The ACC was supposed to be dominant this season, at least that’s what many of the league’s coaches and administrators were openly talking about at preseason media day.

This is Year 3 of the ACC as it is currently constituted. While the first two seasons produced some successes, the league hasn’t quite achieved the dominance that was hoped for when Syracuse, Pitt, Louisville and Notre Dame joined an already strong group of teams.

The belief was that more quality teams would mean more NCAA tournament bids. But the league has gotten only six teams in the field of 68 in each of the past two seasons.

That is supposed to change this season, though, as the ACC appears to be deep and strong given the returning players and influx of graduate transfers.

Advertise with us

But as Pitt and Syracuse get set to tip off the ACC season Wednesday at Petersen Center as part of “ACC Tip-Off” doubleheader (Clemson is at North Carolina in the other game), the ACC looks a lot more like the 6-bid league of the past two seasons than the 8- or 9-bid juggernaut it was hoping to be.

Pitt coach Jamie Dixon, however, believes that the ACC regular season is going to be extremely competitive and that the conference has shown enough in these first two months to believe that it will be one of the best, if not the best, conferences in Division I by the time the NCAA tournament begins.

“I think everybody talked about the ACC being the best league when they put it all together,” Dixon said. “I don’t think that we were there for that first year or two but I said eventually we will get to that point. I think the teams have improved through this one-third of the season.

“I think we will see some remarkable runs by teams and great matchups, it will be what we all signed up for. There are so many good teams there will somebody that is picked down at the bottom that is really good, there are just too many good teams in this conference.”

The ACC may indeed have a lot of good teams but so far it hasn’t shown that often enough in non-conference games.

Advertise with us

The ACC’s first good opportunity to make a good impression was in the Big Ten-ACC Challenge. But the Big Ten had the edge in the series 8-6,  extending the ACC’s streak of not winning the event to seven years.

Some of the ACC’s heavyweights — Duke and North Carolina — have had some head-scratching losses. Also, Virginia lost to George Washington and Miami, who is expected to contend for the title, lost to Northeastern.

There have been some bright spots, too. North Carolina beat Maryland, Virginia beat Villanova and Wake Forest surprised UCLA and Indiana. Syracuse won the Battle 4 Atlantis with wins against Connecticut and Texas A&M.

And while the Ratings Percentage Index (RPI) this early in the season isn’t a perfect metric because there are so many games to play, it is at least somewhat of an indicator of how a league or team is performing in non-conference games.

So far the ACC is 11-22 against teams currently in the top 50 of the RPI. That includes 6-10 against the top 25. There are five ACC teams ranked in the Associated Press Top 25 and seven in the RPI top 50, which means that the league has a lot of work to do.

Advertise with us

But that could prove difficult once the league schedule starts because the bottom half of the league doesn’t appear to be nearly as strong as it did on paper before the season began.

That doesn’t mean that the ACC can’t get eight or nine teams into the NCAA tournament. But it does mean that this, at least so far, is not shaping up to be that breakthrough season for the league.

Dixon said he sees a lot of teams which have a good chance to make a run at an NCAA bid.

“There are clearly a large — say 10 or 12 — teams [who are in a good position],” Dixon said. “It doesn’t mean they are going to have the resume or do the things necessary to get there but there are a lot of teams who have an opportunity to get it done.”

While the ACC’s non-conference season might not be a good development overall, the good news for Pitt is that the league appears to be far more manageable for the Panthers.

Advertise with us

Pitt was picked to finish 10th in the conference in the preseason, but the Panthers (10-1) appear to be better than most observers thought they would be.

The Panthers aren’t likely to contend for the regular-season title but a top-five finish doesn’t seem to be out of the question.

Pitt has a chance to get off to a good start, too. The Orange will be without coach Jim Boeheim Wednesday (he is serving a nine-game suspension for NCAA violations) and then the Panthers play host to Georgia Tech, Boston College and North Carolina State within their first six games.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @paulzeise.