Jason Mackey: Hello, everyone. Welcome to my weekly Pirates chat. We'll get started shortly but feel free to fire away now.

Jason Mackey: And away we go ...

Yuri: Hello Jason. I’m glad to see the Pirates spending some money and bringing in players who hopefully will improve the team. What do you think the Pirates will need to acquire Eugenio Suarez? Thank you Jason.

Jason Mackey: Hi Yuri. I think they could need to go to a third year or up the AAV. I think teams are probabaly hesitant because he's 34, hits for a low average and isn't a great fielder. But they have to do something to separate themselves. It also might be impossible. From everything you hear, he has concerns about playing in Pittsburgh. Entirely possible he just doesn't wanna do it.

Advertise with us

John: Will Skenes be a pirate 4 years from now?

Jason Mackey: I don't think so, no. I don't think an extension is reasonable/likely at this point. You don't want to let him go for nothing. Deal that big probably needs to happen in the offseason for team-planning purpose. Based on info we have now, I'd probably say the offseason heading into his sixth and final year of team control.

FirstTimeLongTime: Hey Brian - given the rankings and hype now surrounding KG (I've read the name Mike Trout a few times) would it be considered a failure if he was not signed to an extension before taking a Major League at bat?

Jason Mackey: *Jason

No, I wouldn't consider it a failure. Not every young prospect signs a long-term extension. That being said, I think there's interest on both sides. And it makes sense given his pedigree. But I wouldn't call it a failure, no.

Advertise with us

Art from NC: Hey Jason- If Soto got 765 million from the Mets, is it out of the realm that thinking, if he continues at his current pace (or actually gets better, if that's possible) that Skenes could get baseball's first billion dollar contract in a few years?

Jason Mackey: Not sure, Art. So much between now and then. Based on your reasoning, I suppose. However, pitchers and position players are different. We also don't know what happens with the CBA and a potential strike. I don't know what reliable way I would have of predicting that.

FirstTimeLongTime: Hey Jason - too many chats to read on the PG, apologies for writing to Mr. Batko in the first question. The front office has be open when speaking about needing another bat to round out this lineup and not just Cutch (bring him back too!) Obviously everyone is yelling for Suarez but unless he is interested in a 1 year deal I don't see it happening. Trades are always a mystery but is there anyone else out there in Free Agency that would fit team need(top half of the order, platoon if necessary etc etc, we're open to all options if it means run support!)

Jason Mackey: It's all good. Not offended. I've been called worse.

Honestly, I'm not sure I'd bother going the FA route if you miss on Suarez. There's just not enough out there to justify the expense, IMO. I'd rather give the money to Griffin & live with Triolo.

Advertise with us

I would still entertain trades. Those candidates include Bohm, Baty, Jung, Paredes and a few others.

Long Time Reader: Jason, what's your sense on the Pirates actually making the last few meaningful acquisitions that they need to for 3rd base and a lefty starter? Are we looking at the equivalent of Tommy Pham and Andrew Heaney or will they sign Suarez? Who are the best players on the market at this time (if not Suarez) and are the Pirates talking to those folks? If not via FA, then what trades do you think are possible? Thank you!

Jason Mackey: I believe they'll make those 2 moves, as I've been saying. I don't think Suarez is likely, as I've been saying. I think Quintana & Anderson are possible LHP starting options. Maybe a Patrick Corbin. Just mentioned the trade possibilities for 3B if you don't get Suarez.

RickLovesBaseball: Any thoughts on a players ability to prepare for the regular season when they do the WBC instead of a full spring training routine?

Jason Mackey: You've got 6-7 weeks. Figure it out. Ha. Those are my thoughts. I think some of that stuff can be a little overcooked. They'll be fine.

Advertise with us

demosthenes98: Who do you think will end up being the second-most important member of the 2026 Pirates? (The identity of the most important '26 Pirate is already known and need not be stated.)

Jason Mackey: Esmerlyn Valdez? Evan Sisk? That was for the first one.

Jason Mackey: Not sure, honestly. My candidates are Cruz, Reynolds, O'Hearn, Lowe & Chandler in a breakout season. I could see Cruz breaking out. I also think Bubba could be an absolute stud. Those are my nominees before I get into the vitriol-laced questions here ...

demosthenes98: Following up on that question, other than Paul Skenes, do the Pirates really have any important players? I don't mean important to the Pirates--I mean important in the way that the players on the Dodgers, Yankees, and other competently-run MLB teams are important.

Jason Mackey: Yes, they do.

Advertise with us

demosthenes98: Travis Williams spoke of "accountability" at PiratesFest. Do you get the impression that, when the Pirates have yet another losing season this year, if Ben Cherington is responsible, he will hold him accountable and fire him? If he is responsible, will he hold true to his principles and fire himself? And what actions will he take if Bob Nutting is responsible?

Jason Mackey: It depends on some factors, but if they win, say, 74 games, I don't see how Cherington keeps his job. Probably Travis Williams in that scenario, too. I don't think that will cause Nutting to sell the team -- sorry. Accountability would come in the form of doing things a different way, I guess.

demosthenes98: Andrew McCutchen is a franchise icon, the face of the Pirates' most recent era of relevance, and still a serviceable baseball player. Bob Nutting is Bob Nutting. Which of these men is worthy to make the final decision as to whether Cutch is on the '26 Pirates? (As this is a matter of worthiness, Nutting's ownership of the team is irrelevant.)

Jason Mackey: McCutchen should be on the team as a part-time DH in a retirement year. If he's not willing to do that, I'm OK moving on. But I would make sure it's known that it was offered.

MUNKEEFIST: How important do teams feel it is to get FA's signed before spring training so they can take care of family things like housing and moving before they report so they can concentrate on baseball? It seems like late additions tend to struggle sometimes and I wonder if it's due to lack of focus. Thanks for the chat!!

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I don't think they put a ton of stock into it, honestly. At least on the position player side where, let's be honest, they don't need that long to get ready. I think you want to know what your team is and build that. Some value there. But it's not absolutely essential.

Al Tuna: Enjoy your work Jason. I feel the Pirates have gotten off to a good start this off season but I'm concerned with the lack of activity since the O'Hearn signing..3rd base remains a BIG hole in the lineup. Not sure Bob Nutting has allotted enough $ to plug holes and actually make Bucs legitimate playoff contenders. Finding a 3rd baseman that hits 20 homeruns would triple the power numbers from last year. Doesn't seem to be a big ask. Improving DH production and adding depth LH SP should be addressed. Do you share my concerns?.

Jason Mackey: They absolutely have important work to do, yes. And I'd like to see it done sooner than later, also fair. But they can still very easily trade for a 3B who hits 20-plus homers. I don't think they'

Jason Mackey: re in danger of being left behind or in a heap of trouble or anything else that might be insinuated here.

EJAV: Saw that Justin Turner is a free agent. I never hear his name mentioned. Would he be a good fit for the Pirates at third base?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: He's hardly played any third recently and had a worse year than Cutch in 2025. I'd pass.

Wayward: Jason, as always, thanks for the chats. Do you know if the Bucs have contacted any of the veteran Lefties that have been mentioned? Of the potential group who do you like best?

Jason Mackey: They have, yes. And I would go with Quintana. I think there's the least amount of risk. Really, really good dude, well-liked by everyone when he was here.

epiballo: Hi Jason, and thanks for the chats! Enjoyed your article on Reynolds. The Pirates had some momentum in signing players to help the offense, but crickets for some time. Is it that no one is available to realistically pursue, or has the money dried up?

Jason Mackey: I wouldn't say dried up, though it's less. I could still see them $105-$110M, somewhere in there.

Advertise with us

I think they're waiting on Suarez. He's making things difficult. There are also trade routes they could go. I agree they need to get moving ... but also not stupidly so, if that makes sense.

Retire21: Is it okay to root AGAINST "Cutch" coming back. If he can't play the field, his regression as a power stick can go only get worse and we need some pop at the DH.

Jason Mackey: You're allowed to do whatever you want. Here's where I'm at: I think it's personably reasonable to see both sides of this: the Pirates wanting a better lineup, Cutch believing he can still play and wanting to do it here. That's why I've been hammering the idea of a compromise: part-time DH, make 2026 it, announce that, etc.

epiballo: If the Pirates go into the season as now constructed, how does not finding a solution at third base impact them? I still think they have done enough to be competitive and can patchwork third base. Am I wrong?

Jason Mackey: If they don't add anyone else, I would imagine it's Triolo there. I expect them to talk extension with Griffin during spring, so I leave open the possibility he could be their opening day SS. Not saying it's going to happen. Just that it's possible. That could be the left side of your infield.

Advertise with us

PrinceBob: I kept meaning to read your piece about what the Pirates should do about Andrew McCutchen but never quite got to it so apologies if you've covered this. I see that Paul Zeise seems to think the Pirates really don't want to bring him back. Do you agree? And do you know if any other teams have shown any interest in signing him?

Jason Mackey: Sorry, heating up some food ... I've heard from people close to Cutch that, yes, he does have other offers. I don't know. If you do, might be the time to take one of 'em. Doesn't seem likely with the Pirates.

I think the Pirates would be open to bringing him back after a few things happen. Just not now.

epiballo: How did you interpret McCutchen's end of season comments, that the Bucs have not improved the previous three years and he wants to play on a winner? I came away thinking he planned on exploring other options and might not sign with the Bucs.

Jason Mackey: Same. I thought it was frustration talking. And also, after he said it, I thought that would probably be the end for both sides. Again, I get where he's coming from. But those and a couple other things he said signaled troubled for me.

Advertise with us

epiballo: After the latest FA signing by the Dodgers, the owners were reported to be "100%" going for a salary cap. It needs to happen, but what are the chances? All reports say the player's union is too powerful to ever think they would agree.

Jason Mackey: I still don't see it. I want it. I think the sport needs it. I've actually started following the NBA more because its finances -- with a cap -- fascinate me. MLB can have a cap and have players get rich. Look at top-tier NBA contracts. My goodness.

But, no. I think they'll prioritize getting back on the field and make only cosmetic fixes.

Bob Nutting: Am i done spending money for legitmate players?

Jason Mackey: No you are not. Keep the wallet out.

Advertise with us

RO: Do you think there’s any want from the Pirates to move Endy around the diamond a little bit this season? I feel like there’s some untapped potential there.

Jason Mackey: I think it's unlikely. They're starting by giving him a chance to catch. They still think of him as a first baseman. Maybe -- maybe -- some corner OF. But we're a couple steps down the road.

Honestly, RO, the biggest thing is that he needs to hit. I don't care what position he plays. If he doesn't produce more offensively, he's not sticking on the roster.

Butch: Whats the hold up with Suarez market? Not getting the money that he thought he would get on the open market? Or just being picky with where he lands?

Jason Mackey: I think it's what he thinks he should get when it comes to years/dollars versus what is actually available to him.

Advertise with us

epiballo: Considering the other teams in the Pirates' division, which do you think, if any, the Bucs can or have leapfrogged?

Jason Mackey: I think they're better than the Cardinals. They could be better than the Reds. They're not better than the Cubs, at least on paper. And it would be silly to bet against Milwaukee.

D9Dave: What about offering McCutchen a player/coach role for the upcoming season? There really doesn't appear to be a full-time player role available for him with the off-season changes that the team has made. This way he could appear in games in a part-time role as a player and help the team as a bench coach at the same time. Perhaps this would allow him to retire as a Pirate player and perhaps he could become a full time coach after this season.

Jason Mackey: You guys love inventing this player/coach stuff. It kinda doesn't work like that anymore. There are so many jobs for coaches and such a line of demarcation between them and players in the modern era ... just ain't happening. Plus, a lot of what the Pirates try to emphasize organizationally -- analytics, advanced data, etc. -- Cutch isn't someone who even wants a ton of info fed to him. Just an obtuse fit.

John from Cranberry: This is just me, but I hate how the Pirates rotate Brownie/Block between TV and radio, and have a million analysts. Why don't they have set booths for each? Thanks Jason!

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Hi John. They do have Brown mostly on TV, Block mostly on radio. I get it, though. Their idea is that both guys can do both. I think they want to do both. And the spin-the-wheel-of-broadcasters tends to provide for a bunch of different types of insights.

Jeff: Thanks for the chats Jason. It seems we have hit a lull in pirate news when it comes to FA. Do you believe they are finished or could we see some more additions. And specifically who would you like to see? It would be a shame to be 1-2 missing pieces away from an actual real contender

Jason Mackey: Don't think they're finished. 3B is the priority, in my mind. The more I think about it, the more I like the Mets guys: Baty and Vientos. Especially Baty.

Austin: Do you think the opening day 3B is currently on the team?

Jason Mackey: I do not.

Advertise with us

Nick Gonzales Lover: Jason im so over this cold weather. How excited are you to get to Bradenton?

Jason Mackey: You have no idea. I think about it every day. Multiple times per day. I'm done with winter. Nothing like spring training.

Matthew: Is a free agent signing or trade more likely to acquire another bat?

Jason Mackey: Trade.

jb: Favorite horror movie?

Jason Mackey: Does "Not Another Scary Movie" count? I'm sorry, I don't really watch scary movies. I mainly stick to comedies and sports. Better if they can be combined.

Adrian: I saw an ESPN article comparing Konnor Griffin to Bryce Harper and Mike Trout. Is there any momentum to him starting at SS Opening Day?

Jason Mackey: They're not in spring training, so I don't know what momentum could be defined as here. But, yes. I think there's absolutely a chance of that happening. He just has to show he's ready.

ZonaBucco: What are realistic expectations for the four catchers going into the season, including Endy Rodriguez?

Jason Mackey: I still think they could trade Joey Bart. Although the way the Cutch situation has gone, I certainly don't have to. Perhaps it's irreparable, and Bart's my DH/backup C/lefties off the bench guy.

Other than that, I think Henry is your 1C. Have to see him hit.

Flores needs to play. Endy, too. I need to see Endy hit. I'd like those two guys to battle it out in Triple-A and see what I have.

Alex: Do you think it is possible the Pirates are waiting on a Suarez decision before they proceed with their off season?

Jason Mackey: Yes, I do.

ZonaBucco: Which prospects (no MLB debut yet) besides Griffin

Jason Mackey: You could see Termarr Johnson. Esmerlyn Valdez, too. They might not be the prospects you're referencing, but remember they added a few pitchers to the 40 earlier this offseason: Bidois, Dotel, Harbin & Kelly.

Ruffsdale_Panther: Hey Jason - I appreciate the chats every week, great job with you coverage of the Pirates. Here is my thought on the starting lineup.

Jason Mackey: Thank you. Will get your next message now.

ZonaBucco: Which prospects that haven’t debuted yet, do you potentially see making an impact this season?

Ruffsdale_Panther: sorry. LF-Mangum, RH-Reynolds, DB -Lowe, O'Hearn, Horwith-DH, 3B -?; CF - Ortiz, SS - ? ; C-Davis

Jason Mackey: I don't know who Ortiz is.

I'd prolly go:

Cruz, CF

Reynolds, RF

Jason Mackey: Lowe, 2B

O'Hearn, DH

Horwitz, 1B

New 3B

Mangum, LF

Triolo, SS

Davis, C

Note: This is assuming they start Griffin in Triple-A. We'll see. A lot to learn between now and opening day.

Tyler: Favorite Bob Weir song? Also do you think Cruz has a better year at the plate? (My favorite Bob song changes but Cassidy always hits the spot)

Jason Mackey: I'll go off the board a tad: Throwing Stones. The energy with which it builds, incredible. By the end, feels like the sky is ripping open.

I do think Cruz has a better year at the plate. Tempering expectations, but he was very different at PiratesFest. If he puts it together, man. Could be something.

Yark: Hearing anything new at all?

Jason Mackey: Not much. Pretty quiet, Yark.

Yark: Do you think there will be any surprise guys to open the year in the pen? Harbin bidois devenski a signing?

Jason Mackey: Devenski would be my pick there. Those will be up, I think. Devenski is someone who could force his way on with a strong spring. Other than that, I look at it like:

Santana

Mattson

Soto

Lawrence

Montgomery

Nicolas

Mlodzinski

Ramirez

Again, maybe Sisk. Maybe Devenski. Some of the recent 40 adds.

T: Do you think the pirates are waiting for Suarez to make a decision and that is why they have not done anything since the o Hearn signing?

Jason Mackey: I don't think it's only that. But I think it is one input right now for a lot of teams, yes.

Sully: Jason your articles are wonderful and to the point. Thanks for the insight. My feeling is the pirates need a big bat to be in the world series talk.

Jason Mackey: Thank you, Sully. They definitely need a bat. Don't think that's going to ignite World Series talk. But if they would sign Suarez, I would certainly agree that they profile as a possible playoff team.

Yark: Do you think any other team would offer #22 anything more than a NRI at this point considering age recent performance and defensive ability etc?

Jason Mackey: I think they might, yeah. Like, the White Sox? Surely. But a team that's going to compete for anything in 2025? No, I don't.

Robert: Konnor Griffin has been getting a lot of comparisons to players like Bobby Witt and Mike Trout in recent prospect write ups. Have there been serious discussions internally with the Pirates and/ with Griffin's camp about an extension?

Jason Mackey: Those usually don't start until February-March, when everyone gets to spring. Right now people are soaking up the last of family time. Myself included.

Ryan: Good afternoon Jason with baseball starting soon who will lead the pirates in hits RBI’s and home runs And saves I’m going with Reynolds Cruz and Lowe and I’m going with mattson for saves even though Santana is the closer Let’s Go Bucs

Jason Mackey: Hi Ryan. I'll go with Reynolds, O'Hearn and Cruz, just to be a little different. Santana on saves. Hope you enjoy spring training!

Robert: You mentioned above that a Skenes extension is unlikely, what would need to happen to at least make it more of a possibility outside of winning of course.

Jason Mackey: Maybe Bob Nutting winning the Powerball. Twice.

Tim: Hi Jason - is there any optimism from the Pirates that Solomento will bounce back from the last two years?

Jason Mackey: I don't think it's something they're expecting based on how things are gone. That said, it is maddening. Ability is in there. As such, I'm not sure how shocked anyone would be if it happened.

Austin Bechtold: How do I work 4 hours a day with this weirdo? Please help me

Jason Mackey: Fernando Mendoza!

Ethan: May not be possible to answer this until everyone's in Bradenton but do you have the sense that the pitching staff (assuming they wanted to replace Marin for a guy who can get more out of them) feels like they got what they wanted with Bill Murphy? Still seems like a crazy good hire to me. Hard not to see what Hunter Brown has become the last two years and not have crazy high hopes for Chandler/Ashcraft/healthy Jones

Jason Mackey: I can answer that one easily. These guys are flat-out thrilled with Murphy. Man, you can tell. They love the dude. He's been in touch with a lot of them. I liked the hire when it was announced. I love it after hearing more about how Murphy operates.

WVJames: Hi Jason, not sure why I think this but I feel like an Alec Bohm addition ( if possible) would be a better fit than Suarez. Thoughts?

Jason Mackey: Depends on what you would have to give up, but I think I agree with you. If the acquisition cost is small, I'm cool with it. That said, if they could Suarez for 2x17, I'd do that in a heartbeat. I just don't think that gets a deal done.

Tori: Where do Endy and Flores fit on this team?

Jason Mackey: Probably Triple-A to start, then earning their way to the big club if they actually hit.

Flores would be ahead of Endy and could start with the MLB team if the Pirates wind up trading Joey Bart.

Mark: Hi Jason. I was reading a story about Horwitz on MLB and he talked about the possibility of playing 2B. I was surprised. Have you heard that? Thanks.

Jason Mackey: Not surprised. I mentioned it in my story that ran a couple days before. He talked about it Saturday. He played one game there in '25, 39 I believe in '24. He's comfortable at 2B.

Chris: Have you heard any concrete changes Bill Murphy has planned? Ex. Any pitchers going to ditch pitch X and focus on Y?

Jason Mackey: Not that concrete, no. It's more about relationship-building at this point. That's stuff that's way more prevalent in spring.

Chris: Any chance the pirates are worried about upsetting cutch with their offer? Like they want him back at league minimum, or ask him to sign mid-season?

Jason Mackey: No, that's not the issue.

Douggy18: Houston needs a backup catcher: would a deal including Joey Bart, Thomas Harrington and Termarr Johnson be enough to get Isaac Parades?

Jason Mackey: That would make a lot of sense, Douggy18. Don't know if it gets done. I'm not Houston. But I'd imagine that at least gets the convo going. (I don't like trading more pitching, though. I'd try to lessen the arm I give up; someone in High-A or something.)

Frank. Slippery Rock: More of a Pirate Organization question but are the Pirates still planning on opening the area next to the ballpark which would provide an atmosphere before games, including a large screen TV .Keep up the fine work!

Jason Mackey: I believe so. Was there a few days ago, however, and it looks like there's still a lot of work to do.

sxm319: I see the Pirates clinching the NL Central by end of August. Am I too bullish on this revamped roster?

Jason Mackey: What makes you think it'll take them that long? Hater.

JohnG: Jason, love your work on the Buccos'; now that Bichette signed with the Mets instead of Philly potentially taking Bohm out of the race, why would they not go all in For Suarez! Will definitely make an inpact and what are the Bucs afraid of paying a bit more to get their guy? Your thoughts. TY

Jason Mackey: I don't think they're going to go all-in the way you described, John. Honestly, I think Bichette could open up options like Baty and Vientos more than direct them to Suarez.

Mike Shutlock: Hope all is well Jason. I just saw something about J Jones being traded to Houston for their 3B. 8 know we have to give to get another legit bat but I'd really hate to lose JJ in order to do it. If he comes back healthy, I think there's a whole lot left in his tank

Jason Mackey: I'd be stunned if they traded Jared Jones. So much potential. Also coming off injury, one of Skenes' best friends? Are you sure you aren't confusing him with Thomas Harrington?

Epiballo: Is Gregory Polanco out of baseball? ‘Monty Python and the Holy Grail’ - best comedy ever?

Jason Mackey: I think he's still over in Japan. And, no. It's funny but come on? Dumb & Dumber is the best comedy ever.

MK: Jason, as a self proclaimed baseball nerd, any recommendations on Pirates/baseball focused books or documentaries?

Jason Mackey: A ton. How much time you got? On my desk right now is "The Baseball 100," by Joe Posnanski. Really like "K: A History of Baseball in 10 Pitches" by Tyler Kepner. My 7-year-old son is carrying around "Homegrown: How the Red Sox Built a Champion from the Ground Up" because he's a huge nerd. Ha. "The Grind," by Barry Svrluga is awesome. You might laugh, but I recommend Jason Kendall's book a lot. "Throwback: A Big-League Catcher Tells How the Game Is Really Played."

Sammy Kalifa: Jason- if you had to bet your next paycheck that the Pirates make the playoffs this year, are you betting yes or no?

Jason Mackey: What are my odds?

Ruckdog: Thanks for these weekly chats: I always enjoy your insights!

Jason Mackey: Thanks, Ruckdog. Pleasure is all mine.

Mike Shutlock: It was on Bucs Dugout today so I take it with a grain of salt

Jason Mackey: I'm not taking shots. I'm just saying, I really don't think that's very likely.

Ruckdog: Do you see the 3B of the future in the top 30 prospect list?

Jason Mackey: I do not. I think it's more likely they add that guy via trade.

Jlmm: Does Cutch realize he would be taking the roster spot of a younger player who might be lost to waivers.

Jason Mackey: I'm not sure given what Andrew has accomplished in the game, that it should be a concern. He deserves to have a retirement year. I'm fine with that. But he has to say that or agree to that. Doesn't have anything to do with younger players. They still have the flexibility.

Mike Shutlock: I feel better now because I thought it was a really bad move if that were the case!

Jason Mackey: Someone asked about Harrington, Termarr & Bart. That would make more sense. Although if I'm GMBC, I'm trying to direct them to a pitcher in the lower levels of the minors, even if I have to give up more potential to do it.

Epiballo: ‘The Baseball Codes: the Unwritten Rules of Americas Pastime’ is my favorite baseball book. Have you read it?

Jason Mackey: I have not, but it sounds excellent. I love that stuff. Spring training is a great time to get some reading done. Thank you for the rec.

Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it for this week. Thanks so much for participating. Great chat. Let's do this again next Thursday. Then the week after that FROM FLORIDA! Stay warm.