NOTRE DAME, Ind. — Kenny Pickett’s voice wavered a bit as he kept afloat a passionate defense of his coach, and Pat Narduzzi likely needed one after one of the most puzzling decisions of his Pitt tenure, which crossed the halfway mark of Year 4 with Saturday’s come-from-ahead loss at No. 5 Notre Dame.
The overarching story of this 19-14 defeat is that Pitt nearly pulled it off, but couldn’t quite finish the job. Plenty of bricks went into that wall, but one that stands out from the rest is a fake punt that was as bizarre as it was unsuccessful, a decision that yanked Pitt’s offense from the field and put the ball — and, arguably at the time, the game — in the hands of a third-string quarterback who had never taken a snap with the Panthers.
“That certainly wasn’t the game, I can tell you that,” Narduzzi said postgame as he faced questions about the call.
But let’s launch into it anyway, because it was a true man-bites-dog moment in the final minutes.
Instead of regular starting punter Kirk Christodoulou, who’s No. 98, a mystery man wearing No. 96 with no name on the back of the jersey trotted onto the field and lined up to punt on fourth-and-4 at Pitt’s 45, with a little less than four minutes left and Notre Dame ahead, 19-14.
Pat Narduzzi on Pitt's loss to No. 5 Notre Dame
The “punter,” whoever it was, took the snap and had no intention of punting. Immediately, it was clearly a fake — the play and the player. He rolled right, looking to throw, but nothing materialized. Finally, he had to get some kind of pass off, and it sailed listlessly out of bounds, gifting Notre Dame the ball in Panthers territory.
Read More
Naturally, NBC broadcaster Mike Tirico assumed it was an errant attempt by Australian native Christodoulou, who grew up playing a different sport, let alone quarterback. He then realized it was No. 96, but there was no player with that number on Pitt’s team travel roster. Tirico mentioned freshman walk-on defensive end Chris Maloney, Pitt’s only 96 on the official roster, but he didn’t make the trip. So who was it?
It was Jeff George Jr., a redshirt junior quarterback who decided to join Pitt in late August as a graduate transfer from Michigan, where he never played a down after leaving Illinois — also the alma mater of his famous football father — following last season. George has been eligible at Pitt for a few weeks now, but had never played — until he pulled that 96 jersey over top of his No. 3, with a George Jr. nameplate that could still be seen through the top layer as he stood on the sideline in the wake of that doomed trick play.
What was the reasoning, or thought process, for Narduzzi on that one?
“To get a first down,” he muttered.
Was there something he’d seen from Notre Dame that gave him the idea it could work?
“Yeah. Yeah. The guy who was supposed to slip out of there tripped and fell.”
Once George Jr. removed his helmet, and thus, to some extent, his disguise, the TV crew figured out who was the makeshift specialist. According to Narduzzi, Pitt has practiced that with George getting the snap.
“Yeah, we had a quarterback in there making the call,” Narduzzi said, affirming that he thought George was the best option.
Pitt QB Kenny Pickett on missed chance vs. Notre Dame
But that meant his No. 1 quarterback, Pickett, along with tailbacks Qadree Ollison and Darrin Hall, kick-return maven Maurice Ffrench and the rest of the supporting cast were on the bench. Notre Dame gave the ball back with a turnover on downs, credit to Pitt’s defense, but the offense was unable to spark anything on their next and final series.
“It’s coach Duzz’s call, and I back him till death,” Pickett said. “I love that guy to death, so whatever he thinks is best, is best. You know, everyone else wants to be a football expert out in this world and they have no clue what the hell they’re talking about — a majority of the time.
“No offense to any of you guys [in the media] but sometimes it’s you guys, too. That’s just the flat-out truth of it. That’s coach Duzz’s call, and I back him 100 percent.”
If Pitt manages to pull that one off and goes on to win, Narduzzi looks like a mastermind. Instead, the opposite happened. For his part, Irish coach Brian Kelly said he sent in the personnel group he uses against “fake punts and offensive sets.”
Pitt has had its moments before on punt fakes and special teams chicanery — think backup long-snapper Nathan Bossory’s touchdown reception last year at Virginia Tech — but this time, the plan went very awry, and it contributed to the Panthers’ missed opportunity.
“It’s absolutely frustrating,” Pickett said of the near-miss. “I think you can hear it in my voice right now. It’s frustrating.”
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.