There won’t be any gold for the Pirates this season.
Jared Triolo and Tommy Pham both came up short in their quests to win Rawlings Gold Gloves on Sunday night — the first of those a surprise considering Triolo put up numbers proving he was worthy of being a repeat winner.
Instead, Miami’s Javier Sanoja was honored as the winner among NL utilitymen, this despite Triolo leading the finalists with nine defensive runs saved (per FanGraphs).
Triolo was attempting to become the Pirates’ first repeat Gold Glove winner since Starling Marte in 2015-16.
After spending most of his time at third base in 2024, shortstop was Triolo’s most frequently played position this past season.
He started 44 games there, appeared in 47 and logged 388⅔ innings. It wasn’t Triolo’s best position — he accumulated 10 defensive runs saved (FanGraphs) at third and second compared to minus-2 at shortstop — but the value became true versatility.
Read More
He can legitimately play anywhere — and well.
Looking at Baseball Savant’s numbers, Triolo tied the other finalist, Miguel Rojas of the Dodgers, with a fielding run value of 5. Traditionally speaking, Triolo made just eight errors across 845 defensive innings.
The issue with Triolo, of course, isn’t his defense or versatility. He needs to hit.
That didn’t happen earlier this season, and Triolo was optioned to Triple-A Indianapolis on July 11. The move worked. It allowed Triolo to tweak his setup and discover more power. He hit .276 with a .775 OPS from Aug. 1 on.
It goes without saying the Pirates will need that version of Triolo, whether he plays shortstop, third or bounces around again.
Last season, Triolo became the 21st Pirate to win a Gold Glove. Overall, the franchise has 52. Roberto Clemente holds the franchise record for the most Gold Gloves with 12.
Pham, who had a redemptive defensive year and also fought his way out of a slow start at the plate, couldn’t edge out Mt. Lebanon’s Ian Happ for the Gold Glove in left field.
Pham, 37, ranked second among NL left fielders in DRS with 5, trailing Happ (9) by a fairly wide margin. Happ has now won the past four such awards.
Pham’s candidacy was lessened by metrics related to his FRV (per Baseball Savant) and FanGraphs’ calculation of defensive runs above/below average.
Still, the eye test for Pham was solid. He played the best left field we’ve seen since Corey Dickerson won a Gold Glove in 2018, and Pham showed his 2024 (minus-10 DRS) was a fluke.
Pham’s now a free agent after his $4.025 million contract expired with the conclusion of the World Series. He was worth 1.0 win above replacement, justifying the expense.
Former Pirate Ke’Bryan Hayes won the second Gold Glove of his career and his first since 2023.
Traded to the Reds on July 30, Hayes was worth 21 outs above average, according to Baseball Savant. That ranked second among all National League fielders, regardless of position.
His fielding run value of plus-17 was third, while only two AL fielders had more defensive runs saved (FanGraphs) than Hayes, who had 19.
The Pirates did wind up with one winner — on the minor league side. Konnor Griffin won the MiLB Gold Glove for his work at shortstop, as he made just seven errors in 89 games.
Griffin this past week was recognized as the Pirates’ minor league player of the year (Honus Wagner Award) and their defensive player of the year (Bill Mazeroski Award) for their annual farm system awards.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.