Editor’s note: Paul Zeise’s son, Elijah, is a scholarship athlete on the Pitt football team.
The rivalry between Pitt and Penn State is dead. Officially. Put a fork in it. Nothing left to see here. Joe Paterno’s ego and a host of bumbling Pitt administrators killed it a long time ago. The game is still fun, but the hatred between the sides seems so forced, so contrived, so disingenuous, that it really has become just another game.
Oh sure, once it kicks off on Saturday night there will be some extra adrenaline pumping among the fans, and the winner will have some sort of bragging rights, but let’s face it: The lead-up to has been, mostly, a stinker.
I get the idea of wanting to be civil and respectful, but this week’s press conferences and media sessions have been downright boring. It’s like every player and coach has been given strict orders to say absolutely nothing. It’s to the point where some fans are trying to squeeze trash talk out of any statement that even seems off-script.
For instance, Penn State’s Miles Sanders sent some of the Pitt fan base into orbit when he said (gasp), “This is just another game.” I don’t buy for a second that he believes that, given he grew up about 10 minutes from Pitt’s campus, played at Woodland Hills and was recruited heavily by the Panthers. He was simply toeing the company line — and frankly, that’s about as innocuous of a statement as there can be. It wasn’t a diss; it simply means that Penn State treats every game the same because they all count the same.
That, however, passes as trash talk in 2018. And then Pat Narduzzi, on his radio show Wednesday, was accused of “throwing shade” — I’m old, but I think that means something similar to “talking trash” — at Penn State defensive back and former Clairton star Lamont Wade.
Read More
Asked what he sees from Wade, Narduzzi answered, “You don't see him a whole lot. You don't see him a lot out there."
Oh, the horror! Narduzzi said a sophomore who played sparingly in the Nittany Lions’ first game played sparingly! That’s incredible — how could he say something so bold?
C’mon, man; this isn’t trash talk. This isn’t even interesting. It makes me long for the days when overly sensitive media relations staffs and coaches allowed a little bit of the players’ personality to shine through, especially leading up to these big games.
I mean, I miss the days of West Virginia’s Richard Bryant declaring, “I’ll be the best Bryant on the field Saturday,” in anticipation of his matchup with Pitt’s Antonio Bryant. The year before that, it was West Virginia safeties Shawn Hackett and Rick Sherrod declaring how much they hate Pitt and Bryant for being, in their opinions, a cheap-shot artist.
I miss the days of Tyler Palko, asked about the “mystique” of Touchdown Jesus and Notre Dame Stadium, answering “That’s for the birds, bro.” That weekend, Palko went out and threw for five touchdowns against the Irish and led Pitt to a huge win — and then dropped his infamous expletive on national television.
He doubled down the next year at Big East media day: “You know these Notre Dame fans are mad at me for swearing on national television,” he said, “but they should be mad that I threw for five touchdown passes against their favorite team.”
And who can forget Darrelle Revis, leading up to a “big game” against a ranked Cincinnati team. “I guess it is a big game, but it is hard to really get up for it like that because in the end, it is Cincinnati. I mean, it’s Cincinnati we are talking about.”
Palko and Revis were always good for saying what was on their mind, and they were given the freedom to speak as they desired. There have been a number of players like that over the years, but recently, that has dried up. Schools have seemingly undergone sensitivity training; players and coaches no longer are allowed to have any personality at all.
I understand why you want to make sure that players are respectful and don’t take cheap shots or say things that cross the line — but all those examples were in good fun. That added spice to the game, a little extra to get fans more engaged.
This week, there has been none of that — nothing at all to add to the hype of this game. It has obviously been overshadowed by the Le’Veon Bell saga, but it still wouldn’t be a bad thing if a couple of players popped off a bit with some harmless trash talk.
The fact that there hasn’t been any — or anything close — speaks volumes about how much spice this “rivalry’ has lost. I’m sure the game will be very competitive, and that the atmosphere will be tremendous, but part of what makes these games fun is the lead-up. And the fact that nobody on either side is allowed to say anything that’s even in the area code of “inflammatory” is a shame.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com, Twitter @PaulZeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.