It’s difficult to pinpoint the moment when the glory days of the Pitt-Penn State rivalry ended.

Was it 1982, when Penn State was rejected by the Big East before Pitt joined it instead? Was it 1989, the year Penn State agreed to join the Big Ten and removed Pitt from its annual schedule in short order? Was it 1984, the year Foge Fazio’s Panthers faded from a No. 3 preseason ranking to a 3-7-1 finish and a period of mediocrity that endures to this day? Was it as late as 2000, when Pitt beat Penn State in their last meeting before a 16-year hiatus that turned the rivalry into more of a cold war?

Certainly all of those events were factors in the series fading from its status as one of the best in college football. If we’re talking about on-field moments, though, you can make a pretty good argument that things were never the same after Pitt’s 10-0 triumph on Nov. 14, 1987 at Pitt Stadium.

The game is the series’ most recent prime-time matchup, at least until their 2018 meeting kicks off Saturday night at Heinz Field. And unlike most of the games that followed until the first modern hiatus began in 1993, it meant something.

Advertise with us
A Pitt fan with a Joe Paterno mask watches the Panthers take on Penn State, Nov. 15, 1987, at Pitt Stadium. (Marlene Karas / Pittsburgh Press)

Penn State was ranked 16th and had designs on a big bowl game. Pitt was unranked but a solid 6-3 with a big upset of No. 4 Notre Dame on its resume. Not quite the national championship stakes of the 1970s and early ’80s. But it was enough to stir the echoes of those days.

The bad blood was still there, too. Pitt was still upset about an skirmish from the year before that purportedly ended with Joe Paterno calling Pitt players a “disgrace to college football.” Paterno later said he’d been referring to participants from both teams, but the narrative stuck on the Panthers’ end.

The football was hard-nosed and ugly, too.

Both offenses failed to execute on multiple drives deep into each other’s territory. Pitt’s Craig “Ironhead” Heyward was a standout, piling up 160 yards on 24 carries, but teammate Jeff Van Horne missed three field goal attempts, and Penn State’s Ray Tarasi had two blocked. Van Horne’s first-quarter conversion accounted for the only points scored by either side until the final minute.

Pitt kicker Jeff Van Horne celebrates with holder Bill Osborn after a first-quarter field against Penn State (Marlene Karas / Pittsburgh Press)

The ending was even worse for the Nittany Lions as their late efforts to tie or take the lead following Van Horne’s third miss with 6:11 remaining were repeatedly thwarted.

Advertise with us

“What I said in my mind was — I was thinking the worst — that Penn State was going to go down and make a field goal, and I’m going to have to make the game winner,” Van Horne told The Pittsburgh Press afterward.

He didn’t.

Instead, Tarasi’s crucial attempt with 4:15 remaining was blocked. Then Pitt’s Billy Owens intercepted Penn State quarterback Matt Knizer and returned the ball for a touchdown with 20 seconds remaining, prompting celebratory fans to tear down the goal post in Pitt Stadium’s north end zone.

It was the coup de grace in Paterno’s first loss at Pitt Stadium. And the Panthers didn’t shy away from crowing about it once the final seconds ticked off the clock.

“We’ve been waiting for a year to get them down here after they booed us and called us a disgrace last year,” Panthers defensive end Burt Grossman told the Press after helping hold Nittany Lions star tailback Blair Thomas to just 87 yards on 27 attempts.

Advertise with us
Pitt coach Mike Gottfried expresses frustration with a call. (Marlene Karas / Pittsburgh Press)

It’d be a stretch to the call the game a classic considering the dreadful execution. It was, however, rivalry in the purest sense — raucously heated and unpredictable.

There have been tight, meaningful meetings and cross words since then. The LaVar Leap in 1999, Rod Rutherford’s masterpiece in 2000 and Pitt’s thrilling 42-39 victory at Heinz Field two years ago all rank among some of the rivalry’s best moments.

That said, its golden age ended somewhere before all of that, and if there’s a moment worthy of being the capstone, it’s probably Owens holding the ball aloft as he streaked into history.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24. 

Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.