PHILADELPHIA — Paul Skenes stood in front of his locker wearing his usual white button-up and gray slacks, his hair damp and slicked back from a shower.

He spoke in monotone — not particularly abnormal, especially not after the performance he was about two hours removed from. Skenes was asked eight questions during a one-minute, 36-second postgame press conference in which his longest response yielded 32 words.

Again, not wildly irregular.

But Wednesday night, in a 10-6 loss to the Philadelphia Phillies at Citizens Bank Park, Skenes looked … off.

Advertise with us

His seven earned runs allowed were a career high. In the fourth inning, he threw four fastballs that flashed below 95 mph.

“I don’t think he was as sharp as he typically is,” Pirates manager Don Kelly said.

That’s been the case for a few weeks now.

In nine starts since May 17, Skenes has posted a 5.36 ERA and 1.40 WHIP through 47 innings. He gave up four or more runs in five of those outings. He didn’t eclipse six innings in any of them.

The Pirates haven’t won a game with Skenes on the mound since May 12 — and it’s contributed to them falling well behind in the National League Central standings. One more loss for the Pirates in a Skenes start would make it 10 in a row.

Advertise with us

This is all talking about the reigning National League Cy Young winner.

When faced with the clouding, loaded question of why, answers in the Pirates’ clubhouse weren’t especially illuminating.

“I’m not sure,” Skenes said. “We’ll figure out what it is and just keep attacking it.”

What about that dip in velocity in the fourth inning and a fastball that averaged 96.3 mph — his career low for a game?

“I don’t know,” he said.

Advertise with us
Pirates pitcher Paul Skenes wipes his face Wednesday after giving up a home run to the Phillies’ Brandon Marsh during the third inning in Philadelphia. (Matt Slocum / Associated Press)

According to Baseball Savant, Skenes’ fastball velocity is in the 87th percentile of MLB pitchers. In 2024, it was in the 99th percentile. Last season, it was 95th.

The reason for a 35-pitch second inning that saw Skenes issue a walk, hit a batter and allow a single and a three-run homer to Phillies’ leadoff man Trea Turner?

“Just fell behind in some counts and left some balls over the plate,” he said.

Skenes’ current ERA of 3.62 — 30th in the majors — is the highest mark he’s posted this late in a season.

He’s holding opposing batters to an 11th-best .211 average. His rate of 11.03 strikeouts per nine innings ranks second in baseball behind Milwaukee's Jacob Misiorowski, the leading candidate for the NL Cy Young. Skenes’ 1.94 walks per nine innings are the 10th lowest in baseball.

Advertise with us

So … why?

The defense behind Skenes has certainly been a factor, but it doesn’t explain, in Kelly’s words, why “fastball command wasn’t like it typically is” and why “the breaking ball wasn’t maybe as sharp.”

Both home runs Skenes surrendered Wednesday came on breaking balls that didn’t quite break — the first to Turner was a hanging sweeper, and the second was a low slider Brandon Marsh sent into the right-field seats.

Could fatigue be playing a factor?

“I mean, today with the heat, too, and in that second inning throwing 35 pitches,” Kelly said, “not sure if that played any part in it.”

Advertise with us

Per Codify Baseball, Skenes’ average fastball spin rate Wednesday was 1,987 RPM. That’s his lowest of the season by a considerable margin, with the next being 2,085 RPM on June 26, his last start, in which he gave up four runs in five innings against the Cincinnati Reds.

As for the declining velocity, Mike Petriello, an analyst for MLB.com, told the Post-Gazette on June 18 it may stem from a desire to remain healthy.

“Pure speculation without talking to him is he probably looks at this and says, ‘I might have a better chance of staying healthy longer if I’m not throwing 110% on every pitch. And I’m good enough that I don’t need to. If that means I’m down one tick, that’s fine,’ ” Petriello said. “That’s speculation on my part.”

In the first inning Wednesday, facing a daunting top of the Phillies’ lineup, Skenes threw the fastball on just two of his 15 pitches and put forth his only scoreless frame of the night.

And from there on, the why still elusive, he struggled to land his off-speed offerings and locate the fastball.

Advertise with us

“Just got to execute a few pitches a little better and I think it’s probably a different story,” he said.

Regardless, the Pirates maintain confidence their ace can regain his form.

“It’s Paul,” Nick Gonzales said. “Cy Young last year, and we’re confident that whatever ups or downs he has, he’s gonna persevere through. He’s gonna be Paul Skenes.”