Not long after the clock hit triple zeros on Nov. 30 of last year at Ohio Stadium, the world gained an explicit glimpse into the disdain that exists between two of college football’s most iconic programs.

The visiting Michigan Wolverines had just completed a stunning 13-10 upset victory over the No. 2 ranked Ohio State Buckeyes. As the Wolverines celebrated their win, a few players attempted to plant a Michigan flag at mid field. The gesture sparked a chaotic brawl, all captured on national television.

Dozens of fights broke out amid a sea of Ohio State and Michigan players. Law enforcement on site struggled to break up the fracas, resorting to the usage of pepper spray to calm things down.

“Ugly scene,” FOX color analyst Joel Klatt said as things unfolded. “An incredibly ugly scene for a beautiful rivalry.”

Advertise with us

Plenty was said of the incident in the following days. But as time progressed, the moment would serve as a defining moment for the losing side. Following said embarrassment, Ohio State — led by quarterback Will Howard and linebacker Jack Sawyer — ran the table, winning four straight playoff games to complete one of the most memorable national title runs in the sport’s history.

The feat cemented Howard and Sawyer as Buckeye legends. With both now in the midst of their first professional season, the Post-Gazette caught up with the Steelers’ rookie duo to reflect on that infamous afternoon and learn how it impacted their respective collegiate journeys.

‘A bad day’

To this reporter’s surprise, Howard and Sawyer both welcomed this conversation with a smile. This, after all, wasn’t a contest that left a great taste in their mouths, but both were willing to share their memories from the afternoon.

“It was just a bad day,” Howard said. “We talk about it a lot — we can’t have bad days at Ohio State, and that was the worst possible day we could’ve had one. It was bad.”

Howard wasn’t kidding.

Advertise with us

The Buckeyes entered the battle looking to snap a three-game losing skid against the defending national champion Wolverines. Michigan arrived in Columbus that Saturday a 21-point underdog, the widest point spread for the rivalry since 1978, per ESPN.

That afternoon, Ohio State’s offense, which entered the final week of the regular season averaging 37.8 points a game, fell completely flat. Howard was a part of the problem. Admittedly banged up from prior victories, he struggled against Michigan’s defense, completing just 19 of his 33 passes for 175 yards, a touchdown and two interceptions.

After taking a 10-10 tie into the locker room at half, neither side could move ahead until late in the fourth quarter. A 21-yard field goal from Dominic Zvada gave the Wolverines a three-point advantage with only 45 seconds remaining. Howard and the Buckeyes had one final chance to respond but were unsuccessful. A turnover on downs with 23 seconds remaining secured the unthinkable for Ohio State fans — Michigan had won again.

Not long after, another battle ensued, one far more noteworthy than a 21-point upset. The Wolverines celebrated their win at midfield. All was fine until a few players attempted to plant a Michigan flag at the 50-yard-line in front of a still mostly full Ohio Stadium.

“We were going to sing ‘Carmen Ohio,’ and right as the sound dings, I hear a bunch of yelling and I looked back and saw their flag in the air at midfield,” Sawyer recalled. “Obviously, we weren’t gonna put up with that, so what ensued after that, ensued after that.”

Advertise with us

Sawyer and a slew of Buckeye teammates rushed to midfield, where chaos erupted. Fights broke out left and right. Police and staff from both teams attempted to break up the madness, but things had gotten too far out of hand. A few players were pepper sprayed by authorities as a result.

“That’s what was crazy, the people getting pepper sprayed,” Sawyer said. “Obviously, you never want anything to get to that point. But at the same time, we’re young grown men who are really passionate and care about our collective schools. When something like that happens, stuff is going to get ramped up like it did. It definitely got a little out of control there.”

Sawyer took it upon himself to bring an end to the brawl. The defensive leader managed to snatch the Michigan flag, escape the sea of arms attempting to grab him and slammed it to the turf, causing those who remained in the stands to erupt with cheers.

The Buckeyes, however, weren’t happy. They might’ve fought off a gesture they believed to be disrespectful, but in the end, they were still the losers that day.

“It was terrible,” Sawyer said. “For us, we weren’t really thinking about the fight, really. We were thinking about the loss.”

Advertise with us

The wait

The loss to Michigan prevented Ohio State from a rematch against No. 1 Oregon — its other loss that season — in the Big Ten championship game. But their season wasn’t over. The Buckeyes had done enough to still earn an at-large bid to the 2024 playoff.

There was a long wait, 21 days to be exact, before they could begin their redemption tour.

“It sucked,” Howard said. “It was really long. It felt like forever, from that last game until that Tennessee game. But it taught us a lot. It taught all of us a lot, and we learned from it.”

Rather than licking their wounds, the Buckeyes used that loss to regroup. As the nation mocked their stumble, they prepared to ensure such issues wouldn’t plague them again.

“Coming out of that game, we took a deep dive and looked at a lot of the stuff we were doing schematically,” Sawyer said. “I give coach [Ryan] Day and the rest of the staff so much credit for the way we were able to use what we didn’t do well. … Leaving that game, we all came together as a group after a team meeting and decided to change some things that needed to be changed.”

Advertise with us

Howard and Sawyer took control of their respective sides of the ball. They held each other accountable, all while pushing ahead toward a common goal.

“I remember during that playoff run, we’d come over to each other every day and ask how our respective sides of the ball were practicing,” Howard recalled. “There was a different level of intensity during that playoff run because of the pissed off, angry attitude we had after the game.”

In addition to gaining a new level of respect for each other, both Howard and Sawyer also developed a deeper appreciation toward their head coach, Day, who was perhaps the most criticized man in sports for three straight weeks.

“He showed me what kind of person he truly is,” Howard said. “Obviously, before I had gotten there, there were a lot of things being said about him, especially pertaining to that rivalry with Michigan. There were a lot of questions, and I kind of wanted to be that guy for him, be that answer. I felt like I let him down in that game.

“ … When I saw him and how he reacted and how he was in the meeting we had after the game, I gained a whole new level of respect for him because I saw him having to really deal with it. I actually got to watch it, not just from a third-party source, but I actually got to see it, how he dealt with it, got us to overcome it and led us during that playoff run. It taught me a lot about the person who he is.”

Advertise with us

The happy ending

The playoff run started with a 42-17 win against No. 9-seeded Tennessee. It was followed by a 41-21 thumping of the top-ranked Ducks in the Rose Bowl, then a 28-14 victory against Texas in the Cotton Bowl, that year’s national semifinal.

Sawyer made the defining play in the latter win, returning a fumble 83 yards for a touchdown that sent his team to the national championship game. Howard, meanwhile, completely erased the memories of his poor performance against Michigan, making big throw after big throw against the nation’s top defensive units.

“I don’t know how you could watch that playoff run and say there were two or three quarterbacks that deserved to be drafted ahead of him, which is crazy because that’s what happened,” Sawyer said of Howard. “The run he went on, the leadership he showed, which you can’t measure at the quarterback position, the way he commanded the offense with intensity and the detail, without that, we don’t win.”

Ohio State’s redemption story concluded with a 34-23 win against Notre Dame. For three weeks, they were forced to sit and listen as the entire sports world chuckled at their lowest moment. But in the end, they earned the right to have the final laugh.

“Looking back now, we always say [the Michigan incident] doesn’t matter,” Sawyer said. “We went on one of the greatest championship runs in college football history.”

Advertise with us

“We turned it into a story that no one is ever going to forget,” added Howard.

While their college days are over, the championship run will forever remain a part of Howard and Sawyer’s football journeys. Their efforts throughout last postseason caught the attention of many, including the Steelers, who selected both in last year’s draft.

As No. 1 Ohio State and No. 15 Michigan prepare for Saturday’s matchup in Ann Arbor, plenty again will be on the line. The Buckeyes aim to conclude a perfect regular season, having yet to lose since last year’s stumble. The Wolverines, meanwhile, can play themselves into the postseason with another upset victory.

Howard and Sawyer won’t be suiting up for that one. Their focus is helping their new team prepare for a Sunday battle against the Buffalo Bills. But come noon on Saturday, both will be watching their beloved alma mater, hoping they get the job done.

“Oh we’ll be watching together,” Howard said.

“I think we’ll get it done this year,” Sawyer added. “It’s time.”