This is Part 5 of a five-part series in which the Post-Gazette will evaluate the Pirates on a position-by-position basis. Part 1 (the outfield), Part 2 (the infield), Part 3 (catchers and designated hitter) and Part 4 (starting pitching) have been published. Part 5 focuses on the bullpen. Each part can also be viewed on the Post-Gazette Pirates YouTube channel.
Trending up
Despite some rough stretches, the Pirates’ bullpen was generally a positive in 2025. However, after losing a few pieces at the deadline and with several pitchers likely to move back into the starting rotation, tweaks will be needed for the bullpen to remain a strength in 2026.
The Pirates bullpen finished with a 3.83 ERA, 13th in baseball, and 5.1 fWAR, tied for eighth in baseball. Pirate relievers kept homers (0.86 per nine innings, 6th in baseball) and walks (3.26/9, eighth best) down. The Pirates were 53-9 when leading after six innings, 56-5 when leading after seven innings and 61-1 when leading after eight innings, all signs of a successful bullpen.
The bullpen was led from the back. David Bednar was excellent in between his return from Triple-A and his trade to the Yankees, posting a 2.37 ERA and a run of 23 consecutive appearances without an earned run that earned him the National League’s reliever of the month award in June. After a disastrous first ninth inning, Dennis Santana proved a capable replacement, finishing with a 1.90 ERA from Aug. 3 onward and a 2.18 ERA overall. Santana was great in leverage, but also showed he could be the closer. He’ll be in his final year of arbitration before free agency.
Isaac Mattson was an extremely pleasant surprise. Mattson appeared in 44 games for the Pirates and had a 2.45 ERA and 45 strikeouts in 47 ⅔ innings. Opponents batted .191 against his four-seam fastball, even with Mattson using it almost 80% of the time. That pitch was the third-most valuable pitch on the Pirates, per Baseball Savant, behind only Paul Skenes’ four-seamer and sweeper.
Carmen Mlodzinski was also stellar after moving back to the bullpen, where he’d had success in 2023 and 2024. Mlodzinski finished with a 3.55 ERA — 5.67 in his first nine appearances, all starts, then 2.12 in his next 25 appearances as a multi-inning reliever. Braxton Ashcraft, Mike Burrows and Bubba Chandler were also impressive in similar roles, although all are viewed as starters moving forward.
Read More
Justin Lawrence looks like an intriguing waiver wire claim, as he had a 0.51 ERA in 17 appearances before and after an elbow injury. Dauri Moreta and Chase Shugart were also solid, although both spent time with Triple-A Indianapolis. Kyle Nicolas, another who spent time in the minors, was prone to blowup outings but held opponents scoreless in 13 of his final 15 appearances.
The bullpen performed well in 2025, but assuming Ashcraft, Burrows and Chandler are all viewed as starters, there will be plenty of production to replace in 2026.
Trending down
Losing Bednar did hurt the Pirates bullpen, even if Santana was capable in the ninth. The Pirates had a 3.70 ERA before the trade deadline, ninth in baseball, and a 4.05 ERA after, 15th in baseball. That number includes data from true starters like Ashcraft, Burrows and Chandler, all of whom appeared in relief in the final months of the season.
The Pirates entered the season with four lefties in the bullpen — Caleb Ferguson, Ryan Borucki, Tim Mayza and Joey Wentz — and ended the year with none of them. Hunter Barco threw three scoreless innings in two relief appearances, but Evan Sisk, the likelier lefty to start the year in Pittsburgh’s ’pen, had a 4.38 ERA in 14 big league appearances after being acquired in the Bailey Falter deal. Finding a lefty is an offseason necessity.
While Bednar found his form, fellow leverage reliever Colin Holderman never found his. Holderman finished with a 7.01 ERA, with opponents hitting .327 against him. Yohan Ramirez also struggled, ending the year with a 5.40 ERA despite his impressive strikeout numbers. Both Ramirez and Holderman are likely non-tender candidates this offseason.
The Pirates bullpen finished the year 22nd in strikeouts per nine and 19th in expected ERA. Some of that is expected when your best reliever, Santana, relies on soft contact, but it could also show regression is possible.
Offseason storylines
The Pirates have bigger needs — offense, first and foremost — but the bullpen could use some reinforcement. They need at least one lefty besides Sisk, someone who can handle leverage spots besides Santana and Mattson, and ideally someone else who can handle multiple innings like Mlodzinski.
Fortunately for the Pirates, there’s always plenty of relief help on the market. Former closers Ryan Helsley, Devin Williams and Kirby Yates are available, if the Pirates want to buy low on someone with experience, while Nick Martinez could also be a fit. Steven Matz and Andrew Chafin are two of the top lefties, and Matz could fill a multi-inning role.
Santana, Holderman, Ramirez, Moreta and Lawrence are all arbitration-eligible, with Santana, Moreta and Lawrence as the likeliest to return.
Prospects to know
The Pirates have a few intriguing minor league arms that could help the bullpen in 2026.
Chief among them is Brandan Bidois, named Wednesday as the Pirates’ Kent Tekulve minor league reliever of the year. Bidois, a 24-year-old right-hander from Australia, had a 0.74 ERA in 40 appearances this year between Low-A Bradenton and Triple-A Indianapolis, including a stretch of 18 consecutive hitless innings. Bidois is Rule 5 eligible this offseason.
Eddy Yean, Triple-A Indianapolis’s fireman of the year award winner, is a minor league free agent after going 8-5 with a 3.06 ERA in 70 ⅔ innings. Antwone Kelly, a starter at Double-A Altoona, is also Rule 5 eligible and could be claimed, especially if teams see his 5-foot-10 frame and triple digit fastball and decide to use him as a big league reliever.
Number to know
95.3 - The Pirate bullpen’s average four-seam fastball velocity, a top-10 mark in baseball
Three key questions
1. Which relievers will the Pirates keep in arbitration? Will any Rule 5-eligible pitchers be protected?
2. What will the Pirates target in free agency?
3. How can the Pirates build a good bullpen in a full year without David Bednar?






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.