Like the old Ernest Hemingway line, the Pitt football team squandered a big lead in its 2017 season opener two ways: Gradually, then suddenly.
After teetering on the precipice of embarrassment for the better part of a half-hour, coach Pat Narduzzi walked into his postgame news conference and let out a “woo” that was more sigh of relief than shriek of triumph.
Pitt’s 28-21 beating back of Youngstown State in overtime Saturday at Heinz Field was enough to bring back images of the shocker that happened in this same matchup, in this same stadium, to kick off the 2012 season.
The first game of Narduzzi’s third year as Pitt’s coach was nearly spoiled emphatically, as what appeared to be a relaxing tune-up on the North Shore turned into a prickly situation thanks to the plucky Penguins punching back from a 21-0 halftime deficit, soundly dominating the Panthers in the process. It was a stunning turn of events before a crowd of 40,012, many of whom might had already mentally moved on to the most anticipated game of the season a week from now at Penn State.
“It couldn’t have been a better first half,” Narduzzi said.
And if the second had been any worse, Pitt wouldn’t have had the chance to benefit from some clutch catches in an extra stanza no one figured this game would need when the clock struck 3 p.m.
Read More
Jester Weah, team captain and top receiver, made his only statistic of the day count with an 11-yard touchdown reception as the Panthers started with the ball in overtime. When the Penguins took over, redshirt freshman Bricen Garner — a nearby Central Catholic High School graduate seeing his first collegiate action by starting at free safety — made a catch of his own in the end zone, this one an interception to ensure the Panthers’ survival in Week 1.
“It’s always nice to make an interception or a play like that, especially to win the game,” said Garner, who was a man of few words after his sterling debut.
The debuts of quarterback Max Browne and offensive coordinator Shawn Watson weren’t quite as stellar, with Pitt’s offense faltering throughout the second half after a run-heavy game plan to start.
Browne was 17 of 24 for 140 yards and a touchdown in the Southern California graduate transfer’s first game with the Panthers, but with plenty of chances to slam the door on a Football Championship Subdivision opponent, Pitt instead limped into overtime after redshirt freshman Alex Kessman pushed a 38-yard field goal wide right as time expired.
“I think, obviously, everyone wants to have that first game be a blowout, but we were forced to stand in there and have a fistfight,” Browne said. “A lot of teams may have to wait till Week 3 or 4 to have their first test; we got it Week 1, right away.”
It’s not exactly supposed to come from an FCS foe — albeit one of the best programs the second tier of Division I football has to offer — and for a while, everything played out according to script. Pitt’s will was imposed, its defensive concerns briefly assuaged, and all that was left to settle was the final score.
The Panthers gashed the Penguins for 146 yards in the first half and allowed just one single, solitary rushing yard on seven futile attempts. Qadree Ollison, who started at running back, finished with 91 yards on the ground and 35 more through the air, but most of that damage was done in the first 30 minutes when he rushed for two touchdowns. The lone score in the second quarter came not from a veteran back, but from freshman A.J. Davis, from a yard out.
But for all that worked early on, just as much went awry later. Youngstown State’s rally started with a 1-yard touchdown run by New Castle alumnus Tevin McCaster inside of five minutes to play in the third quarter.
It took almost 15 minutes more, but the Penguins struck again, on a 25-yard touchdown pass from Hunter Wells to tailback Christian Turner with 6:10 left, making it 21-14. On Pitt’s next possession, Justus Reed found Browne near midfield for a strip-sack, forcing and recovering the fumble to set up the Penguins at Pitt’s 42.
Two plays later, Wells found Turner out of the backfield like deja vu for a 42-yard touchdown pass to tie the score with 3:35 to go.
“At halftime, I told our guys, ‘Hey, this is too easy. Let’s try to slow it down a bit. I want to have a little adversity in the game,’ ” Narduzzi joked. “They listened to me, I guess.”
Browne managed to bring the offense to the Penguins 20 on the ensuing drive, but that’s when Kessman missed the mark for the second time.
And though overtime wasn’t in the plan, Pitt escaped with a 1-0 record to take to Beaver Stadium in six days.
“A win is a win, but at the end of the day, we can always do better,” defensive end Dewayne Hendrix said. “I’ll leave it at that.”
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.