NEWARK, N.J. -- Pitt secured its seventh-consecutive victory in its series with Penn State, 81-73, Saturday at the Prudential Center, a game with a result that seemed so certain until it wasn't, as it has been with Pitt numerous time this season.

So how'd we get here?

Turning point: After leading by as many as 24 early in the second half, Pitt saw its lead slip to five with 1:50 remaining after a free throw from Shep Garner. On the Panthers' ensuing position, Jamel Artis found an open Sheldon Jeter, who cooly drained a corner 3-pointer to give his team a 74-66 lead with 1:28 remaining and end any serious threat from the Nittany Lions.

Game ball: Mike Young. He described his performance Saturday as "decent" in the post-game press conference, but it's an adjective that's more reflective of the season he's having than the day he had in North Jersey. He finished with a game-high 29 points, nine of which came in the final 4:20 as his team was fending off Penn State, and pulled down nine rebounds.

Advertise with us

Notable stat: 42 39, Pitt's first half and second half scoring totals Saturday, respectively. And against Penn State, of course. The universe works in strange and mysterious ways sometimes. That, or it was a perfectly executed troll job.

What it means: It's a victory for the Panthers in what seemed to be their toughest non-conference game remaining (though Rice, their Dec. 17 opponent, is pretty good; more on the Owls later). As things stand now, an 11-2 out-of-conference record appears likely and, given the rigorous slate Pitt will face in the ACC, almost necessary.

But what happened Saturday was the continuation of an early-season trend that sometimes seems like an inherent shortcoming -- this team can't seem to put away games. I described earlier how a 24-point lead got as low as five in just a single half, but this is far from an isolated instance. In fact, it's gotten to the point of being the norm for this team.

A quick look at the other examples, in chronological order:

- Eastern Michigan: up 12 with 6:50 remaining, ended up going to overtime, where Pitt won by three.

Advertise with us

- Yale: up 11 with 8:40 remaining, lead got down to three, won by five.

- Morehead State: up 17 with 16:52 remaining, lead got down to seven, won by 13.

- Maryland: up 25 with 15 minutes remaining, lead got down to eight, won by 14.

- Buffalo: up 16 with 15:48 remaining, lead got down to three, won by five.

Instead of writing a story about this being perhaps Pitt's most consistent and dominant performance of the season -- in part because Penn State is young and, frankly, not very good -- it became another example of what, for the Panthers, has to be an unsettling trend.

Advertise with us

What's next: A home game Dec. 17 against Rice. Pitt's a 76 percent favorite against the Owls, who KenPom has at 95, with a projected final score of 83-75.

Notable quotables: "We're a team that's doing a really good job for portions of the game and halves of the game. Sometimes, like today, such a good job we were able to almost put a game out of reach, not that it's really out of reach when it's 20 points. We all know better than that. But we're still trying to find the kind of consistency and kind of play we need throughout a 40-minute game." - Kevin Stallings

"You're coaching pretty talented guys when the guy stands up here that had 29 points and nine rebounds in a college game and said 'I played OK.''" - Stallings on Mike Young

"It seems like we come in here game after game and have long stretches of pretty spectacular play. We were really good in the first half. We just have to look at those positives and try to build on them. We know we haven't been as good, especially defensively, in the second half. We just have to try to address that." - Stallings

"In the first couple of first halves, we've all been playing together, playing for one, especially on the defensive end. We've been getting into the gaps. We usually build up a lead, but any time you build up a lead in college basketball, the other team is going to come and pick up their energy level. I feel like sometimes, we just don't answer the bell. They'll pick up their energy level and we'll just stay kind of the same. I feel like that's why it keeps happening. It's a pattern we're going to fix." - Sheldon Jeter

Advertise with us

"With us, it shows us where we have to grow, make progress as a team, progress as individuals and progress as a program in general. We show ourselves we have the potential to really play good defense and get a team on their heels and really get up big, though we also show how we can let a team come back. We have a lot of experience, with four seniors, but it still shows where we can grow and mature. It'll come over time." - Mike Young on giving up sizable leads

"I felt like today was a breakthrough for our freshmen. They did not shoot the ball particularly well, if you look at Tony [Carr] and Lamar [Stevens]'s numbers. But for the first time, they broke through and kept competing regardless of missing or making shots. That, to me, is a monster breakthrough moving forward when we're two weeks away from the Big Ten. I'm excited about that and that type of potential." - Penn State coach Pat Chambers

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG