On a night when Pitt tailback James Conner rumbled for three rushing touchdowns and 300-pound right tackle Brian O’Neill scored too, the lion’s share of the legwork was done by a placekicker.

Virginia Tech’s Joey Slye tied an Atlantic Coast Conference record Thursday by booting six field goals, and the 25-ranked Hokies survived a seesaw affair at Heinz Field to escape with a 39-36 win.

Virginia Tech collected 556 total yards to Pitt’s 458, and 29 first downs to the Panthers’ 17.

And the thing is, it could have been worse. So much worse.

Advertise with us

“That could’ve been 80 points up there if they scored touchdowns,” Pitt coach Pat Narduzzi said.

Instead, the Hokies’ points came three by three. Slye was given six short field-goal tries, and he converted them all — from 31, 21, 22, 26, 37 and 22 yards. The silver lining in that line is the fact Pitt’s defense was backed into the red zone nine times and allowed just three touchdowns.

For most of the game, Pitt’s defense bent but did not break. Yet it still softened too often. Quarterback Jerod Evans picked apart the Pitt secondary for 406 passing yards and two touchdowns, giving the Hokies (6-2, 4-1 ACC) three 100-yard receivers in a game for the first time in program history. Bucky Hodges had 145 yards, Isaiah Ford 143 and Cam Phillips 109.

“It was a fade fest out there,” Narduzzi said. “Our corners were positioned to make plays. Got to make one.”

Since holding Villanova to 7 points in Week 1, Pitt has averaged 36 points allowed per game.

Advertise with us

For the Panthers (5-3, 2-2) and their ruffled defensive corps, the road gets no easier from here. Their next two games both are away from Heinz Field, against Miami and No. 3 Clemson.

Despite the recurring defensive woes, the Panthers had a shot at completing a fourth-quarter comeback. Down 10 with 3:58 remaining, they struck back with a swift touchdown drive, quarterback Nate Peterman to receiver Jester Weah. Narduzzi opted against an onside kick, betting on his defense for a late three-and-out, and the Hokies eked out a first down to ice it.

Peterman was 13-for-22 passing for 267 yards, a touchdown and an interception. His first-quarter pick was his first thrown since Sept. 17 against Oklahoma State.

Conner carried the ball 19 times for 141 yards. It was his first three-touchdown game since he rushed for four scores Nov. 5, 2014, against North Carolina. Held to less than 100 yards in each of the previous four games, Conner plowed through Hokies defenders and refused to relent.

“He’s a beast,” Narduzzi said. But Conner countered that he didn’t do nearly enough. He wasn’t fast enough, Conner said, and he didn’t make enough defenders miss in open space.

Advertise with us

The first quarter was halfway gone before Peterman, Conner and the Pitt offense saw their first snap. After Slye capped the game’s opening drive with a 31-yard field goal, Panthers kick returner Quadree Henderson fumbled on the kickoff, turning the ball over on the Pitt 19. On Pitt’s next drive, Peterman was picked in Panther territory by linebacker Mook Reynolds.

Backed up to the goal line two drives in a row, the Pitt defense was unshaken. Virginia Tech came away with only three points. Pitt’s offense took just six snaps in the first quarter, with 11 of their 12 total yards coming on a single Conner carry, and the defense began to wear down.

After 22 minutes and three fruitless drives, Pitt’s playmakers found their footing and the offense sprang to life. Conner plunged across the goal line twice in the second quarter and once soon after the halftime break, bowling over a Hokies linebacker to give Pitt its first lead, 21-16.

The Hokies’ hopes seemed low when Evans went down with a right leg injury while being swallowed up on a third down midway through the third quarter. But Slye legged them into the lead with two more chip-shot field goals, and Evans returned in time to hand off to Marshawn Williams, who powered into the end zone from 2 yards out with 7 seconds left in the quarter.

More Conner carries and a timely pass-interference call put Pitt in position to call once again on O’Neill. He lined up at left tackle, disengaged at the snap and took a handoff from Peterman and headed for the right pylon. A low hit sent him flying, but he stretched the ball over the goal line.

Advertise with us

A two-point conversion tied the game, and Slye then untied it with a 22-yard field goal. The sides swapped touchdowns later in the quarter, but, in the end, Slye’s sixth kick was the difference.

“We didn’t make enough plays,” Narduzzi said. “Plain and simple.”

Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.