Brian Batko: Good afternoon, everyone. Chat Narduzzi here. Let's get it cranked up.

H2P: I'm liking the changes that are being made on the depth chart Bookser to RT, Moss to Co-starter, and Whitehead to the BS are there any other moves that are being made besides QB obviously

Brian Batko: That seems like pretty much it, H2P. I've also noticed Kam Carter creeping up the two-deep at DT week by week, so I wonder if you might see more of our favorite Netflix player there now in ACC play. And I'll be curious to see if Damar Hamlin gets more in the mix. Josh Conklin said today Hamlin has been working a lot lately with Jordan Whitehead, but then quickly added it has nothing to do with the depth chart. Do you believe him?

rob: Why is Morrissey at center and not Officer ? And do you think the game would have been closer if Dinucci went in earlier ?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: I think Pat Narduzzi and his staff really like Jimmy Morrissey. Doesn't sound like they think he's been overmatched as a redshirt freshman. From the early returns, if anyone's losing their starting role on this O-line, I think it's gonna be RT Jaryd Jones-Smith, with Brandon Hodges sliding back in (if healthy)

SOMDPanther: Let's get the on-campus stadium question out of the way early: If "New Pitt Stadium" could be built on Atwood street such that either Sorrentos OR Antoons must be razed to provide the necessary space, which iconic late night joint would you save?

Brian Batko: Love where your head is at, SOMD. I would preserve Sorrento's, no doubt. When I tell people I prefer Sorrento's, they usually reply that Antoon's is more pizza for less money. Since when are gluttony and stinginess good qualities???

Brian Batko: Since they didn't play it Saturday at Heinz Field, I'm adding a new feature to the weekly chat: Sweet Caroline (you'll never know when it's gonna be, much like the real thing, but this week you're getting it in the "first quarter")

Terry: brightwell has looked out of place to me at MLB think he belongs outside with saying that do you think pine gets some more snaps this week?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Hi, Terry. I think Brightwell has had some "bright" spots and some where he hasn't done so "well." But I also believe it's too early to write him off at the MIKE, and it's certainly too early to know what you've got there in Chase Pine, who admittedly looks the part.

Xzavier: What are the chances Paris Ford sees the field this season? I would think it's more of possibility after OK State embarrassed the safeties on national TV.

Brian Batko: Thanks for our court-mandated Paris Ford Q, X. Comments from Narduzzi and the other coaches make me think those chances are low, and even more so, the fact that Ford hasn't dressed for either home game makes me think it's even less likely. (Stephen A. Smith voice) HOWEVA, I'm sayin' there's a chance that he finds his way out there eventually. Maybe next weekend in a low-leverage matchup at home with Rice? I say why not?

Pitt defensive coordinator Josh Conklin on Georgia Tech

M96: What's more likely to happen? Pitt finds some sort of identity and finishes with 8 or 9 wins and a decent bowl; somehow limps to 6 wins (hello Detroit the day after Christmas); or the season completely falls apart and is only able to manage another win or two.

Brian Batko: Hmmmm. Of those three options, I'll play it safe and say Door No. 2, M96. Not sure the Panthers have looked anything close to resembling a 9 or even 8-win club, but I'm not sure I'd predict a total disintegration at this point.

Advertise with us

old german: Any way Pitt would consider using tarps or something similar for advertising to cover the large empty seat sections for some games at Heinz?

Brian Batko: I don't know, but I'll add it to my list of questions for Heather Lyke

meisterbrau: Does Pitt communicate with the Pirates considering future scheduled games? For example, they know the upcoming backyard brawl games years ahead, does Pitt request to the Pirates to request to mlb to be away that weekend? Thanks Brian.

Brian Batko: I don't know, but I'll add it to my list of questions for Heather Lyke. Thanks, meisterbrau, good question.

pittbb80: I thought Pitt hired a defensive minded coach? Did Narduzzi leave his defense in Michigan? It's year 3 and the defense is NOT improving. Its unacceptable.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Hi, pittbb. It's been bad, yes. My brilliant colleague Craig Meyer will have more on this in a story for Post-Gazette.com. The numbers are frightening. That said, I've had people tell me - former players, coaches, etc. - that Year 3 is when things start coming together for a team to fully grasp this defense. Now, the smashing success at Michigan State didn't come until Years 4 and 5, but it's at least one reason to stay optimistic.

HTP4Ever: Does Narduzzi ever game plan defensively for an individual opponent? It looked the same D against Youngstown & Penn State. Obviously those schemes did not work and it appeared he did not adjust from last year's game against OSU.

Brian Batko: I'm quite certain he does, but as even OK State coach Mike Gundy said last week, there's only so much a coach is going to change his scheme, or his base defense. You won't see any coach taking a complete 180 philosophically, i don't think. The going will certainly be different Saturday at Georgia Tech, which wants to run, run, run.

PittMeister: I am concerned about the recruiting with both the product on the field in Year 3 of Duzzi. Not to mention what an embarrassment with so many big recruits at the game for visits. The team played awful and the fans and game atmosphere were humiliating. I have zero point zero optimism for next season or the foreseeable future. SOP.

Brian Batko: Fair, but I'll say this: Pitt has lost badly before. At home. So has every other team. It wasn't some sort of recruiting death knell. Don't put too much emphasis on one defeat, ugly as it was.

Advertise with us

Pitt Cruzer: Quite a Duzzi last weekend! Narduzzi has to do better with his defense. If the talent is lacking, then it is his fault! Recruit better or adjust the defense to your strengths!

Brian Batko: I'll pass that along

Pope: How do you think recruiting was affected today? The lack of fan support for a Top Ten Team; the empty yellow seats; sleeping fans shown on social media; and free drink bribe for fans to stay to the end of the game. We had to lose some recruits.

Brian Batko: Today? Don't think the meter has moved much today, Pope. And no, Pitt hasn't lost any recruits since Saturday. Amazingly, one bad performance didn't change a high school senior's entire worldview.

Pitt boy: Let the MacVittie era begin! Max Browne is not the answer and I am not impressed with DiNucci either. Play for the future with MacVittie.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: I'll pass this along, too

Pitt Yinzer: I don't think people give Paul Chryst enough credit. He left talent behind for narduzzi, which helped his first 2 seasons. Now, we are seeing the fruits of narduzzi's recruiting. His top guys are either suspended, kicked off the team, hurt, or academically ineligible. I hope Michigan State takes Narduzzi back!

Brian Batko: Paul Chryst left some very good players behind, and also left some position not all that fortified. Quarterback, for instance. Obviously, things haven't gone according to plan for Narduzzi this season, but it's 3 games. Jordan Whitehead is no longer suspended, Rori Blair and Jeremiah Taleni were not Narduzzi recruits, Damar Hamlin is healthy now and Paris Ford is eligible (as far as I know). I think that about covers your complaints point by point.

President Stache: The last good recruiter Pitt had was Dave Wannstache! Pitt also had better fan support with Wanny. Bring back Wanny!!!

Brian Batko: Joe Starkey the mans has a column coming soon on this very topic. Keep an eye out for it, Stache.

Advertise with us

Dream backfield: This latest humiliation would be easier to take if we fans knew help was on the way. They are not. Duzzi can't recruit and he can't win with this lower level talent he is bringing in.

Brian Batko: Wow, lots of comments, not so many questions this week.

Pope: The team against OSU just did not look mentally or physically prepared to play. That is the fault of coaching. Your thoughts?

Brian Batko: Defensive coordinator Josh Conklin said these exact words today: "We didn't coach as well as we needed to." And Pat Narduzzi sort of alluded to that Monday, as well, that if the coaching isn't sinking in for the players, that's not all on the athletes. Coaches get paid a pretty penny to figure out how to get through to them.

Blawnox Pitt Guy: do you think Narduzzi is obsessed with James Franklin and beating Penn State that he didn't have enough left in the tank to beat OSU? It might explain how we almost lost to Youngstown State in overtime the week before Penn State.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Nah, probably not

OHIO412FAN: Brian, with Pitt coming off a bad lost to OK ST, what needs to change? Will they go with Browne or Dinnuci? They lack the skilled players like last year to propel them in games like these, (AKA Clemson game). What improvements need to be made?

Brian Batko: Well, in relation to that game, everything needs to change. Personally, I think they'll go with Ben DiNucci at QB, but I wouldn't be shocked if it's Browne. Improvement-wise, it's a little different on both sides of the ball. Defensively, I think there's a lot of things to fix. Offensively, I think there's one BIG thing to fix - quarterback play (though the line could use some work, too).

HTP4Ever: How do you think Pitt will do against Ga Tech? Pitt struggled to beat Youngstown in OT; was never really in the game against Penn State and was completely embarrassed against OSU in so many ways, including the play on the field and on line stuff.

Brian Batko: History would indicate it'll be close. In both matchups with GT since Narduzzi got here, Pitt has won by a field goal. So maybe get ready for a nail-biter this weekend?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Great chat, Mike!

Brian Batko: I think you're lost, Jason.

Tina: Dahlkempers or David Weiss?

Brian Batko: I think you're lost, too.

Kevin : Dinucci did provide a spark when he came in but honestly really didn't play that well. Knowing the backup QB is everyone's favorite how long till the good ole pitt faithful are calling for macvitte to start

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: See above, Kevin

Terry: How much of a must win game is this for pitt?

Brian Batko: Terry: On a scale of 1-100, I'll say 84.

H2P: Do you know if pat narduzzi took your suggestion (free of charge I might add is very generous of you) and will put Paris on the field for real this week?

Brian Batko: I don't know, and I don't expect he'd tell me if he did. But no, I don't expect Paris Ford to be on the travel roster en route to Atlanta, given that he's playing scout-team QB. I thank you for noticing my generosity.

Advertise with us

Matt N.: I liked that Dinucci seemed to spread the ball around to more receivers -- and downfield more. Browne has a good arm but seems hesitant to get vertical sometimes. What's your take?

Brian Batko: Definitely seems hesitant, Matt. Max even said that himself when we talked to him before the OK State game. He and Shawn Watson were working on getting him to "pull the trigger" on some of those potential big-play throws. He made a good one at Penn State, and Jester Weah dropped it. Weah got wiiiide open Saturday at Heinz Field, Max aired it out, but just simply overthrew him. I think if Narduzzi DOES go back to Max this week, might as well see if he can connect on some of those deep balls.

salb: Will Whitehead's return give an uptick for the defense and maybe even a spark for the offense?

Brian Batko: If it doesn't give the defense a boost, that ain't good. Because he's almost certainly Pitt's best athlete out there. I wouldn't anticipate seeing him on offense, but I guess you never know.

H2P: Watson has no idea how to call canadas offense it's great that he tried but it's about time he stops trying and does his own thing. Think it's the only way to save the offense. Thoughts?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: My thought is that I'm not sure how great this offense would look this year even with Matt Canada, given the losses of Nathan Peterman, James Conner, Scott Orndoff, Adam Bisnowaty and Dorian Johnson.

Jeem: What's up with Quadree Henderson? Before the Ok State game Narduzzi even said he wasn't 100%, but he looked pretty healthy when he took that screen pass 74 yards. Other than that play though, he just hasn't been performing up to expectations this season.

Brian Batko: Hi, Jeem. Not sure what's going on there, but yeah, even on that play you're talking about he did get caught from behind. Granted, Pitt finished that drive off with a TD anyway, but that to me was maybe another indication that he's not fully healthy. He better get right for ACC play though, because that would be as much of a shot in the arm for the offense (or special teams) as anything else.

Pitt linebacker Saleem Brightwell talks Georgia Tech

Alan: It seems that no matter who coaches Pitt, all they are able to attract are 2 and 3 star recruits and maybe a 4 star here and there. Consequently, they are consistently outmatched when going against elite teams (except for the occasional upset like Clemson and PSU last year). It's been like this for 25+ years. Not having an on-campus stadium doesn't help. It seems like it's going to take much more than what Pitt is willing or able to do to have a consistent top 25 team. Pitt is over-matched in the ACC in both football and basketball and it doesn't appear this will ever change. Maybe it's time to become a MAC team where Pitt can compete easier and not get embarrassed like they seem to do too often.

Brian Batko: Probably not.

Advertise with us

Jeem: What impact will Whitehead returning this week have on the defense? Obviously it should be positive, but to what degree? He is only 1 guy.

Brian Batko: Good point, he is but a man. Nonetheless, I think he'll make tackles other guys might not. I think he'll be able to cover up the mistakes of inexperienced players in some ways. He won't be a cure-all, but his versatility to play either safety spot should help, too.

Andrew: Do you sense any concerns from the coaching staff on facing the Triple Option offense this week?

Brian Batko: No more than other years. The benefit is that they've faced it three times at Pitt, GT twice and Navy once. Pitt's 2-1 in those games, but with both wins against GT, that seems like something to put in the positives column.

BigPitt: Why have confidence in ACC play when OOC play was so bad? That includes OT win agains YSU.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: I wouldn't say I have confidence in ACC play, but some of the other Coastal teams don't seem that great this year, either.

Jeem: What sights, if any, are you gonna check out while you're in Atlanta? I recommend the College Football Hall of Fame.

Brian Batko: That's a good idea. Wouldn't mind seeing a Braves game. Food-wise, my editor Michael Sanserino tells me Mary Mac's Tea Room is a must. I've also heard good things about The Varsity and been told the Coca-Cola museum is overrated.

Pittguy: Is Josh Conklin in over his head, I think Narduzzi might want to make a change! His good friend Scott Shafer-ex Syracuse- is at Middle Tenn St. Any chance he looks elsewhere?

Brian Batko: College coaches are often nomads, Pittguy, especially assistants. So I'd just say there's always a chance, I guess.

PittBob: Franklin won a conference title in year 3 with average players. Narduzzi has similar type of players. Shouldn't this be his coming out year?

Brian Batko: Every team has some average players. Penn State, last year and this year, also has some very good players. Naturally, Narduzzi hopes to take a step forward this year, as any coach would in any ensuing year. It just doesn't seem to be trending that way thus far.

Rico Bosco: Do you think it’s time for narduzzi to swallow his pride with stuffing the box? The secondary even with Whitehead and hamlin is not talented enough and okst scores multiple times on the deep route that crossed through the middle of field. Multitudes of students will not be attending the rice game at least. Something has to change or pitt football will die a painful death.

Brian Batko: Narduzzi's first goal in any game is to stop the run, and I don't think he'll change his mentality on that. With Tyrique Jarrett and Shakir Soto gone, does this team have the ability to do that like last year's? Time will tell.

Panther Prowl: Is it worth scheduling top ten teams when the stadium is still far from being full?

Brian Batko: My personal opinion is play good teams

Jack: Will Alcorn State make a run this year?

Brian Batko: Not looking good for the Braves at 1-2 with their only W against Miles College

Zeebus Sharmko: How are Pitt players taking the last two losses...down in the dumps, or opportunities to learn from, hold their heads high, reach for the sky and get 'em next game?

Brian Batko: Hello, Zeebus. From their outward appearance, it's the latter, but I've never really noticed college athletes to be all that mopey. No clue how they're feeling behind closed doors, but I tend to think they're not all that bent out of shape about being 1-2 and losing to two Top 10 teams.

Pittguy: Any word on George Ashton?

Brian Batko: Negative

Dan: Is this the worst Pitt team since the early years of Walt Harris?

Brian Batko: Could be, but Dave Wannstedt was also 5-6, 6-6 and 5-7 his first three years before going 9-4. Back away from the ledge, Dan...

Jeem: Can confirm, Coca-Cola museum is overrated

Brian Batko: Thank you, but it is a fantastic beverage all the same imo

Dan: Brian, every eligible healthy player dresses for home games. Isn't it obvious that Ford isn't eligible? He might be an academic red shirt.

Brian Batko: Seems that way, to some extent. But I do think I've noticed some walk-ons (read: 0.0 chance of playing) also not fully dressed, so maybe keeping Ford in sweatpants is just a way to let him know he has to keep working if he wants to see the field?

Blaze: You gonna take my question or did I just waste 20 minutes waiting

Brian Batko: Sorry, Blaze. Lots of questions.

Blaze: Hi sir. When is Narduzzi gonna fire Conklin because his defense is an embarrassment. And why is recruiting worse in Narduzzi's 3rd and 4th year here? I am starting to think this guy is another in a long line of busts.

Brian Batko: Everyone was on board with Narduzzi after beating Penn State and Clemson last year. It just seems the fan base has soured on him recently, with the last two losses, but obviously these things change like the wind. I think recruiting is just a tough ballgame, honestly. As for Conklin, he's been discussed.

Matt N.: Did Coach Duzz burn Davis' redshirt just to beat YSU or will we see a lot more of him during ACC play? It seems now that we opened that can, we better see what's in it.

Brian Batko: Good question, Matt. Based on all we've seen, Davis was really a stop-gap measure to fill in Week 1 with Chawntez Moss unavailable. Now that Moss is back, he's been a forgotten man in the RB rotation. But that doesn't make a whole lot of sense when he's already burned his redshirt. I'll keep an eye on it, for sure.

SOMDPanther: Dr. Freddy Fu and the fine Doctors at UPMC have at last achieved their goal of transplanting preserved limbs, and corresponding abilities, of former Pitt Greats to current Pitt players. But its an expensive endevour, and one which Heather Lyke and the External Operations wing of the AD's suite have only sourced enough funds for a single operation. Coach Duzz has decided to play this card on his QB [OR his QB], and has narrowed the options down to the following. Which should he choose? A. Dan Marino's Arm B. Rod Rutherford's Legs C. Tyler Palko's Heart D. Mark Myer's Kicking Foot

Brian Batko: Has to be A. Dan Marino's Arm. Did you see the NFL Network feature on him last week? Tremendous. I hadn't seen one of those "A Football Life" shows before, but it stood up to the level of a 30 for 30 in my eyes. It's a must-watch. Tyler Palko's heart a close second, tho.

Jeem: There have been many disappointments for the Pitt football already this season. What to you is the most disappointing of them? QB play from Browne? O Line Play? Receivers not stepping up? Quadree Henderson disappearing? Shawn Watson? Or something else?

Brian Batko: I think I'd say the defense in general, specifically the D-line. We knew they were a young group coming into the year, but much was made about their talent level. So far, it just hasn't shown. Three sacks in three games isn't good enough.

Jeem: I think Pitt fans in general need to calm down. I mean suggesting Pitt drop down to the MAC may be the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard. Your thoughts?

Brian Batko: I, uh, agree

Pittguy: What is your Saturday prediction?

Brian Batko: That's a tough one. I don't think I can bring myself to predict a Pitt win. Just doesn't seem like a rational thing to do. But I'll be slightly irrational and predict a better day for the offense. How about Georgia Tech 31, Pitt 23? I think that's right around where the point spread is, anyway.

Brian Batko: OK, a small-scale prediction, and now a large-scale prediction before we go...

Jeem: Though it's still early, through what you've seen so far do you think Pitt keeps their Bowl appearance streak alive?

Brian Batko: Given that I guessed earlier that this team will find six wins somewhere, I'll say yes. But obviously that won't make for a very fun bowl game.

Brian Batko: OK everyone, long and busy chat this week, sorry if I couldn't get to you. But I had fun, hopefully you did too. See you all next Wednesday.