After Pitt's first practice of spring camp — a session that took place two weeks ago, though it feels more like four months — Pat Narduzzi made a claim. The Panthers' coach said he “can't imagine” having two better safeties in the country than Damar Hamlin and Paris Ford.
It wasn't necessarily a crazy thing to say, especially given the timing and sentiment. Both could have declared for the NFL, and Pitt could have been looking for a pair of starting safeties this offseason. Instead, Pitt's push toward 2020 was underway with Ford, a ball-hawking first-team All-ACC selection, and Hamlin, a sure-tackling presumptive captain, back on the South Side.
“We look totally different with those two guys out there,” Narduzzi added. “They're like brothers. ... I would say it probably is the best tandem in the country right now.”
But is that true?
Hamlin, after Narduzzi's interview scrum came to a close, didn't question his coach's claim. “You're supposed to believe in yourself no matter what,” Hamlin added. “Just based off of what we put out on the field last year and how we can build with our chemistry going into another year, I don't see nobody better than that.”
Ford chimed in a few minutes later, saying: “We leave that for the people.”
Read More
Or we can leave it for the statistics.
Sure, there are variables involved. But after hours of combing through numbers — hat tip to SportSource Analytics and Sports Info Solutions during these days of self-quarantine — we have an early verdict on whether or not Narduzzi's statement, that Hamlin and Ford make up the best safety duo in college football, is rooted in fact.
The numbers
For the purpose of this exercise, intangibles are not included. Of course, the groomed understanding between Ford and Hamlin, friends since high school, plays a role in why Narduzzi has faith in them as a tandem. But there's no way to measure leadership or communication skills, especially when evaluating the safety situations at 129 other Football Bowl Subdivision programs.
So we'll stick to 2019 figures that matter, stats that demonstrate reliability, disruption and downfield denial, respectively: tackles per game, total passes defended (interceptions plus pass breakups) and coverage results when targeted.
2019 most tackles per game, among FBS returning safeties
(courtesy of SportSource Analytics)
1. Talanoa Hufanga, USC, 9.0 (90 tackles in 10 games)
2. Hamsah Nasirildeen, Florida State, 8.42, (101 in 12)
T3. Troy Lefeged, Utah State, 8.0 (104 in 13)
T3. Sydney Brown, Illinois, 8.0 (88 in 11)
5. Jay Lenard, San Jose State, 7.92 (95 in 12)
6. Tyler Coyle, UConn, 7.82 (86 in 11)
7. Darrick Forrest, Cincinnati, 7.57 (106 in 14)
8. Paris Ford, Pitt, 7.46 (97 in 13)
9. Joe Foucha, Arkansas, 7.25 (87 in 12)
10. Andre Cisco, Syracuse, 7.22 (65 in 9)
11. Stephan Blaylock, UCLA, 7.17 (86 in 12)
T12. Ky'el Hemby, Southern Miss, 7.15 (93 in 13)
T12. Devon Key, Western Kentucky, 7.15 (93 in 13)
14. Dwayne Johnson Jr., San Diego State, 7.08 (92 in 13)
15. Damar Hamlin, Pitt, 7.0 (84 in 12)
Notes
• Ford-Hamlin is the only returning duo that features both players at seven tackles per game or more. SportSource Analytics actually lists Hamlin below seven per game, but that's because it counts the McKees Rocks native playing 13 games in 2019. He only played 12, missing the Georgia Tech game on Nov. 2.
• SportSource Analytics also lists Oklahoma State's Malcolm Rodriguez as a defensive back, though he moved from safety to linebacker last training camp. His 7.92 stops would have been tied for fifth nationally. However, Oklahoma State does have a pair of stellar safeties we'll get to in a second ...
• The next closest returning ACC safety pairing to Ford-Hamlin is Virginia Tech's Divine Deablo (6.46 tackles per game, 84 in 13) and Chamarri Conner (5.23, 68 in 13).
• Coyle announced in December that he was leaving UConn and transferring to another program. He remains in the transfer portal and a loose end in the 2020 conversation.
2019 most passes defended, among FBS returning safeties
(Courtesy of SportSource Analytics)
1. Kolby Harvell-Peel, Oklahoma State, 18
2. Trevon Moehrig, TCU, 15
3. Paris Ford, Pitt, 14
T4. Tariq Thompson, San Diego State, 12
T4. Aashari Crosswell, Arizona State, 12
T5. Damar Hamlin, Pitt, 11
T5. Tyler Coyle, UConn, 11
T5. Greg Eisworth, Iowa State, 11
T5. Will Boler, UAB, 11
T5. Dy'Jonn Turner, UAB, 11
T5. Sterling Weatherford, Miami (OH), 11
Notes
• Only two duos that had both players reach double-digit passes defended: Hamlin-Ford and Boler-Turner from UAB.
• Duo with the most passes defended: Harvell-Peel and Tre Sterling from Oklahoma State. Sterling, whose eight tackles for loss ranks third among returning Power Five safeties, had nine pass breakups in 2019, bringing the Cowboys' duo to 28.
• Hamlin and Ford's 25 pass breakups rank second among returning duos. Moehrig and Ar'Darius Washington, who chipped in seven passes defended, came in third with 22.
• LSU's Kary Vincent would have been fourth nationally with 13 passes defended, but there are questions over his distinction as a true safety. He is listed on LSU's roster as a safety, but in his bio is given the distinction of nickelback. This will matter later in the discussion.
2019 coverage results when targeted, among notable FBS duos
(Courtesy of Sports Info Solutions)
Paris Ford, Pitt: 34 targets, 17 completions, 50% completion rate, 3 INTs, 1 dropped INT, 54.66 passer rating against
Damar Hamlin, Pitt: 52 targets, 25 completions, 48.08% completion rate, 1 INT, 0 dropped INTs, 60.26 passer rating against
Kolby Harvell-Pele, Oklahoma State: 40 targets, 15 completions, 37.5% completion rate, 5 INTs, 3 dropped INTs, 34.69 passer rating against
Tre Sterling, Oklahoma State: 23 targets, 12 completions, 52.17% completion rate, 1 INT, 0 dropped INTs, 22.55 passer rating against
Trevon Moehrig, TCU: 31 targets, 12 completions, 38.71% completion rate, 4 INTs, 1 dropped INT, 29.17 passer rating against
Ar'Darius Washington, TCU: 15 targets, 5 completions, 33.3% completion rate, 5 INTs, 0 dropped INTs, 14.72 passer rating against
Dy'Jonn Turner, UAB: 41 targets, 20 completions, 48.78% completion rate, 1 INT, 0 dropped INTs, 44.97 passer rating against
Will Boler, UAB: 46 targets, 20 completions, 43.48% completion rate, 2 INTs, 3 dropped INTs, 69.47 passer rating against
Notes
• Washington and Moehrig's nine combined interceptions rank first nationally among returning safeties.
• The TCU duo's combined completion rate allowed (36.95%) is also the best of the aforementioned group.
• Hamlin and Ford's combined completion rate allowed (48.83%) is the worst of the four tandems, and their average passer rating against (57.46) is the highest of the bunch.
The variables
For the most part, 2019 data narrows down the top duos. But the numbers don't account for everything in play here.
For example, Texas stud Caden Sterns hasn't been mentioned yet. Why? The 2018 Big 12 Defensive Freshman of the Year and first-team all-conference safety missed four games last season due to injury. He didn't have the chance to follow up his four-interception, 62-tackle introduction to the college game. Perhaps he'll return in full with an equally impressive partner in the back end.
Same goes for Georgia's Richard LeCounte. He's a first-round selection in way-too-early 2021 mock drafts. But will a Bulldog step up and form a dynamic duo alongside him?
Tyler Coyle, the aforementioned UConn safety who logged 7.62 tackles per game in 2019, is still in the transfer portal. Where does he end up? Say he goes to Texas, Florida State or Arizona State. There's another duo worth looking at if he links up with Sterns, Nasirildeen or Crosswell.
We mentioned Vincent and LSU earlier. The system run by former defensive coordinator Dave Aranda, who left to become Baylor's head coach, employed three “safeties.” Though LSU considers Vincent (four INTs) a safety on the roster sheet, he's really a nickelback. How will he be defined and used by new play-caller Bo Pelini? Will he link up with safety JaCoby Stevens (85 tackles, five sacks, three INTs in 2019) in the back-end? Or will that role end up with Todd Harris, who was injured early in the 2019 campaign?
If we were dissecting the best trio of safeties, LSU probably has it in the bag. But we're not. Best tandem “right now,” as Narduzzi put it, is what we're seeking. Which makes it hard to factor in the situations at Texas, Georgia and LSU — and any other variables up in the air.
The verdict
If this were up to Pro Football Focus, strictly in its analytics vacuum, Ford and Hamlin wouldn't make the top two safety duos in the country. Back in January, the website ranked its 30 best returning defensive backs. Eight of them were safeties, and neither Ford nor Hamlin were listed.
Moehrig (No. 5 overall among DBs) and Washington (No. 9) were PFF's highest-ranked safeties, suggesting the site sees TCU's duo as college football's best back-end tandem. Oklahoma State's Harvell-Peel (No. 13) and Tre Sterling (No. 28) were the only other duo included.
PFF did select Ford for its All-ACC first team, complimenting his hard-hitting “brand of football seldom seen in today's landscape,” while leaving Hamlin out of consideration entirely. Not even an honorable mention nod.
Thankfully for Ford and Hamlin stans, PFF doesn't determine everything. But there is something to be said for why the site graded and recognized other safeties.
Frankly, Ford and Hamlin's coverage skills lack in comparison. Their combined passes defended can't be ignored, but neither can their passer rating and completion rate allowed. Both could have gone to the NFL, but that doesn't mean there aren't any weaknesses to be bolstered.
Now, from a reliable tackling perspective, Ford and Hamlin might be the most productive sure thing anyone could ask out of a safety tandem in 2020. They're almost always in the right spot at the right time. Rarely do they miss a tackle. Ford, especially, makes stops near the line of scrimmage others wouldn't, thanks to his uncanny instincts.
Based on the numbers alone, Moehrig and Washington at TCU and Harvell-Peel and Sterling from Oklahoma State are better cover safeties than Ford and Hamlin entering 2020. That's not really deniable, should they replicate their 2019 success next season.
But Narduzzi has said before he wouldn't trade Hamlin and Ford for anyone. And that's fair, given what they bring to Pitt's defense, which is reliant on its corners making plays in press coverage and its safeties laying the lumber.
Ford and Hamlin may not be the top all-around safety tandem in the country. But they're arguably the best for what Pitt needs in 2020, with room to grow. And really, that's all that matters.
John McGonigal: jmcgonigal@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jmcgonigal9





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.