Braxton Ashcraft is really good.

I’m not talking good for a second-year player or a No. 3 starter, either. Right now, it could be argued Ashcraft is among the best pitchers in the National League.

Per Baseball Savant, Ashcraft ranks in MLB’s 80th percentile or better in pitching run value, fastball run value, breaking ball run value, expected ERA, ERA, fastball velocity and chase percentage. His strikeout and walk percentages are not far behind, ranking within the top fourth of MLB pitchers.

“He’s been great,” manager Don Kelly said following Ashcraft’s seven strong innings Thursday in St. Louis. “Again today, he was efficient, getting ahead, first-pitch strikes and then being able to put them away. I thought he did a phenomenal job.”

Advertise with us

These are the metrics of an All-Star, which Ashcraft could be on his way to becoming should this type of production continue. He’s still 26 years old, still less than a year removed from his major league debut.

All of this should give the Pirates — and their fanbase — a reason to celebrate. But Ashcraft’s background also provides legitimate reason for concern.

Braxton Ashcraft is really good — perhaps too good for his own good.

A bumpy road

Most fans became aware of Ashcraft over the last few years, when he started progressing through the minor leagues. He was a top-100 prospect as recently as 2024, but his road to “The Show” was far more complex than most other arms in the Pirates’ system.

In 2019, his first year as a pro, Ashcraft underwent a Latarjet procedure on his left shoulder (non-throwing) to address numbness he was experiencing while on the mound. He, along with all other minor leaguers, missed the next season due to COVID-19.

Advertise with us

Ashcraft then had two more operations. The first was due to a meniscus tear in his right knee in 2020. The second was Tommy John surgery in 2021, which forced him to miss the entire 2022 campaign. Ashcraft returned in 2023, logging 52⅔ innings in a season that started in Low-A Bradenton and ended in Double-A Altoona.

His career really started to take off in 2024, when, after a solid run with the Altoona Curve, he earned a promotion to Triple-A Indianapolis. But that year, too, included injuries. He was placed on the injured list due to right forearm tightness and inflammation on three separate occasions. He logged just four innings after June 25 and spent the final month of the season rehabbing at the Pirates’ spring training facility in Bradenton, Fla.

Of course, last year went well for the 6-foot-5 flamethrower. He debuted with the Pirates on May 26. He worked out of the bullpen — a role completely unfamiliar to him — until the final months of the season. He ended up making eight starts before the year was over but only reached the fifth inning in three of them.

Workload was understandably a concern the Pirates had for Ashcraft. Yet he still pitched 118 innings between Triple-A and the majors, shattering his career high of 73 from 2024. Team sources have told the Post-Gazette the previous pitching group used Ashcraft more than the organization originally intended heading into the 2025 campaign.

But then again, how could you blame them? He was filthy, finishing with a 2.71 ERA and 71 strikeouts over 69⅔ innings in the majors. He established himself as a staple for the 2026 pitching staff.

Advertise with us

This past winter, the Pirates traded away right-handers Mike Burrows and Johan Oviedo to add bats to what was once a weak lineup. Their departures all but ensured Ashcraft would begin the season in the starting rotation.

With less pitching depth, the Pirates needed Ashcraft to take a step forward. So far, he has. Through 10 starts, Ashcraft has gone 3-2 with a 2.89 ERA. He has struck out 65 batters, which, entering the weekend, ranked sixth in the National League.

Last year, Ashcraft did most of his damage with his fastball and slider. This year, his curveball is significantly better, and that further distinguished pitch mix has allowed him to go deeper into games. He’s logged at least five innings in all but one of his starts this season. He’s pitched at least seven innings in four of his last six outings.

As we head into the final week of May, Ashcraft is currently on pace to again eviscerate his career high in innings pitched. He’s already thrown 62⅓. He’s been efficient, averaging just over 14 pitches per frame.

“That’s been my goal as a starting pitcher,” Ashcraft said Thursday. “ ... Going deep into games is our job as starting pitchers. To be able to do that consistently has been a blessing.”

Advertise with us

There’s no sign of Ashcraft slowing down — unless his body or the Pirates stop him.

Gas or brakes?

Innings limits and pitch counts exist for a reason. While longtime baseball fans love to highlight how starters used to pitch 200-plus innings in a season without issue, they fail to highlight the hundreds — if not thousands — of promising young arms whose careers were cut short due to overuse.

Every story about Nolan Ryan and Bob Gibson can be matched with “what could’ve been” tales about Mark Prior and Brandon Webb. In today’s game, we’re seeing far more cases of the latter than the former.

Nothing in baseball has evolved more over the last three decades than pitching. Not long ago, there were only a few pitchers capable of touching triple digits on the radar gun. Now, there are starters and relievers who do it on all 30 teams.

Breaking balls and off-speed pitches are nastier, too. They are far more difficult to hit — but also take a greater toll on the pitcher.

Advertise with us

Major league teams invest millions of dollars each year studying players’ biometrical data. They understand the best path to October involves the least amount of injuries. Still, injuries happen, especially on the mound.

Now, let’s take another look at Ashcraft. He’s already had Tommy John surgery. He’s less than two years removed from ending a season early due to right forearm tightness. Last year was his first season as a pro that included no injuries, a feat that took six years — seven if you include the COVID season — to achieve.

Are we sure letting him remain in the rotation from start to finish is in anyone’s best interest?

While we all like to highlight the common trends teams use to protect pitchers — 100 pitches per game, only 30 to 40 added innings of work each season, minimum of four days’ rest between starts — the reality is everyone’s body is different.

The Pirates monitor Paul Skenes’ workload differently than Jared Jones’. Mitch Keller and Bubba Chandler also have different plans. Industry norms don’t always need to be followed, but when considering Ashcraft’s injury history, it’s tough to argue he, more than perhaps anyone else in the organization, should be handled with care.

Advertise with us

But there’s also the other side of the coin.

The 2026 Pirates are a far worse team without Ashcraft in the rotation. Right now, the Pirates can’t afford to get worse — especially on the mound.

While the rotation has been a strength, there are already enough tough choices ahead that don’t involve Ashcraft.

Jones’ return is quickly approaching. He wants to be a starting pitcher, but the Pirates have yet to clearly state how he’ll be used. Carmen Mlodzinski has been fine but has only logged six innings twice in 10 outings. Chandler’s rookie inconsistencies are getting harder and harder to ignore. Putting additional pressure on all three doesn’t seem like the best idea.

The bullpen is also a mess. It entered the weekend having already blown 11 saves. Middle relief is perhaps the biggest issue. But when Ashcraft is on the mound, middle relief isn’t a worry with how deep he has gone into games.

Advertise with us

While Ashcraft would make the bullpen better, the collective unit could be tasked with more work with Ashcraft out of the rotation.

Decisions, decisions

No one loves telling the Pirates what they should do more than me. But right now, I don’t envy Ben Cherington and Co. for the decisions they have to make.

Having Ashcraft throw 180 innings could give the Pirates their best chance to reach the postseason. It could also set him up to suffer a career-altering injury. The Pirates owe it to Ashcraft to consider not only what's best for the team but for him individually. No player’s future should be jeopardized over the pursuit of success in one season.

To the Pirates’ credit, pitching is what they know best. They scout it well, develop it well and, for the most part, have put their young arms in a position to thrive.

Sooner rather than later, I imagine we’ll see a decision on Ashcraft’s workload. June is the point in the season when teams typically feel they have enough data to start planning for the rest of the year.

Advertise with us

The Pirates will have to get creative. Ashcraft might have to skip an occasional start, as we saw with Jones in June 2024. Ashcraft might enter certain outings with a hard cutoff after the fifth inning, as we saw with Skenes last July before the All-Star break.

A six-man rotation is also an option, although it risks not only throwing off the routines of other starting pitchers but putting more dependence on a bullpen that would be short an arm.

And all of these options come under the assumption the rest of the rotation will remain healthy through September — which almost certainly won’t be the case.

Needless to say, some interesting choices lie ahead. The Pirates still have a slew of pitching talent, but Ashcraft’s injury history, paired with his current dominance, complicates things.

Braxton Ashcraft is really good. It’s on the Pirates to keep it that way.