While exiting Cleveland’s Huntington Bank Field early Friday morning, I overheard a pair of stadium employees chatting in the distance. Both were flying high after the Browns’ victory against the Steelers, but something else had them even more excited.
“First this. Now, the Guardians on Saturday,” one of them said. “There’s nothing like October baseball.”
That’s something Cleveland sports fans would certainly know. The Guardians are postseason regulars. Along with the Milwaukee Brewers and Tampa Bay Rays — this year’s top seeds in the National and American leagues — they exemplify what a small-market franchise is capable of when run properly from the top down.
As those three organizations continue their respective pushes toward a World Series crown, I can’t help but wonder if Pirates team president Travis Williams is following along from home, taking notes. If not, he certainly should be.
Last October, Williams assured Pirates fans better times were ahead. He insisted the franchise was “a lot closer” than the team’s 71-91 record suggested. In a room full of reporters, he stated the team’s goal for 2026.
“Make the playoffs — period, full stop.”
Read More
That obviously didn’t happen.
This year’s Pirates finished 82-80, good for just the franchise’s fifth winning record since 1992 but still not enough to clinch a playoff spot. Players and coaches both acknowledged they fell short of the goal, expressing pride in the progress made but also noting further work to be done.
“That’s everybody’s goal going into every season,” manager Don Kelly said last month. “When you sit there and feel like you fell short of it, there is disappointment. And from a cultural standpoint, to see the way these guys compete every single night, it’s hard not to be excited about the future.”
Added Paul Skenes: “We all wanted to play in October ... This is my third year, and every year, at the end, we’re talking about ‘What’s it going to look like for next year?’ And I’m tired of it. We are in a good position for next year, I know that, but it’s gonna be tough to think about that again for a whole offseason.”
General manager Ben Cherington echoed a similar sentiment last weekend. But neither Williams nor his boss, Pirates owner Bob Nutting, was made available to speak on the 2026 season following its conclusion.
It would’ve been nice to know if either of them — more notably the latter — shares that same type of disappointment because in the end, that’s what will truly determine if this capable group can finally get over the hump.
To Nutting’s credit, the Pirates were far more aggressive last offseason, especially for his standards. They acquired better players through trades and free agency. The team’s payroll on opening day was higher than ever before. Konnor Griffin was signed to the most lucrative deal in franchise history not long after.
These moves wouldn’t have been possible if Nutting hadn’t stepped outside his comfort zone.
It’s worth wondering what inspired him to do so. Perhaps he felt obligated to do more after watching the Pirates stumble through an embarrassing 2025 campaign. Or maybe he was pressured into it by the commissioner’s office to show that even MLB’s worst teams are making a genuine effort to win.
Regardless of what actually inspired that change from Nutting and his front office, those aggressive moves made the Pirates a better ballclub.
After missing the playoffs yet again, a similar approach must be taken heading into 2027.
There’s no telling what this upcoming offseason will look like. It’s even more difficult to project what the league’s financial landscape will be whenever a new collective bargaining agreement is reached.
Yet, regardless of what lies ahead, the Pirates must remain aggressive when it comes to building next year’s roster.
There will still be time to sign free agents and make trades prior to opening day. And when that time arrives, there needs to be more urgency to improve.
This shouldn’t need to be stated, but unfortunately, when talking about a franchise that has made just six playoff appearances since the start of the Reagan administration, it does.
The Pirates’ lack of success over the past three decades can allow any type of progress to feel more notable than it actually is. There were certainly things worth celebrating throughout 2026. There’s absolutely reason to feel optimistic about where the organization is capable of heading. But the job isn’t finished.
It’s not difficult to imagine Nutting feeling content with a winning season. He likely believes this team could have reached the playoffs had it not been for injuries. That may or may not be true.
With nearly every key player from this year’s team set to return next season, Nutting may feel like the big moves have already been made, that only a few minimal transactions are required to fill in the cracks.
That simply can’t happen. That’s how an 11-year streak of missing the playoffs can easily turn to an even dozen.
The players deserve more from their owner, as do the fans, who after years upon years of supporting a product unworthy of their attention are finally excited to watch baseball on the North Shore.
These Pirates are close to popping champagne in a clubhouse next September. They have the core to get there. But this year showed they still need some additional help to finish the job.
Nutting stepped outside his comfort zone and helped the Pirates improve in 2026. Further investment will increase his team’s odds of finally achieving its goal. Coasting after coming up short will not.
The Pirates need their owner to step up and deliver, to give them a real shot at maximizing the potential we all witnessed throughout the past season. Failing to do so would be a letdown for everyone involved.
Period, full stop.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.