday evening in the form of a buzzer beater over Ohio State. Jeff Capel’s squad has had an overall miserable season so far, suffering ugly losses to West Virginia and UCF before getting upset by Quinnipiac. The Buckeyes aren’t exactly a basketball juggernaut, and the victory won’t likely change much for this team. But the win was still fun to watch. Props to Damarco Minor for hitting a shot that will likely serve as the high point for this team’s 2025-26 campaign.
2. On the note of big shots, stick taps to Kris Letang for finally giving the Penguins an overtime win. Post-regulation play has been a notable thorn in this team’s side. Friday night, Letang put that trend to rest, scoring the game-winner to secure a 4-3 victory over the Blue Jackets. The Penguins are still in the midst of an ugly month. Heck, the following day, they were blown out on home ice. But perhaps no longer having the overtime monkey on their back can allow the team to play a bit looser in tight situations moving forward — or at least coach Dan Muse should hope so.
3. Could there have been a more fitting start to the second half of this week’s Steelers’ embarrassment? All season long, Mike Tomlin’s team has struggled to show any sign of life after the break. After taking a 7-3 lead into the locker room against a tough Bills team, the Steelers were instantly smacked in the face — well, at least their 41-year-old quarterback was — and immediately surrendered a lead they’d never recapture. It’s truly impressive how fast this team can bottom out week to week. There is no fight. There are no answers. This is what Pittsburgh’s football team has become. And it’s hard to see anything changing before the end of the season.
Most Valuable Player
ESPN’s Marty Smith
No connection to Pittsburgh, but I don’t care. Marty Smith was the MVP of the weekend for his reporting of the Lane Kiffin fiasco in Oxford, Mississippi. Kiffin, after briefly convincing some he had changed, reverted back to his old, slimy self over the weekend when he chose to leave his 11-1 Ole Miss team for the LSU job. And he did so in true Lane Kiffin fashion — by making it all about himself.
Reporters waited on standby for Kiffin’s announcement, one that was originally supposed to be made after Friday’s Egg Bowl. Smith, covering the story for ESPN, stayed in position to report throughout the entire weekend, giving routine check-ins throughout Friday evening, all day Saturday and into Sunday morning.
As hours turned to days, the story grew tiresome for all involved. Yet, when the time came, Smith was there to get the interview. That five-minute conversation solidified Kiffin’s legacy. His answers were hollow, and his face displayed shame. And those quotes and visuals were made possible through the perseverance of Smith and his ESPN teammates. Well done.
Least Valuable Player
Those who continue to watch this city’s professional football team — myself included
Look, I get it. It’s the NFL. It’s the Steelers. What the heck else are we going to do on Sundays? But this isn’t fun for anyone involved. The product isn’t good. It’s just not entertaining football, even when they win. Game days just don’t feel the same right now. Fans used to arrive on the North Shore with excitement. Now, it seems as though a cloud of dread hangs over Acrisure Stadium. And as I noted above, the forecast doesn’t exactly show any sunny days ahead. As the football fans in this town love to say ... “Here we go.”
Question of the week
Which WPIAL football team has the best shot to win a state championship?
Three local teams will compete in this year’s PIAA finals: Clairton (Class 1A), Avonworth (3A) and Central Catholic (6A). All three have traveled unique roads to Mechanicsburg. As a casual follower of high school ball, I feel as though Avonworth has the best shot to get the job done. The Antelopes have demolished every team they’ve faced this year, including WPIAL Class 4A champion Aliquippa.
Duke Johncour’s program is on a quest for its first state championship. Northwestern Lehigh will likely be its toughest test. The Tigers needed overtime to defeat Avonworth, 36-33, in last year’s state final. They, too, enter this year’s championship game with a perfect record. The Antelopes have had a year to reflect on what went wrong, and Saturday is their chance at redemption. The Class 3A championship game marks the only battle of the unbeatens, and this writer can’t wait to watch.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.