When the Colorado Rockies placed Justin Lawrence on waivers early last March, the right-handed reliever thought they might’ve done so to give him enough time to settle in with a new team.
That happened with the Pirates, as the 31-year-old late-bloomer produced downright dominant numbers when he was healthy, creating the possibility that they may have discovered a diamond in the rough.
The funny part was how long — or short — that initial strategizing session seemed to take.
Sounds like about 30 seconds.
“They told me, ‘Hey, you have two really good pitches. Throw them down the middle, and you’re going to have success,’” Lawrence recalled Saturday during PiratesFest at David L. Lawrence Convention Center. “That changed my mindset on pitching and attacking hitters.”
Maybe sometimes baseball really isn’t that complicated.
Read More
Although his season was interrupted for four months due to right elbow inflammation, when healthy, Lawrence simplified his approach and was essentially unhittable over 17 appearances.
It was enough to make him one of the more intriguing back-end options for the Pirates as they sort out their bullpen mix in 2026, with Lawrence pitching to a 0.51 ERA in 17 2/3 innings, walking eight, striking out 23 and allowing just one earned run.
When Lawrence talked about what worked for him, what led to those gaudy numbers, the answer wasn’t overly complex.
It was the belief the Pirates showed in him. And it may have turned around his career, from someone with a 5.43 ERA the past four years in Colorado to someone manager Don Kelly has trusted with late-game situations, as well as a pitcher with the stuff to handle himself there.
“It helped me regain confidence in myself, and that’s the biggest thing for me,” Lawrence said. “I debuted a little bit older and was up and down my first couple years.
“My last year in Colorado [6.49 ERA in 56 games] didn’t go the way I wanted. So, kind of having the success that I did in 2025, I believe I can play this game a lot longer. That’s what I hope happens. Hopefully it’s here.”
It’s a fascinating story and also one essential for small-market teams building bullpens — identifying players in other organizations and either using them differently or helping them improve.
With Lawrence, however, it didn’t involve an additional pitch learned or gigantic mechanical tweaks. The Pirates helped him trust his (already very good) stuff and have the confidence to throw it over the plate.
The recipe started with Lawrence’s sweeper, one of the better pitches on the staff and something he used 50% of the time in 2025. Hitters had an .086 batting average against it, as well as a .114 slugging percentage. Those are laughably small. Its whiff rate (40.0%) was also outstanding.
It essentially became a frisbee Lawrence could land in the zone, one opposing hitters couldn’t touch, and the byproduct became better sinker numbers because hitters had to honor the threat of the sweeper.
Averaging 95 mph with a pitch that has seen a gradual drop in arm angle over the years, Lawrence saw his sinker go from one of the 20 worst pitches in baseball (minus-18 run value in 2024, per Baseball Savant) to something that actually performed reasonably well.
Its run value was a middle-of-the-road 4, while Lawrence saw his sinker’s slugging percentage against drop from .629 to .368. Yes, leaving Coors Field had something to do that. But so did the return of his confidence, trusting his stuff was good enough to challenge hitters.
“Just going out there and saying, ‘Here it is, do what you can with it,’” Lawrence said. “I had some success with that, so hopefully I’ll be able to put that together for 70-plus innings this year.”
It could be a sneaky important part of the Pirates’ 2026 season — the performance of their bullpen and specifically what becomes of Lawrence.
Does he stay healthy and function as a dominant setup man alongside Gregory Soto, Isaac Mattson and maybe one or two others? Or was the small sample size, interrupted by a not-insignificant arm issue, simply a mirage?
The Pirates are obviously betting the former, as they avoided arbitration with Lawrence by agreeing to a one-year, $1.225 million contract with him for 2026.
Lawrence has been talking regularly with new pitching coach Bill Murphy about where and how he found success last season and how to find even more this upcoming season, leading him to believe that 2025 might’ve only been a start.
“The short stint I had last year was good, but we sat there and talked for over an hour and had a presentation about things that can make me better,” Lawrence said. “In my career before, it’s always been go out there and perform, do what you gotta do to get outs and stuff like that.
“But to have success and then have somebody in your corner saying, ‘Hey, this is how we can actually make you better.’ It’s really exciting.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.