NOTRE DAME, Ind. — It didn’t take long for the college football world’s ears to perk up and take stock of Pitt’s latest upset effort, this time at one of the holy grounds of the sport.
By the time it was over, that notice was fully served on a picture-perfect fall day at Notre Dame Stadium, a picture-perfect Saturday afternoon for the Panthers to do the unthinkable again.
Pitt held the lead for more than 40 minutes, but it needed more. What transpired in the end was No. 5 Notre Dame 19, Pitt 14. Not quite three seasons in a row with a stunner against a team ranked in the Top 5 for the Panthers, who nonetheless found a way to factor into the national conversation by virtue of testing an undefeated College Football Playoff candidate.
“We took a Top 5 team all the way to the wire, and for whatever reason … ” Narduzzi said, then shrugged. “You figure it out. I can figure it out, you guys can figure it out. We didn’t pull it out in the end.”
It’s hard to make sense of from Narduzzi, who told his players, “sometimes you can’t control what you can’t control.” That would seem to be a veiled comment about officiating, as Pitt had eight penalties for 80 yards to Notre Dame’s four for 45, but plenty else also went wrong for the Panthers (3-4).
Pat Narduzzi on Pitt's loss to No. 5 Notre Dame
The wind really left their sails when Fighting Irish quarterback Ian Book — who was 13 of 14 for 158 yards in the second half — lofted a touchdown pass right into the waiting arms of Miles Boykin, 35 yards over top of cornerback Dane Jackson in coverage. That put the ball in the hands of a Panthers offense that struggled to generate much momentum after its dominant touchdown march to open the scoring, and quarterback Kenny Pickett’s unit faltered on two separate possessions in the final five minutes.
Read More
First it was a mind-boggling fake punt on fourth-and-4 from the Panthers 45, one that was especially bizarre even for that sort of trick play. Instead of starting punter Kirk Christodoulou, Pitt trotted out a mystery man wearing No. 96 with no name on the back. Unmasked, it turned out to be third-string graduate-transfer quarterback Jeff George Jr., who rolled right and looked to throw, let it fly but came up empty.
Pitt’s defense forced a turnover on downs on the ensuing Notre Dame series, but then things went even further south for the Panthers offense. Pickett was sacked for a loss of 14, then threw three consecutive incompletions to halt the upset bid.
“Tight ballgame,” Narduzzi said. “We were ahead almost the entire game, and our kids played their tails off. … Went toe-to-toe with a Top 5 team. We’ve played two other Top 10 teams, and didn't go toe-to-toe because we hurt ourselves.”
At halftime, Pitt was staked to a 7-6 lead. The Panthers didn’t race out to their 7-0 advantage so much as they trudged to it, thanks to forcing an Irish punt on the game’s opening possession, then stringing together a textbook drive of methodical rushing that took almost 10 minutes.
The Panthers went 88 yards in 17 plays over 9:43, capped by Qadree Ollison’s 9-yard touchdown run on third down, out of Pitt’s upstart Wildcat formation. If that wasn’t enough of an early upset alert, on the ensuing Notre Dame drive, Book tossed just his second interception of the season, picked off by sophomore cornerback Jason Pinnock.
Pitt QB Kenny Pickett on missed chance vs. Notre Dame
That was the final play of the first quarter, and by the end of it, the Irish (7-0) trailed for the first time all year after the first 15 minutes. Ollison’s score also provided the largest (and just second) deficit in 2018 for Notre Dame, which may need to finish the regular season unblemished to secure itself a spot in the Playoff. The Irish hadn’t been behind since it was 3-0 against Wake Forest three weeks ago, before reeling off back-to-back wins over ranked teams, Stanford and Virginia Tech.
While the last play of the first quarter was a jolt for Pitt, it couldn’t hold a candle to the first play of the third. Narduzzi’s decision to defer upon winning the coin toss proved prescient, as Maurice Ffrench opted to return the second-half kickoff from the 1, rather than fair-catch it, quickly angled toward the sideline and then beat everyone down it for a 99-yard touchdown that made it 14-6.
“Coming out of the tunnel, we were so amped up that we were even saying, ‘We need one play,’ ” Ffrench said.
It was a spark, and the defense even capitalized on it, with safety Jazzee Stocker picking off Book again as the Irish neared the red zone. But that would go down as Book’s final miscue, and the third quarter would see kicker Alex Kessman miss two field-goal attempts, including a 47-yarder after Stocker’s takeaway. Kessman, who hit from 45, 54 and 55 just last week, also pushed a 36-yarder wide right early in the fourth quarter.
“We had them on the ropes in the fourth. If we don’t leave any of those drives to field goals and we punch it in ourselves, it’s a whole different story,” said Pickett, who was adamant about not blaming Kessman. “That’s on the offense. We have to go down there and score.”
Pitt’s offense finished with just 242 yards, Pickett going 19 of 28 for 126. On the other side, Book ended up 26 for 32 for 264 yards, two scores and two interceptions, as he got Notre Dame’s offense back on track just in time to dodge a disastrous mark on its record.
The Panthers defense came to play from the jump, posting three sacks and limiting the Irish to just 80 yards rushing in addition to the turnovers, but it didn’t sustain for a full game and wasn’t enough to pick up the offense’s slack. Two years running, an otherwise middling Pitt squad had found ways to stun undefeated, highly ranked opponents under Narduzzi, and it seemed the magic was happening again in South Bend, until it didn’t.
“Every loss feels the same,” Pickett said. “You come into every game, no matter what team you’re playing, to win. I wasn’t surprised. I know everyone else is surprised, but that was exactly what we thought was going to happen."
NOTES -— Leading receiver Taysir Mack didn't make the trip and has now missed two consecutive games with a lower-body injury from the Central Florida loss. … Pitt now has an off week before finishing the season with five ACC games.
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.