Pitt’s odds in its trip to Notre Dame a decade ago weren’t quite as long as they’ll be this weekend, when the Panthers travel to face a Fighting Irish squad ranked in the top five.
They weren’t great, though.
Coach Dave Wannstedt’s squad was coming off a humiliating 54-34 home loss to Rutgers in which quarterback Bill Stull was injured and taken off the Heinz Field turf on a stretcher. Stull was subsequently ruled out for the Nov. 1, 2008, trip to Notre Dame, Ind., and the outlook only got worse once the game started.
Backup Pat Bostick struggled to find his rhythm, causing Pitt to punt on three of its first four possessions. He then threw a costly interception just before the half, and Notre Dame quarterback Jimmy Clausen made him pay by turning a short field into a 4-yard touchdown pass to Michael Floyd that gave his team a commanding 17-3 lead after 30 minutes.
Less than an ideal, but it all turned out to be merely a prelude for Pitt’s wild comeback to win the longest game in both programs’ storied histories.

“When you throw picks, it’s not about you,” Bostick told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette of his early struggles afterward. “You can’t say, ‘Woe is me.’ ”
Read More
He didn’t. Instead, the Panthers came out of the locker room and showed some fight quickly. On the first drive, Bostick found Oderick Turner for 37 yards to the Notre Dame 4, and LaRod Stephens-Howling cashed in a play later, plunging across the goal line for a touchdown that got his team back into the game at 17-10.
That’s when things started to get wacky.
After Pitt forced a punt on the ensuing Notre Dame possession, Bostick threw another pick. This time, his defense picked him up by forcing Notre Dame to turn the ball over on downs.
Enter Panthers star running back LeSean McCoy. After an exchange of punts, he began to impose his will on the Irish in the fourth quarter, turning five consecutive carries into 32 yards and the tying touchdown for Pitt.
Notre Dame answered with a 6-yard touchdown pass from Clausen to Golden Tate, but McCoy simply sparked his team again, this time with an 18-yard run to the Irish 14 that set up receiver Jonathan Baldwin for a 10-yard touchdown catch that knotted the score, 24-24.
“I had a slow start because I was trying to find things that weren’t there instead of just hitting them, and that is kind of the problem I had at the beginning of the year,” said McCoy, who finished the day with 169 yards on 32 carries. “I just relaxed and couldn’t let all this hype being at Notre Dame get to me, and so I just relaxed and the line played great. I had some confidence in them and we just started hitting some things.
“I took it on myself [when the team was down at the half], I had to play for my team.”

The fireworks were far from over as regulation ended in a rather dysfunctional stalemate.
Notre Dame got the ball back with a little more than two minutes remaining and blew its chance to take the lead when Pitt stuffed a fourth-and-1 run by Clausen at midfield for no gain.
Not to be outdone, Bostick squandered excellent field position to drive for a possible game-winning field goal by throwing his third interception with 20 seconds remaining. That took the game to overtime, and arguably senior Pitt kicker Conor Lee’s finest hour.
Both offenses sputtered with multiple opportunities to win. Pitt’s first possession of overtime stalled at the Notre Dame 5. Notre Dame’s subsequently failed to cash in from the Pitt 4.
The game proceeded with Lee and Irish kicker Brandon Walker trading field goals of various lengths … until Walker blinked.
His miss, wide to the left from 38 yards out in the fourth overtime, meant that Lee needed only to nail a fourth pressure-packed kick, his fifth of the game, to give his team the win. McCoy set him up for a short kick by snapping off an 18-yard run to the Notre Dame 6, and Wannstedt ran just one more play before calling on his kicker to win the game from 22 yards away.
Lee was money, banging the ball between the uprights. Final, 4OT: Pitt 36, Notre Dame 33.
“It’s something I think every kicker wants to have happen,” Lee told The Associated Press afterward. “I was like, I guess I won the game. Time to celebrate.”
It might not have been the biggest win in Pitt history. Notre Dame wasn’t nationally ranked and finished an uninspiring 7-6.
In retrospect, though, the game proved to be a bit of a catalyst for bigger things to come. Pitt finished the season by winning three out of four games to get to nine wins for the first time since 2002, and the following year, many of the same characters contributed to Pitt’s first 10-win season since 1981.
At the very least, it was a classic win worth savoring, and that’s exactly what Wannstedt did.
“I can’t describe the heart that our football team has,” he said afterward. “We’ve come back before but never on the road against a quality football team like Notre Dame.
“We never folded. No one came unglued.”
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.