Capel reacts to loss to Niagara

The signs were there.

Surprising and jarring as Pitt’s 71-70 loss to Niagara Monday night at the Petersen Events Center was, players and coaches alike could sense something about this night, something that told them this game against a relatively anonymous opponent from a small private school in western New York may end differently than many anticipated.

Senior Jared Wilson-Frame felt it before his team even took to the court, going back to what he thought was a lethargic practice the previous day that lacked any of the energy and focus that had helped propel the Panthers in their first eight games. Prior to tip-off, coach Jeff Capel watched as Marvin Prochet, the Purple Eagles’ injured star forward, huddled his teammates around him. Even in that moment, as he stared 90 feet away on the other end of the court, Capel could feel an excitement and enthusiasm for the upcoming game that his team was never able to match.

Two hours later, as the jarring sound of the final buzzer pierced a frustrated, disgruntled arena, Pitt’s worst fears and most ominous inklings had been realized. A season defined up to that point by hope and progress had been dealt a disheartening and uncharacteristic setback.

Advertise with us

“We can’t just turn it on and off,” Wilson-Frame said. “We cannot do that. No basketball team can do that and we’re definitely not the basketball team that can do that.”

In a season in which the Panthers (7-2) have defeated two Atlantic 10 teams and lost by just one on the road against a top-15 Big Ten team, the loss represented the nadir of the still-nascent campaign.

The Purple Eagles (3-4), victorious as they were Monday, were picked before the season to finish ninth in the 11-team Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference and entered the night with losses to the likes of Saint Francis (Pa.), St. Francis (N.Y.) and Grambling State. To add insult to injury, they won without Prochet, who averages a team-high 20 points and 11.3 rebounds per game.

Sandwiched between rivalry games against Duquesne on one end and West Virginia on another, the matchup with Niagara could have been aptly described as a trap game for Pitt. In reality, the loss may have been just as much a product of a team too impressed or content with its 7-1 record.

“As a team, we probably thought we were a little better than we were,” Wilson-Frame said. “We were on a little high horse because we’re looking and we’ve got wins in the win column, close enough to the wins we even had last year. We had a game where we could have did that and taken care of that problem, right away from the jump, from the tip. But nobody, not even myself, was ready. I blame myself for that.”

Advertise with us

It finished the game with a season-high 18 turnovers, with four of its five starters having at least three. Though his team held Niagara to just 0.91 points per possession, Capel bemoaned the Panthers’ defensive effort, citing the lack of togetherness and tenacity.

Offensively, they had just as many, and perhaps more, problems. Against a zone defense that sought to neutralize dribble penetration from the speedy likes of freshmen Xavier Johnson and Trey McGowens, Pitt frequently looked disjointed and out of rhythm, shooting just 42.1 percent from the field, its second-lowest mark of the season, and regularly being whistled for offensive fouls on sometimes out-of-control drives.

“They’re very aggressive,” Niagara coach Chris Casey said. “We felt we had to find a way to take something away. What we really attempted to do was take drives away. We knew we were going to give up some 3s doing that, but I don’t think you can play it straight.”

Even without Prochet, the Purple Eagles outrebounded the Panthers, 38-31, and finished with 14 second-chance points, compared to only three for Pitt. It was one of many things that told the story of a 16-point home favorite that spent much of the night on its heels.

“I don’t think there was anything we handled well,” Capel said. “That’s on me and our staff. We have to do a better job. I don’t think we handled anything well that they did. They outplayed us in every facet of the game.”

Advertise with us

Pitt’s three freshmen carried much of its scoring load, as Johnson (19 points), McGowens (12) and guard/forward Au’Diese Toney (12) accounted for 43 of the team’s 70 points. Toney also added a team-high nine rebounds while Wilson-Frame had six assists.

As poorly as they played, and despite trailing by 12 with nearly six minutes remaining, the Panthers had an opportunity to snatch a win, even on a night in which they may have not deserved it. A Wilson-Frame 3-pointer trimmed his team’s deficit to one with eight seconds remaining and after forcing a turnover on the ensuing inbound pass, Pitt got it into Johnson, who drove to the basket and got a clean look, only to see his layup from high off the glass rattle around the rim before falling outside of it.

While Pitt’s players walked to the locker room in disbelief and agony, Niagara’s players rushed on the court and embraced one another in jubilation. A celebration few outside of themselves had expected had come to be.

“It meant a ton to me,” said Niagara forward Dominic Robb, a Pittsburgh native and North Catholic graduate who finished with 12 points. “I love this city. I always wanted to play here and it ended up senior year, just perfect timing to get to come here. I felt awesome playing. I always wanted to play here since I was a kid. To get a win here is just huge for us. My teammates all supported me. They all said ‘You’re coming home. Let’s get a win.’”

And get a win they did.

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG