Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Larry Murphy and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Gino Ceriani, @Gino_Ceriani: What do you think of Pens giving up on Sprong without giving him a chance playing top 6?
Starkey: I think the most amazing part of the Sprong saga, Mr. Ceriani, is that he’s still only 21. My God, it feels like he’s been around longer than Kelly Buchberger, and it feels like every time the Penguins faltered over the past four years, the fallback position for many was: Sprong can fix it!
And yet, as you say, he never really got a chance to prove himself in the only position he really could prove himself, which was in the top six. Sprong might not even be an NHL player, but if he is, it has to be in an offensive role with skilled players around him. His outstanding characteristic is that dynamite release. He’s a goal scorer. If you don’t put him in a goal-scoring situation, you’re wasting your time. And everyone else’s.
Having said that, I have to believe if either Sidney Crosby or Evgeni Malkin desperately wanted to play with Sprong, he would have been given more of a shot up there. Instead, he got a heavy dose of Derek Grant and pressbox popcorn in his final weeks here (and who knows — maybe a stint with Derick Brassard might have saved them both).
There is also a bit of a logjam on the right side here, as you well know.
Read More
I would love to have seen Sprong get a long look with Sid. I would love to have seen a talented young forward get a real chance on one of the oldest teams in the league. But, Mike Sullivan obviously didn’t believe Sprong could help him — and, in case you haven’t noticed over the past three years, Sullivan is right a lot. He believes Dominik Simon is a better fit, and he appears well justified in that belief.
As for the return, it’s definitely too bad Marcus Pettersson isn’t Elias Pettersson, but them are the breaks. What he is, is a lanky, somewhat intriguing player who apparently delivers a nice breakout pass and gives the Penguins something they needed — a promising young defenseman.
Now if only they had some more promising young forwards.
Kevin Groden, @dubv01: Why is Mike Tomlin so bad at challenging calls? Seriously, I am having trouble ever remembering him winning one and they don’t even appear to be close.
Starkey: Well, Mr. Groden, if you were 2 years old, you wouldn’t remember Tomlin ever having won a challenge because he hasn’t won one since 2016.
After a robust start to his challenging career, Tomlin has gone full Brian Bixler. He was 0 for 4 last year and is 0 for 4 this year, according to profootballreference.com. He wins challenges less frequently than Daniel Sprong scores goals, and he seems particularly obsessed with spot-of-the-ball plays.
The folks at thecomeback.com broke it down last year and determined that between 2015-17, Tomlin had the worst challenge rate in the NFL at 3 for 12 (25 percent). Next-worst was old friend Bruce Arians at 30 percent (the best were Doug Marrone at 8-for-11 and Mike McCarthy at 10-for-15, so let’s not read too much into this).
I wonder who, exactly, is in Tomlin’s ear on these things. We know Mike Sullivan’s challenge guy is Andy Saucier (who helped the Penguins win two Cups), and we know Clint Hurdle’s challenge guy is Kevin Roche (Hurdle won about half his challenges last season).
Who is Tomlin’s guy? Does he have a guy?
He needs a guy. Or a better guy.
Hopefully he wins a challenge before your third birthday, Kevin — and before Daniel Sprong starts lighting it up in Anaheim.
Joel Alexander, @Joel_Closer: Why didn’t the Steelers pursue C.J. Anderson once Le’Veon Bell didn’t report? Conner may not be able to play a full season and it’s a completely different season in the playoffs
Starkey: I’ve got a better question, Mr. Closer: Why don’t they sign Anderson NOW? Stevan Ridley clearly is not in this team’s plans. He keeps getting a hat only to be sat. Anderson rushed for 1,000 yards last season. He’s a good all-around back. Carolina signed him as insurance for Christian McCaffrey and didn’t need the insurance (at least not yet). The Steelers do. Kansas City, in the wake of cutting Kareem Hunt, brought in Anderson and Charcandrick West for visits on Monday and signed West. The Steelers should sign Anderson.
Craig McConnell, @craigpmcconnell: Do you expect a down judge to lose his job?
Starkey: From the Steelers game the other night, you mean, Mr. McConnell, and it wouldn’t be a surprise if the league took action. That was an abomination, particularly at the line of scrimmage.
The Chargers’ right tackle, Sam Tevi, was moving early all game — even once on the winning field-goal drive if you look closely.
If you look at the NFL Ops web site, you will see the various responsibilities of the officials, and you will see that the umpire, down judge and line judge all have some at the line of scrimmage.
The umpire, for example, “watches for false starts on offensive line” on pass plays.
The umpire was Bruce Stritesky, and it’s hard to imagine what he could have been looking at all night — particularly on Tevi’s comically early false start on the Chargers’ first touchdown. I’ve seen players just stop playing when a guy jumps that early.
It has also become apparent that the Chargers snapper illegally moved the ball before snapping it on those final field-goal attempts.
Referee Bill Vinovich’s crew, which included down judge Phil McKinnely and line judge Mark Perlman, at the very least should be mortified by its performance upon review.
The rest of us were mortified watching it live.
NerfHoopDreams, @NerfHoopDreams: Why aren't penalties (or missed penalties) reviewable? They still have limited challenges, it's not like a coach can review every play.
Starkey: Great question. I wouldn’t say holding calls and such should be reviewable, Mr. NerfHoopDreams (great handle there), but certainly offside, illegal motion and the like should be. Bill Belichick has called for more plays to be reviewable. Tevi jumping three hours early on the touchdown pass the other night should have been an easily reviewable play. Ridiculous that it’s not reviewable when something like the spot of the ball (much harder to detect in most instances) is.
MFH, @FakeHoltzy22: At your current athletic ability, could you cover Keenan Allen better than the Steelers did?
Starkey: At least as well, Mr. Holtzy22. At least as well. Which is to say, not at all.
Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.