Penn State is (voluntarily) rotating off Pitt’s football schedule after this season. That will leave a rivalry-shaped hole in the Panthers’ slate for a couple of years until a four-year Backyard Brawl series with West Virginia begins in 2022.

That makes now as good a time as any to take stock of what Pitt has in its ACC schedule, entering its seventh season of conference membership. Is there a rival in the bunch?

Below are breakdowns of seven annual opponents — six from the Coastal division and one protected series from the Atlantic — for your consideration. Let us know your thoughts in our attached poll, the comments section, on social media and via email — sports@post-gazette.com and abittner@post-gazette.com. We’ll include some of the best responses in a follow-up post.

North Carolina — If your rival is your nemesis, then no other team is close. The Tar Heels have beaten Pitt each of the first six times they’ve played as conference opponents. The games have been frustratingly close, too, with none being decided by more than a touchdown. The nadir was a 34-31 home loss to a 2-8 North Carolina team in 2017. It probably should have been a gimme that would have made the Panthers bowl eligible. Instead, they blew it in a prime-time matchup and went on to miss the postseason for the first time since 2007. So there’s plenty of reason for animosity from a Pitt perspective, but that doesn’t seem likely to be reciprocated until the Panthers win a few games.

Advertise with us

Duke — It’s been a different story for Pitt on the other side of Tobacco Road. The Panthers are 5-1 against the Blue Devils as conference opponents. It’s not a simple story of domination, though. The games have been *wild,* featuring scores that resemble those of the conference’s rough-and-tumble hardwood circuit. The first meeting in 2013 was a 58-55 slug fest of a Pitt victory in Durham, then Duke returned the favor by prevailing in a 51-48 double-overtime shootout at Heinz Field the following year.

Last season, Pitt began a four-game winning streak that clinched a division championship by erasing deficits of 11 and 10 points in the second half to hold Duke off by a 54-45 margin. So the series isn’t lacking for entertainment value. Still, the Blue Devils might have to deal a few more humbling defeats before Panthers fans begin caring about them.

Syracuse — Speaking of wild games, the first of three old Big East foes on this list was the opponent for one no Pitt fan will soon forget. The Panthers and Orange combined for a whopping 137 points and 20 touchdowns in a 76-61 Pitt win at Heinz Field in the 2016 regular-season finale for both teams. It shattered a lot of records and defines this series — at least the ACC portion of it.

Historically, the series has been pretty even; Pitt has a 39-31-3 edge. The last 30 years have been pretty lopsided. Syracuse dominated through Pitt’s dark days in the 1990s, and the Panthers have gotten the better of play since. Perhaps the Orange’s resurgence last season to finish 10-3 could be a signal of more of a back-and-forth to come between these teams, who meet every year despite playing in different divisions.

Miami — This series has been one-sided since its Big East days. The Hurricanes own a 26-11-1 advantage all-time, with only three of those Pitt wins coming since the national championship season of 1976. In its ACC iteration, Miami’s relative mediocrity following its dominant run in the 1980s, ‘90s and early aughts has taken the sizzle out of most of the games, with one very notable exception.

Advertise with us

Pitt’s 24-14 win against the second-ranked Hurricanes at Heinz Field in the regular season finale in 2017 was the Panthers’ biggest against a divisional opponent and put some shine back on what was otherwise a lost season. It could be an inflection point for a more competitive series in the years to come, but that remains to be seen.

Virginia Tech — The series history isn’t long, but it’s contentious. The Hokies hold a narrow 10-8 edge since the two first met as Big East opponents in 1993. The Panthers, however, have owned them in big games. Pitt beat Virginia Tech teams ranked in the top 12 each year from 2001 to 2003. The latter two of the three wins came against top five teams and sent the Hokies into the ACC with a bitter taste in their mouths. In ACC play, the sides are an even 3-3, though Pitt did win a non-conference matchup in 2012. The games have mattered, too, as the winner has won the Coastal division in two of the past three years. One of them got Pat Narduzzi all worked up. A lot of ingredients to work with here.

Georgia Tech — Yes, we’re including the Yellow Jackets on this list because this series has been a competitive 3-3 since it became an annual affair. Granted, there’s not a lot of regional tension here and the games have not had the highest profile. They have been entertaining. There was Pitt’s spectacular meltdown that included turnovers on five straight possessions in a 56-28 loss in 2014.

Then there were back-to-back thrillers in 2015 and ‘16 in which Pat Narduzzi got two of his grittiest wins as Pitt coach. Sometimes the quirky, odd-ball grudge matches are the best in college sports, so don’t rule this series out simply because it doesn’t seem like a natural fit.

Virginia — The Cavaliers have been mostly garbage since Pitt joined the conference, and the series reflects that, as the Panthers own a 5-1 mark. The best you can say is that their 2018 meeting was pivotal in the Coastal race. Pitt’s 23-13 win in the Charlottesville rain put them in commanding position to meet Clemson for the ACC title.

Advertise with us

If they’re ever good at the same time, proximity could add some flavor to the teams’ matchups. That, however, will require Virginia to put together more than one decent season.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.