Post-Gazette readers have spoken, and they think Pitt’s ACC rival is the team it joined the conference with six years ago.

Polling by CivicScience conducted last week found that 40% of 655 respondents view the series with Syracuse as the Panthers’ top conference grudge match.

The teams have met 73 times, with many of those matchups coming in the old Big East Conference. Pitt has a 39-31-3 edge and has won five of the six meetings since both schools defected to the ACC in 2013.

One other former Big East foe fared well in the poll, as Virginia Tech pulled in 26% of the vote. No other ACC school really resonated with fans, though.

Advertise with us

The third most popular choice for a rival in the poll was “no one” at 20%. North Carolina, which has beaten Pitt each of the six times the teams have met as conference opponents, was next with just 7% of the vote. Miami followed with 5% while Duke and Georgia Tech barely registered with 1%.

Some readers weighed in with their thoughts on the topic on social media, in the comments section and via email. Here are some of those responses.

Reader Matthew Nester, via email:

This is a really tough question, Adam. None of these come close to stirring up as much hatred as Penn State does. Of course, it is hard to hate anything anywhere close to as much as Penn State. They are so, so deserving. None of these come close to stirring up as much hatred as West Virginia does, either. While a far cry from Penn State, the proximity and history make me have a strong hatred for them, too. I guess I would have to go Virginia Tech. We have been playing them for a while now, and, unlike Miami, they haven’t dominated us.

Reader TS in the comments:

I think in order to be a rival, the other team has to consider you their rival, too. Miami does not consider Pitt their rival. Syracuse maybe. North Carolina and Virginia Tech, no. Pitt doesn’t have a rivalry right now, plain and simple. They should, with West Virginia, but I don’t know if either team wants to restart the backyard brawl. I would walk from the Penn State deal after this year, and not look back, if I were Pitt. 

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.