Derek Gipson was born and raised in Aliquippa, a proud son of a proud town. In all his years there, he has noticed a glaring absence of something.

“I’ve never met a Penn State fan,” he said one day this week. “Never. Not around here. It’s all Pitt.”

Not even 250 steps northeast on Franklin Avenue, Bobby Bonner sat in front of the Uncommon Grounds coffee shop, as he does most mornings from about 6:30 until 10. Atop his head was a blue-and-white cap with Penn State’s Nittany Lion logo as the centerpiece.

Across Western Pennsylvania, Pitt and Penn State fans live among one other, even if it’s sometimes unseen or unspoken. In towns such as Aliquippa that dot the outer reaches of Pittsburgh, the two fan bases divvy up neighborhoods, friendships, offices, even marriages and families.

Advertise with us

Mr. Gipson and Mr. Bonner typify a question without a firm answer heading into Saturday’s football matchup between the two rivals: In a region with so much intermingling, where does the geographic footprint of Pitt’s fan base end and Penn State’s begin?

The reach of the schools and the territory they cover varies, revealing some of the fundamental differences between them.

Penn State is the behemoth, with an undergraduate enrollment of just more than 46,000 and a swath of fans that, between its name and centralized location, stretches across the state and swallows many parts of it. Pitt is the urban research university, with an undergraduate enrollment of about 19,000 students and an identity more closely tied to a city than an entire state.

Though Penn State has 30,416 alumni in Allegheny County — more than any other county in Pennsylvania, according to figures from the university’s alumni association — Pitt is still the predominant team in Pittsburgh and many of the immediate outlying areas. But just how far does that go?

There’s not an ironclad border, no wall around the 412 area code, but there are clear transitional spots in all directions. In 2014, using data measuring a team’s share of Facebook likes in a given area, the New York Times constructed a map of college football fandom, complete with a ZIP-code-by-ZIP-code breakdown of the three most popular schools in a location.

Advertise with us

Many of the results are easy enough to guess. The 15213 ZIP code, which encompasses the vast majority of Pitt’s campus, is 44 percent Pitt fans, compared to 15 percent Penn State fans. Within the city limits, that gap between the two never gets lower than 13 percentage points in Pitt’s favor.

The farther one wanders away from the city center, the more blue and gold gives way to blue and white. In the 16066 ZIP code — which envelops, most notably, Cranberry — the Nittany Lions have a four-percentage-point advantage. Nanty Glo, a town of about 3,000 in Cambria County that’s the closest thing to a geographic midpoint between the two campuses, is home to a 49-percent-to-16-percent difference in Penn State’s favor. By the time one reaches State College, 80 percent of the residents are Penn State fans, with Pitt not even cracking the top three (Notre Dame and Ohio State are tied for second, both at 2 percent).

At some point on that trek away from Pittsburgh, there’s a middle ground. The 15001 ZIP code, with Pitt and Penn State both at 26 percent, is the most curious inclusion. That area most prominently includes Aliquippa, the home of Tony Dorsett, Mike Ditka, Darrelle Revis and Sean Gilbert, among others, a town that is indelibly linked to the history of Pitt football.

Mr. Bonner, a Georgia native who moved to Aliquippa in 1970, saw many of those decorated players pass through over the years and admired them for their accomplishments. But when his niece attended and graduated from Penn State, he picked his side. Many who live around him are Pitt fans, people like Mr. Gipson.

“They pull the string a little bit, but I don’t let that bother me,” Mr. Bonner said.

Advertise with us

The sheer size of the ZIP code — a seven-mile radius that includes Hopewell and West Aliquippa — contributes to the split, as does the area’s history.

“It’s just the complete diversity of this town,” said Joe Samangy, a Hopewell resident and Pitt fan. “You have every ethnic group. It used to be that each neighborhood was like a plan — Plan Seven, Plan 11, Plan 12. When the steel mills first opened in the early 1900s, you lived where your ethnicity was. The Italians lived on Plan 11. The Lebanese lived one place. Plan Six was for the executives at the J&L plant. It’s a very diverse city.”

To the east, the direction one heads to go from Pitt to Penn State, there’s Delmont and the 15626 postal code, about 25 miles from Downtown Pittsburgh and 110 miles from State College, with a 30 percent to 30 percent deadlock between the two sides.

It’s a divide some of its residents know well and experience daily. John Krautbauer, a Delmont resident and the owner of John’s Barber Shop, had children attend Penn State and became a fan. He and his wife still make the trip to Happy Valley occasionally, if even just to go to The Waffle Shop, a popular restaurant in the area. The tension he sees between the two sides, even in the lead-up to Saturday’s game, is minimal, usually limited to good-natured ribbing.

“I’ve got a lot of Penn State customers and a lot of Pitt,” Mr. Krautbauer said. “And they like to jag me because they know I’m Penn State.”

Advertise with us

North of Pittsburgh, the 16059 postal code (containing Valencia, among others) is evenly populated by Pitt and Penn State fans, 29 percent to 29 percent. In nearby Cranberry, a Dick’s Sporting Goods is stocked with the merchandise of both schools. Sales for those items are, one employee said, “very even.”

As one inches closer to the state’s southern border, fandom becomes more convoluted, with allegiances less evenly split between the two sides with the increased emergence of West Virginia supporters. Still, New Stanton and the 15672 ZIP code stands as a good southern border, with Pitt and Penn State both represented at 29 percent.

In those various places, there’s a certain passion over what the football series represents to the region, but it’s a fervor that seldom goes too far, even for all the vitriol the rivalry creates. As it turns out, it’s possible for Panthers and Nittany Lions to live together in relative harmony.

“I haven’t come across anybody who will tear you apart because you’re a Penn State or Pitt fan,” Mr. Krautbauer said. “They’re just good people.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG

Advertise with us

Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.