Mitch Keller’s woes continued Thursday. The Pirates’ offense and bullpen nearly let him get away with it — until a blast too far in the ninth.

Keller completed just three innings, and three Pirates home runs weren’t enough in a 10-5 loss to the Atlanta Braves on Thursday afternoon at PNC Park. The tying run reached third in the eighth, but Dennis Santana allowed a grand slam to Mike Yastrzemski in the ninth that put the game out of reach.

The Pirates are 47-47 and will need a series victory against the Milwaukee Brewers (58-34) to go into the All-Star break above .500.

“Just sucks. Obviously don’t want to lose the series,” Keller said. “ ... We’ll be good. Got a big series coming up and just need to take care of business there.”

Advertise with us

Keller allowed three earned runs on four hits and two walks. He struck out three.

His biggest issue was the lack of a put-away pitch, as the Braves continually fouled balls off. He threw 72 pitches, including a 35-pitch third inning (that did not include a walk).

It was Keller’s shortest start since July 28 of last year, when he needed 73 pitches in two innings against the San Francisco Giants.

“They just fouled off a lot of pitches two at-bats in a row. Just kinda drove the pitch count up,” Keller said. “I just gave up a couple hits and obviously the [Matt Olson] home run. Just wasn’t good.”

The Pirates trailed, 3-0, after the top of the third inning but got two back in the bottom half on back-to-back home runs from Bryan Reynolds and Esmerlyn Valdez.

Advertise with us

Keller was expecting to go out for the fourth — “kinda surprised, but it’s not my call,” he said, brushing off injury concerns — before manager Don Kelly elected to turn to the bullpen.

“Felt like the best chance for us to win there and coming back towards the top of the order was to go with Cam [Sanders],” Kelly said.

But the Braves jumped on the right-hander. Sanders threw 39 pitches in the fourth inning, recording just two outs, walking three and allowing a two-run home run to Jim Jarvis and an RBI single to Drake Baldwin. The homer was the first of Jarvis’ career.

After Sanders, the bullpen kept the Pirates in it until the ninth. Hunter Stratton stranded two of Sanders’ runners, then pitched a scoreless fifth before a 38-minute rain delay. Yohan Ramirez pitched two scoreless innings, allowing just one walk, and Gregory Soto pitched a 1-2-3 eighth.

And the Pirates chipped away. Jake Mangum hit a two-run homer against Bryce Elder to the upper rows behind the Clemente Wall to make it 6-4 in the fourth. Mangum added an RBI double in the sixth, finishing the game 4 for 5 with three RBIs and a triple away from the cycle, to pull the Pirates within a run.

Advertise with us

They just couldn’t get that final run — and Santana couldn’t keep them close enough for a chance.

It was over when ...

Yastrzemski’s blast hit the seats. Santana loaded the bases on a walk, a single and an intentional walk. He struck out Austin Riley for the second out but fell behind on Yastrzemski before leaving a four-seamer over the heart of the plate.

Santana’s ERA this season is now 5.95. He simply hasn’t been the same pitcher as he was in 2024 and 2025.

Kelly elected to go with Santana with two lefties due up, even with Soto in the game and Mason Montgomery warming. He said he liked the pocket for Santana, though he would have gone with Montgomery if the Pirates had tied it or taken the lead. Down one, he didn’t want to keep “chasing.”

“We need other guys, too, to step up and get some outs,” Kelly said, adding he has seen improvement in the bullpen. “ ... Tough when you lose a game like this that you're right there. I was told by a mentor of mine about chasing all the time, you can't do it all the time. But we did with Soto. Gave us a chance there in the eighth inning and we need Santana to hold the game there.”

Advertise with us

Santana left the clubhouse before reporters entered.

On the mound

On Wednesday, Pirates general manager Ben Cherington noted how Keller has struggled against left-handers this year. The Braves, knowing that, lined up six lefties and a switch hitter.

The Braves fouled off 17 of his 46 strikes. They swung and missed at just five.

Thursday was Keller’s final outing before the All-Star break, an opportunity both for rest and to dial in on his struggles. He has a 7.62 ERA in his last eight starts, a span in which he and pitching coach Bill Murphy have looked at a little bit of everything.

“We’ve talked about pitch selection, pitch design, everything honestly,” Keller said. “I think it’s more mechanical on my end than anything. I’m excited to be able to have this week here to really hone in on some things.”

Advertise with us

At the plate

The Pirates scored five runs on eight hits yet went 1 for 10 with runners in scoring position.

Mangum’s day was a bright spot. He’s batting .360 over his last 34 games.

“I'm just trying to win at-bats,” Mangum said. “At the end of the day, I've never been upset about a single and I've never been upset about a homer. Just trying to win at-bats and score points for the team."

Bucs bites

• The Pirates entered Thursday with 117 home runs, as many as they hit in all of 2025. They’ve now passed that mark with 68 games to go.

• While Carmen Mlodzinski was physically in the Pirates’ bullpen, Kelly said he was unavailable Thursday.

Advertise with us

• Nick Gonzales drew three walks, tying a career high he set earlier this year.

Up next

The NL Central-leading Brewers come to town for the final three games before the All-Star break, starting Friday at 6:40 p.m. All-Star right-hander Braxton Ashcraft (9-3, 3.24 ERA) will pitch for the Pirates against Brewers right-hander Brandon Sproat (3-4, 5.13). The game will be televised on SportsNet Pittsburgh and broadcast on the radio on 93.7 The Fan.